Master Vandar vs Yoda

Originally posted by Ganner Rhysode
I personally don't think I can make an accurate prediction on this fight. We really don't know enough about Vandar or his abilities. All we know is that he is of Yoda's species.

However, given that he is merely a member of the Dantooine council, a division of the Jedi Sect, while Yoda was at the head of entire Jedi Order, and that he died on Katarr without putting up much of a fight, I would have to guess Yoda.

with the little we know it might be best to correct this statement.

Vandar was not a member of the Dantooine council, just like Vrook wasn't. Very few people on Dantooine were members of the Dantooine council. They were only there to train Revan..

Now the outcome for this thread? I have no idea who will win.

Originally posted by 1 naruto
vander was killed by exar, a sith with little knowledge of the dark side.

WTF, Exar has "little knowledge of the dark side"?

Vandar was killed by him? Pass what you're smoking.

Exar kicked the shuffleboard what? 45 years before Vandar did?

Originally posted by Fishy
with the little we know it might be best to correct this statement.

Vandar was not a member of the Dantooine council, just like Vrook wasn't. Very few people on Dantooine were members of the Dantooine council. They were only there to train Revan..

Now the outcome for this thread? I have no idea who will win.

Er, sorry, you're actually wrong. In the game, they even say they're the Jedi Council. Your character can say, "I thought the Jedi Council was on Courscant," and then they tell you about how this is merely a lower division of the council.

Also, Nihilus isn't exactly your most typical Sith. He didn't go down and do battle with all of the Jedi on Katarr, but rather fought them from space using his warped, really weird power. There's no way of telling who would have won in an actual saber duel.

yoda no questions asked

Originally posted by Ganner Rhysode
Er, sorry, you're actually wrong. In the game, they even say they're the Jedi Council. Your character can say, "I thought the Jedi Council was on Courscant," and then they tell you about how this is merely a lower division of the council.

Meh...

a) You can see at least Vrook sitting on the council on Coruscant before the events of KotoR even happen (I don't recall if Vandar was shown their too). So at least Vrook is a member of the Coruscant council.

b) Do you think they would tell Revan that they have just passed by to train him ? At least Vrook did exactly that.

And Vandar ? Well...he seems to be younger than Yoda and at least he had to argue with Vrook about the power of the Exile and we know (KotoR dark side ending) that he isn't able to counter Bastilla's battle meditation - he doesn't even consider to try fighting against it. Seeing that people like Mace Windu didn't even try to contradict Yoda's words, he seems to be older than Vandar and we have seen that he's quite the saberfighter and a powerful force user...

...if you want to have my guess, I'd say Yoda. But it's really a useless debate since we know virtually nothing about Vandar's power.

Originally posted by Lee-San28
yoda no questions asked

Originally posted by Lee-San28
yoda no questions asked

Yeah, no questions except these:

How powerful was Vandar?

Do you even know who Vandar is?

Do you know who Nihilus is?

Can you stop being a noob?

Hey, Illustrious, I know who Nihilous is, and I addressed the point you're trying to make already, and debunked it, yet you seem to be ignoring my post.

😉

You debunked it with a "we don't know what would have happened."

No shit? If you mean "debunking" as putting on your best imitation of Captain Obvious, yep, you did.

I debunked it in that it was basically said, "well hey. Nihilus took on a planet full of Jedi, one of whom was Vandar. If you're saying Yoda could beat Vandar, you're saying he's better then a planet full of force users."

And I showed that that point had virtually no wait on the current arguement. Unless I understood who made the point I'm referencing, I belive that's how it went down.

Exactly. That circumstance already had no weight. Nothing has much weight in this argument.

The questions I asked him were all in increasing order of ridicule.

Well, the fact that you brought up Nihilous seemed to suggest you thought his position DID hold weight over the arguement, otherwise your mention of it seems quite... Out of place.

Originally posted by Ganner Rhysode
Well, the fact that you brought up Nihilous seemed to suggest you thought his position DID hold weight over the arguement, otherwise your mention of it seems quite... Out of place.

A KotOR II villian.

Actually I think he was referring to your spelling error.

If that's the case, then disregarding my points due to the fact that I mispelled an awkward name, then he's being quite ignorant and full of himself.

That's not too unusual for calvin.

Originally posted by Tangible God
That's not too unusual for calvin.

Originally posted by Ganner Rhysode
If that's the case, then disregarding my points due to the fact that I mispelled an awkward name, then he's being quite ignorant and full of himself.