Green Lantern hal jordon vs Silver Surfer (no power absorbing)

well the legendary Hal Jordon must battle the Silver Surfer in a remote uninhabited solar system this is not parallax in this battle just normal Hal vs Silver Surfer but there shall be no energy absorbtion from either side.

come on people you say silver surfer can do this and that so how would he do against a GL of the caliber of Hal Jordan with his absorbing powers nixed?????????????

I'm assuming that SS's speed would still play a role in determining a favorbale outcome for him against Hal. These 2 are among my favorites.

SS has never shown to fight at super speeds to my knowledge but if you can say diffrent please do so and no im not making it a rule that he needs to not fight at super speeds im just saying he's never shown that he can fight at that speed. Thanos has never been shown to fight at such speeds yet we all know how a battle between surfer and thanos goes.

As long as SS can still manipulate matter he should win. I'm just not sure that Hal's ring gives him protection from that kind of attack. Take away matter manipulation and Hal's need to recharge (as I could see this fight lasting a long time due to the similarity of the characters) and I'd give Hal a slight edge 6/10. Surfer is a beast but he isn't really that good of a fighter, while Hal is.

why do you give Surfer such an edge and for him to have to recharge he'd have to fight for days or at least a day to my knowledge beside that he can manipulate matter as well surfer has no edge in this fight its just one on one no i can suck the energy out of you nonsense.

Kahn, GL can manipulate matter as well.

SS can basically transmute any elements (for example the elements that make up Hal's body or even his ring) into any other element he wants. He could turn Hal into gold if he wanted to. His power set is as an matter/energy manipulator fueled by the power cosmic. I'm not sure that Hal has ever fought a matter manipulator before and if his ring would protect him. If it doesn't, then SS wins everytime.

Now, as far as I know Green Lanterns don't manipulate matter often (I may be wrong here) and the only pic I've seen of a similar feat is in a very old GL comic so it might not still be in continunity. GL power set that is used most often is energy manipulation. So if Gal's ring does protect him or you take away the matter manipulation, then I'd say Hal would win because he is a better fighter.

the same goes for GL turning SS into a banana 😄

Originally posted by Mider
the same goes for GL turning SS into a banana 😄

Do you have a recent scan of a GL doing that? I don't follow the GL comics so if you know of a example I'd like to see it because I didn't know that they could do that (save the old comic I mentioned). Anyway if that is the case, as I said earlier, Hal would take IMO

GL has turned stuff into confete from what ive heard i think bullets or energy blasts im not the expert on either of them but neither are you there powers are very similar sept for the whole absorbing bs.

I dont think the matter manipulation would work for the smple fact that GL has already changed his own molecular structure from shrinking his size to that smaller than a atom, to increasing his size to that of a giant. Even changing to energy as well as metal.

Err, GLs high-end feats are impressive. But there's no way a normal GL takes a herald without assistance. A herald is like a GL on steroids, and without any of the weaknesses or limitations.

this isnt a normal GL its Hal Jordan

Yes and Hal is fighting a something thousand year old being practiced with his powers for a long long long time.....

Originally posted by Mider
this isnt a normal GL its Hal Jordan

Doesn't matter. It's close enough. Hal is still human behind the ring. Surfer is a cosmic being who draws on the ambient energy of the universe. Durability, speed, strength, matter manipulation all go to surfer. He has better command of his powers, and more experience with them. Moreover, no yellow weakness, and unlike a GL, surfer's body is its own battery.

well id put him up against the yoda of GL's a GL who fought Parallax and was winning i think but when Parallax lost his human half he finally beat the GL but i do not know who this GL is but yes he exists somewere but i dont know his name.

Originally posted by soleran30
Yes and Hal is fighting a something thousand year old being practiced with his powers for a long long long time.....

Originally posted by slade10
Doesn't matter. It's close enough. Hal is still human behind the ring. Surfer is a cosmic being who draws on the ambient energy of the universe. Durability, speed, strength, matter manipulation all go to surfer. He has better command of his powers, and more experience with them. Moreover, no yellow weakness, and unlike a GL, surfer's body is its own battery.

The GL ring can do anything plus more than Norrin Radd can.

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Hal was fighting Cosmic threats way before Norrin Radd was.

How is that Possible Norrin is SO SO much older then Hal ........................