Sidious - The Debate

Indeed.

Originally posted by Borbarad
How much "electrical" power you think does that ship have to generate in order to rip the core of a star off, carry it through the galaxy and then throw it at other people, eh ?

And why did other people trying to use the "technological" power of that ship die in the process if it has nothing to do with the personal power of the user ?

It's STAR WARS...how much fuel do you think a star destroyer would have? Oh, and noone ever ripped the core of a star out minus Aleema...the Denarii was just blown up, that's it...and Aleema threw the Cron star a veeeery short distance.

Oh, and could Aleema and Crado dying have to do with Kun not warning them what they were gonna do would cause the other stars in the cluster to blow up, vaporizing their ship as well as the enemy? Yep. They died because Kun tricked them

Naga threw it too, how Naga threw it requires more energy then Sidious doing his force storm stunt.

He never threw it. *Checks again* Nope, no throwing, it just exploded. There's not throwing involved. Prove there was, please. And he used the ship, I've provided ample quotes and evidence now

The only way we can sort this out is by having scans done of the pages. Then we will know who is lying and who is not.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
It's STAR WARS...how much fuel do you think a star destroyer would have? Oh, and noone ever ripped the core of a star out minus Aleema...the Denarii was just blown up, that's it...and Aleema threw the Cron star a veeeery short distance.

Oh, and could Aleema and Crado dying have to do with Kun not warning them what they were gonna do would cause the other stars in the cluster to blow up, vaporizing their ship as well as the enemy? Yep. They died because Kun tricked them

It's nice how the ability of that nice organ between you ears seems to end with "reading".
And if all you detailed studying of the functioning of SW weapons haven't made you spot the logical errors in you theories I surely can't help you either.

If I had a scanner, I would. I'll ask TFN if they've got any

The quotes are wrong. Logic, reason, and math prove that.

Yes, he did throw it at the Republic ships because otherwise his own ship would have been consumed by the explosion, as it expands faster then his ship can travel. He had to throw it away from him.

It's nice how the same technological weapon seems to work different on two ocassions. When Sadow uses it, it simply detonates planets. When Aleema uses it, it suddenly rips the core of stars off and throws it into a certain direction.

And it's also nice how Sadow uses "the power that this ship has left" to do something with it and it has generated some new power mysteriously thousand years later.

ARGH ! 😮‍💨

The quotes are wrong? Yeah, post scans then.

Funny how you guys ignore Kun had found it again and apparently 'refilled' it. And if Sadow 'threw' it, why wasn't the entire Republic fleet destroyed instead of three ships? Even more curious was that by the time it exploded, he'd escaped into hyperspace. The only people who saw that were his pursuers who were vaporized immediately after.

Because only 3 ships were following him at this point. If he could have escaped into hyperspace, the Republic ships could have too. He didn't because you can go into hyperspace near a star and he was.

You have access to the chronology, hm? Turn to page nineteen. Can we read 'star destroying weapon?' Flip open to the comic 'The Sith War' And 'Downfall of the Sith Empire' turn to the sections of Sadow's escape and when Kun gives Aleema the ship....read it right there. I'm losing nothing by giving you all this, so find it

Originally posted by Lightsnake
The quotes are wrong? Yeah, post scans then.

Funny how you guys ignore Kun had found it again and apparently 'refilled' it. And if Sadow 'threw' it, why wasn't the entire Republic fleet destroyed instead of three ships? Even more curious was that by the time it exploded, he'd escaped into hyperspace. The only people who saw that were his pursuers who were vaporized immediately after.

Yeah. Kun simply "refilled" it. Sure.
I love people to whom "LOGIC" is just a five letter word starting with "L".

Just think one moment about it: For you there is more "logic" behind assuming that the ship is completely technology which doesn't have any connection to the force. It's just another superweapon. Now it keeps working in different ways and somehow it can be "refilled" by somebody who doesn't basically know anything about the technology used in it.

And you really want to tell us that this is more logical than the explanation that this ship (with all the nice little chrystals and stuff like that in it) just works as a focus or amplifier for it's users force powers which seems to be the more accurate explanation since we're dealing with Sith, Sith magic and stuff like that here - some "science" that entire goal it seems to be to make people stronger using artifacts, chrystals and stuff like that ?

So can you tell me why a force user is needed to operate it when it's "just technology" ? No ? Great...

The supernova was his scapegoat. when the smoke died, Teta thought he'd died in the explosion when he used it to escape. He'd prepared for it and the republic ships didn't, that simple.

Now, I'm off to work, continue this later

Hey, Brando, why don't you offer a better explanation? Why don't you get up, read a bit, then come back and try to argue when you know what the hell we're talking about. Kun had the damn thing along with a LOT of dark side artifacts for a LONG time. And the ship is used with the Dark Side, so? a lot of ancient Sith technology was as well. Golden Age of the Sith had Ludo operating a ship with the Dark Side. Care to explain why the ship's control center is just a giant crystal? No? Okay.

Now, I'm off

Still doesn't show why the ship could do what you say it could.

OMfg Sidious would own Naga shadow or any of these loosers.

LOL U NUB! PROVIDE TEH PROOF!

sysph noob. Ive been here longer then you!!

Yeah, but I'm Der Sturmer. Where the hell is Ush, this guy is obviously a Jackstein sock! Like Glentract!