Captain America vs Batman(no shield-no gadgets)

Started by Deadline220 pages
Originally posted by Caps Conscience
You are easily one of the best debaters on this board, keep it up. 👆

Now you've done it, sranks heads gonna explode.

Batman wins 5/10.

Deadline is my sock account, but he's grown self aware. Ban him Bada, just to be safe. 😎

Originally posted by srankmissingnin
Deadline is my sock account, but he's grown self aware.

😑

Captain America would beat Batman in a h2h fight and in general in my opinion. Captain America is the furthest that a human can level up to without becoming a super powered character. He is Batman's superior. Cap never tires, is super fast and is way stronger than Batman. On top of that. Cap is a tactical genius in h2h combat and battle strategies. In the Marvel/DC cross over they made Batman win but that is totally BS like when King Kong beat Godzilla when they met.

What the hell is wrong with some of you on here? Batman is just a regular guy in very good physical condition while Captain America is at the top of the totem pole regarding a human being. No way is Batman as strong as Captain America... NO WAY. Comic books and history can clearly show and tell you that.

Originally posted by LetsbeREAL
What the hell is wrong with some of you on here? Batman is just a regular guy in very good physical condition while Captain America is at the top of the totem pole regarding a human being. No way is Batman as strong as Captain America... NO WAY. Comic books and history can clearly show and tell you that.

Cap may be stronger but he is not way stronger. Bats got feats that are super human as well.

Cap does tire.
Batman is the better fighter IMO
Both have similar speed and reflexes.

Cap wins 7/10

Really mastered over 140 styles of fightin lol he must have a lot of spare time. Cap wins, cap is faster, stronger and one punch lands on bats he's out cold turkey style.

Originally posted by scyven
Really mastered over 140 styles of fightin lol he must have a lot of spare time. Cap wins, cap is faster, stronger and one punch lands on bats he's out cold turkey style.

Ok Cap does win but let's be honest. One punch isn't taking Bats out. Bats has tanked super human blows on multiple occasions.

Cap isn't really faster (combat speed).

Cap is stronger but not by a lot.

Bats IMO is the slightly better fighter. Cap is awesome with the shield though.

I think a fair assessment is Cap 7/10

Batman ain't bench pressing 1200LBs and Cap doesn't tire. Batman is a normal man, Cap is enhanced. Batman won the cross over and I do like Batman a whole lot but Captain America should have won that fight.

Originally posted by LetsbeREAL
Batman ain't bench pressing 1200LBs and Cap doesn't tire. Batman is a normal man, Cap is enhanced. Batman won the cross over and I do like Batman a whole lot but Captain America should have won that fight.
actually cap won

I think he's talking about the Marvel vs DC fight.

They both lose to Judge Dredd.

Originally posted by LetsbeREAL
Batman ain't bench pressing 1200LBs and Cap doesn't tire. Batman is a normal man, Cap is enhanced. Batman won the cross over and I do like Batman a whole lot but Captain America should have won that fight.
Batman has strength feats in far excess of 1200lb.
IMO, Batman will win a straight fight against CA (gadgets vs. shield) but he is losing a majority in pure h2h.

Cap does tire.

Originally posted by h1a8
Batman has strength feats in far excess of 1200lb.

prove it.

Originally posted by h1a8

Cap isn't really faster (combat speed).

Cap is stronger but not by a lot.

Bats IMO is the slightly better fighter. Cap is awesome with the shield though.

I think a fair assessment is Cap 7/10


Yes he is. DS who capt physical equal is directly represented as faster stronger ect then Batmna. Why on earth you would pretend Capt not faster is beyond me.

No capt is significantly stronger. Capt has better strength feats and more consistent by far.

No he not at all, and even writer has come out say capt better fighter.

I don;t there really no reason to give Batman a chance in h2h.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Yes he is. DS who capt physical equal is directly represented as faster stronger ect then Batmna. Why on earth you would pretend Capt not faster is beyond me.

No capt is significantly stronger. Capt has better strength feats and more consistent by far.

No he not at all, and even writer has come out say capt better fighter.

I don;t there really no reason to give Batman a chance in h2h.

Capt isn't the better fighter. Crossover is not canon and characters words are meaningless if it contradicts on panel evidence.

Batman has strength feats that are far beyond human potential (super human strength feats). Thus he is not much weaker than CA.

CA isn't faster in combat than Batman. I would say they are equals in this dept. Bat is slightly the better fighter. CA seems like he is because of the shield. But this fight is without his shield.

Cap is a better fighter, Cap is a lot stronger than Batman there is no comparison, the man fights demigods and holds his own, Batman track record with enhance humans is not that great. Speed Cap is so much faster is not even funny, and his fighting experience eclipse Batman, in the Korvac saga Cap was trained in alien art form and gain 100 yrs of experience. Batman will give Cap Hell, can he beat Cap no, eventually Cap blows will be to much for Batman to over come!?

When Deathstroke fought Batman hewas caught off guard by Batman surprise attack, with in minutes DS knock his a$$ out with three punches and DS is Cap's equal.

People who are still trying to make it out like Captain America is not superior to Batman physically is in denial. I like Batman and think he is one of the, if not THEE best hero in DC BUT if you compare their abilities it clearly shows that Captain America is stronger, faster and more durable. Batman is in great condition and is an excellent fighter but Captain America is just better.

"The Super Soldier Serum enhances all of Captain America's metabolic functions and prevents the build-up of fatigue poisons in his muscles, giving him endurance far in excess of an ordinary human being."

Batman is an ordinary human being. Case should be closed.

Originally posted by LetsbeREAL
Why are some people still trying to make it out like Captain America is not superior to Batman physically is beyond me. I like Batman and think he is one of the, if not THE best hero in DC BUT if you compare their abilities it clearly shows that Captain America is stronger, faster and more durable. Batman is in great condition and is an execallent fighter but Captain America is just better.

"The Super Soldier Serum enhances all of Captain America's metabolic functions and prevents the build-up of fatigue poisons in his muscles, giving him endurance far in excess of an ordinary human being."

Batman is an ordinary human being. Case should be closed.

Batman is only ordinary in definition, as he has no enhancements. His feats however suggest differently.