Cap has been shot in the head point blank and walked it off the next page... Furthermore again Cap has feats just way to far outside of "Peak" to be considered human anymore. Batman at the least has the excuse of gadgets/explosives/clever tactics to take out harder targets Cap tends to bullrush with the stars and stripes as well as straight up enter full on brawling trades with characters far, far, far outside his weightclass.
People here are seriously underestimating Batman. Skill-wise Batman is superior, while Cap fight great, Batman is a great fighter. Also Cap major wins were almost always done when fighting with his shield. Cap uses is shield in his fight almost 95% of the time, Batman uses his gadgets less than 10 % of the time unless outnumbered or outclassed physically. With the thread stipulation it tilts the advantage further toward Batman.
Originally posted by Laminator_X
I actually really like Batman's assessment of the matchup in JLA/Avengers:"All right. It's conceivable you could [b]beat
me, Avenger, but it would take you a very long time." [/B]
Of course, one could focus on different words 😛
"All right. It's conceivable you could beat me, Avenger, but it would take you a very long time."
Those writers knew what they were up to.