Captain America vs Batman(no shield-no gadgets)

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Let me put all the speculation to an end.

Batman is a master of 127 different form of martial arts. Taking all that he has mastered and putting it in to one. Making him a more effective fighter and martial artist than captain America. Because instead of batman taking all the effective martial arts and forming a new style. He could take only the most basic, important thing from each of the 127 arts that he knows and form an art that is more fluid in its movement and firm in combat.

Batman has taken beatings from super-powered beings and he is still hear to tell the tail. Like the beating batman got from superman when he thought that batman was darksied. How about the time when batman was dressed up as brainac. Or how about the beating he got from Mongul. Batman is one tough GUY. Being more powerful that him does not automatically give who ever it is the win.

Batman speed should be able keep up with Captain America. He has been shown to tag Bart (speedster from the teen titans) at low sub speed.

In a UFC fight it is a straight 50/50 mark for both contenders. If batman cheats as well as he fights more wins to him. Who is more likely to cause a disqualification? Who is more likely likely to use some forgotten art?

All that was pure PIS crap and you know it.

Okay my bad, just trying to be nice to batcrap for once. Everybody says I "hate on him" too much. Yeah cap 10 out of 10. hehe

Please don't mind so much about what everybody says. You probably laid some good anti batman facts that the batside did not know how to respond to. Don't mind.,,

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Let me put all the speculation to an end.

Batman is a master of 127 different form of martial arts. Taking all that he has mastered and putting it in to one. Making him a more effective fighter and martial artist than captain America. Because instead of batman taking all the effective martial arts and forming a new style. He could take only the most basic, important thing from each of the 127 arts that he knows and form an art that is more fluid in its movement and firm in combat.

Batman has taken beatings from super-powered beings and he is still hear to tell the tail. Like the beating batman got from superman when he thought that batman was darksied. How about the time when batman was dressed up as brainac. Or how about the beating he got from Mongul. Batman is one tough GUY. Being more powerful that him does not automatically give who ever it is the win.

Batman speed should be able keep up with Captain America. He has been shown to tag Bart (speedster from the teen titans) at low sub speed.

In a UFC fight it is a straight 50/50 mark for both contenders. If batman cheats as well as he fights more wins to him. Who is more likely to cause a disqualification? Who is more likely likely to use some forgotten art?

Call it pis call it crap it has been written it has been done and batman has been shown that he can roll with some of the punches from the big boys.

Besides all these different writers that seemingly wrote about the same thing. They must have some little faith in batman's training and his suit.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Call it pis call it crap it has been written it has been done and batman has been shown that he can roll with some of the punches from the big boys.

Besides all these different writers that seemingly wrote about the same thing. They must have some little faith in batman's training and his suit.

My argument simply states that batman can take captain america's punches and then some.

Your logic of captain america being a better martial artist that batman states he could be because he took the most effective martial arts and put it into one.

Well I basically used the same logic with batman being better martial artist because he knows 127 forms of martial arts. And he could just as well combine the art that he knows by taking the most basic (not the whole martial art like you did with captain america) forms of each and putting it into one.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
My argument simply states that batman can take captain america's punches and then some.

Your logic of captain america being a better martial artist that batman states he could be because he took the most effective martial arts and put it into one.

Well I basically used the same logic with batman being better martial artist because he knows 127 forms of martial arts. And he could just as well combine the art that he knows by taking the most basic (not the whole martial art like you did with captain america) forms of each and putting it into one.

Originally posted by King KAM
you do know that it doesnt matter what each style teaches the are PLENTY of styles that just ar enot effective at all meaning, that a man who knows just 1 effective martial art can take out a man who knows 150 uneffective ones.

Agreed thats's why Boxers do so well in mixed martial arts competitions.

getting your ass kicked and survinig doesnt make him tough, cap has been hit by Thanos, The Thing,Hulk,Cage,Juggernaut, and still lives to tell the tale

Very good but which of the two has a body enhanced by the SSS. While the other just has suit and a normal body. And with the beating he got from superman batman suit might has as well been a tutu.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Very good but which of the two has a body enhanced by the SSS. While the other just has suit and a normal body. And with the beating he got from superman batman suit might has as well been a tutu.

which is why it's called PIS and bad writing.

Originally posted by Sir Whirlysplat
Agreed thats's why Boxers do so well in mixed martial arts competitions.

you do know that it doesnt matter what each style teaches the are PLENTY of styles that just ar enot effective at all meaning, that a man who knows just 1 effective martial art can take out a man who knows 150 uneffective ones.

You are not going to get any arguements from me on this one. Besides I was only using the logic propossed by King Kam only instead of captain america I put batman instead and a few more martial art practices.

which is why it's called PIS and bad writing.

But you still cannot deny that it did not happen and it was not in continuity.

You did not answer my question but I guess you got the picture in big bold letters.

Cap wins plain and simple.

Hey it is your opinion aganist mine but I present reason as to why it would be a 50/50 match.....and I am damn well happy with it. To be honest none of the guys that posted have been able to do anything about it.

The perfect human vs. human. Captain Amercia will beat batman it will not be easy win for captain america but he will still win.

If it was a straight fight but batman is as crafty as they come. He would cheat, bend the rules, and most likely to anything to get a win. To come out 50 to 50.

Originally posted by lifeisaglich
If it was a straight fight but batman is as crafty as they come. He would cheat, bend the rules, and most likely to anything to get a win. To come out 50 to 50.

Bend what rules? cheat how? kick him in the balls?

Is there some other form of cheating I don't know about because if there is I want to use it the next time someone makes up a thread with a character with questionable ethics.

Originally posted by Jose123
Bend what rules? cheat how? kick him in the balls?