I admit i didn't read all 33 pages of this thread.
As far as im concerned im kinda 50/50 on this one. Post Crisis Superman isn't THAT strong anymore, but they toned down everyone so he's still in DC's big league. As for Hulk, even though he can regenerate from ANYTHING, and has possibly unlimited strenght, he can still be ko'ed. Not many in the Marvel universe could do it, hearth based characters i mean. Juggy, Abobination, Absorbing man, Thor, Thing...These guys "could" do it, but the odds are against them. Surfer took on the Hulk once and had to throw him into space to end the fight, where Hulk just waited. Kinda like how Thor pooped his pants facing Juggernaut and sent him in a portal...yeah, boring but legit.
In my opinion, Hulk is comparable to Doomsday's first apparition, the one that took out Supes but died in the process. BUT Doomsday is faster than Superman...which is nothing to sneez at.
Also, a pissed off Superman ain't no boy scout either, He might not have Hulk's unlimited Strenght, but like any humain being, with adrenaline and sheer rage he gets a boost. If he decided to let it all out and disregarde the fact that Hulk is human...
Know what? The only way to really tell would be to kill Lois Lane and tell Supes Hulk did it and kill Betty Ross and tell Hulk Supes did it...now THAT would show us both characters at their best!
Bottom line, ill give this one to Supes 7 out of 10 times.