Marka Ragnos and Exar Kun vs. DE Sidious and NJO Luke

I would have to say Ragnos and Exar pwn the newbies.

Well we all know that Ragnos and NJO Luke are the greatest and most powerful of their respective "light and dark" sides. I can't say who's better because I'm a Ragnos fan but I know NJO Luke becomes the greatest of the greatest.. If I were to see 1 fight it would be those 2 going at it for the title of Greatest ever. However, Kun and DE Sidious are equals in terms of Force powers, but as we know Kun would be superior to Sidious in light saber combat.. Sorry Lightsnake.

I wouldn't even give Sidious enough credit to call him equal to Kun in force ability.

why not? sidious did accomplish quite alot of feats, unless you count sith magic/spells then yeh sidious doesnt compare, yeh ragnos vs NJO luke in an actual book would be a good fight 😛

Feat wars? *rolls eyes*

Not really. Luke would get curbstomped by Ragnos.

Luke was even afraid of Ragnos just from his spirit. Really... How is Luke "omg I am teh oober furceg0d with no trayning" Skywalker going to beat him? More "I swing like I have twenty sabers" hyperbole?

If it's stated in the novels then it has to be part of the argument. If you're not going to take the novel seriously then why would you take stupid comic books seriously?

Originally posted by tdtd
If it's stated in the novels then it has to be part of the argument. If you're not going to take the novel seriously then why would you take stupid comic books seriously?

I think you're totally missing the point: many of the instances that NJO Luke supporters use are clearly hyperbolic statements, even if they are used in the text. "He swings as though he had twenty sabers". Come on now.

Ah..Yes I am missing the point then... I thought that the novels make him seem like a God though

It's hyperbole. How can Luke "swing like he has 20 sabers"? Does the individual know precisely what it would be like to have 20 sabers? What proficiency are those sabers being swung at? &c.

In KotOR, it's remarked that the ground shook as Exar walked. While it's possible, it's more than likely hyperbole, aka exaggeration.

Hyperbole is not admissable in an objective comparison.

yo illustrious i love you
and **** you lightsnake

where has lightsnake been?

I guess his been fantasing about luke skywalker that he is now officially sleeping with a luke toy each night and day and forgetting about everything else

No he lost the debate and left because he couldn't deal with all his points being defeated... It happens a lot.

Kun's spirit>JA Luke>DE Luke>DE Palpatine so Flesh and Blood Kun should be>NJO Luke.

Wow, cringeworthy stuff in here.

Originally posted by The Merchant
Kun's spirit>JA Luke>DE Luke>DE Palpatine so Flesh and Blood Kun should be>NJO Luke.

That's not how it works at all, lmao.

Sometimes I think you're trolling.

These old threads are comedy gold mines.

Good thread. Sheev solos.

Team 1.