I have MSN, it's in my profile...I'm sorry I'm not replying in full now, but there are some issues going on so I'm....really not in a mood to do a huge response.
All I'll say is Juyo was totally incomplete until Mace and Sora developed Vaapad. And while both are aggressive, force use couldn't be more different.
Mace had also fought for most his life and was one of the great lightsaber fights. You're confusing bad choreography with character choices, otherwise after the spin, Sidious would've taken off Mace's legs. And the little smile before he zaps Mace was described as 'satisfied.' Malak would at least be caught off guard by Sidious using a style that turns his own power in the darkside around him and switching off styles.