Captain America versus Daredevil!!!

Hmmmmm. I'm a bit of a fanboy of both of these characters...

I'ma go with DD on this one. Cap's shield is worthless. DD can sense exactly where the thing is going with his radar sense no matter how many times the thing rebounds off of walls and the floor. And considering that pic posted of DD whacking Cap with his own shield, I'm pretty sure Cap would remember that and just drop the thing and go toe-to-toe with DD.

I believe Cap is slightly stronger and faster and more agile than DD. I mean, he does have the utmost peak of human abilities in all those areas. DD is a regular human, highly trained and extremely close to peak human, but not more. I think he looks more agile because he can react to things faster on a mental and instinctual level than other people because of his radar sense. Either way, Cap's small physical advantage is essentially negated by DD's radar sense.

Who's the better fighter? Hmmm. Marvel's rating system is garbage. DD is clearly a 7 like Cap. I just happen to think that they'd both get a couple of shots in, but DD would take advantage of pressure points and his radar sense to end the fight.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Hmmmmm. I'm a bit of a fanboy of both of these characters...

I'ma go with DD on this one. Cap's shield is worthless. DD can sense exactly where the thing is going with his radar sense no matter how many times the thing rebounds off of walls and the floor. And considering that pic posted of DD whacking Cap with his own shield, I'm pretty sure Cap would remember that and just drop the thing and go toe-to-toe with DD.

I believe Cap is slightly stronger and faster and more agile than DD. I mean, he does have the utmost peak of human abilities in all those areas. DD is a regular human, highly trained and extremely close to peak human, but not more. I think he looks more agile because he can react to things faster on a mental and instinctual level than other people because of his radar sense. Either way, Cap's small physical advantage is essentially negated by DD's radar sense.

Who's the better fighter? Hmmm. Marvel's rating system is garbage. DD is clearly a 7 like Cap. I just happen to think that they'd both get a couple of shots in, but DD would take advantage of pressure points and his radar sense to end the fight.

I agree almost completely with you.

I do believe that DD wins, but I also believe he is just a little more agile and quicker (not faster) than Cap. But yea, Cap has the strenght, speed, and endurance going for him.

DD's radar sense is pretty much what wins him this fight.

I had to bring this thread back up because of the recent Captain America vs Spider-Man thread and the recent Spider-Man vs Daredevil thread.

Regarding DD vs CA, circumstances would dominate. 5/10 for either, depending.

What kinda bothers/confuses me though, is how Spider-Man appears to be regarded as being on the same level as these two. Spider-Man is unambiguously, clearly superhuman in so many ways, yet in the Versus threads either Cap or DD are presented as rough equals to him. I don't agree. It makes me wanna ask: well then what is the point of the spider-powers, if a human-perfection serum or radar-sense puts opponents on par?

Just for the hell of it, consider his strength (just as an example). Spider-Man can lift/press (minimally?) 10 tens. The average man can military press about 100 pounds. This makes SM some 200 times stronger than your average joe. Even if Cap can lift 1000 pounds, SM is still 20 times stronger. This is a huge difference. Add to that his proportionately as powerful speed and agility, reflexes, instinctive manner of fighting and that ever-popular spider-sense, plus his own experience and intelligence...IMHO, Spider-Man is at least a solid notch above CA or DD. BTW, I'm not a fanboy; just trying to see this from a gut-level feeling.

Certainly, any of the above mentioned could do SM harm, given the right circumstances. But all else being equal, something just seems amiss here: jobber aura, PIS, whatever.

great fight but cap takes it, hes not in top 5 heros of marvel for nothing

bump

Originally posted by peejayd
* i think DD wins...

Yeah thats pretty much how it should go.

DD takes a slight majority for me.

Both are close in terms of abilities. Cap has an advantage in terms of speed, agility, strength but Daredevil isn't far enough behind for that to matter too much.

Both are pretty equal in terms of fighting skills. Cap specializing in his own form of judo and Daredevil in his own asian and boxing mix.

Unbreakable shield vs Unbreakable sticks. I'd say Daredevil has an advantage here. Cap's shield won't hit Daredevil no matter how many times it bounces off of stuff. Daredevil on the other hand can have those clubs bounce round for days before they hit their target and Cap doesn't have the luxury of super senses.

Then its Cap's stamina vs Daredevil's skills. Cap can conceivably last for as long as it takes to win, but Daredevil can dodge, parry and reverse Cap's attacks as well as locate his weak points. If Daredevil is using his senses to their fullest he can get this win. DD 6/10

daredevil can't even see him, lol, jk. naw but seriously though, i think that cap would take it 8/10

In Born Again, DD pretty much said that Cap was leagues ahead of him physically. I say that Cap will win the majority, maybe 6/10, but it'll be a close fight.

Daredevil wins this IMO, not by much though. 6/10. and its only because of his radar sense in which he'd predict all of caps moves before he even does it, thus putting DD always one step above the cap so he can counter blows, and then maybe come with a nerve strike. it'd be close though, cuz Caps endurance would be hard to work through, and his superior reflexes would almost nearly be enough to keep up w/ DD's radar sense, but not quite. not to mention, hes far stronger than DD via SS serum which puts him one step above peak human. DD takes this though, good fight.

Originally posted by Milkie

Daredevil wins this one. DD has superhuman heightened senses, and can dodge and avoid every of Cap's attacks. Cap has the peak human strength, endurance, etc...but so what, DD is pretty strong, and has near superhuman endurance.

Originally posted by JediMasterLuke5
Cap wins, he's a better fighter and is stronger.

And he is smarter. Cap should win every time. DD could get a lucky shot, so I'll give Cap just 19/20.

Originally posted by Milkie

Milkie, this video is hilarious, although, it makes absolutely no sense......... Kind of like Aquateen.

Actually I change that. DD can't get him ever!!!!!!

Captain America wins 100% of the time, he is too heavy for DD, and can easily match DD in the speed department, cap has the better weapon, and is far superior in fighting.

Hmm.....

Cap, just.

6/10

Originally posted by Etrigan
Hmm.....

Cap, just.

6/10

Daredevil 6/10. The senses will give him the razor thin edge he'll need to pull a majority. Captain America will give him hell everytime though. It may even be a draw.