100 HK-47's versus the Geonosis Jedi.

Same situtation as the Geonosis arena, but the battle droids are replaced with 100 Hk-47's totting Mandalorian Repeaters.

Who wins?

Those jedi are fekked.

All Jedi die...

HK's are able to fly on there own, have flamethrowers and are a hell of a lot smarter then the Jedi.

What? I don't see how the HK droids are going to win. It took thousands of droids to take out the Jedi before the Clones showed up. That was with Geonosian heavy weapons too. Are you telling me that it would take more then 2 Jedi to pull the guns away from the Hk's hands? In DN, Leia, who is very weak, maybe able to give TPM Obi-wan some trouble at best, is able to turn the guns away from her that Chiss soliders(I think it was Chiss) had pointed at her. Mace alone could take out many HK droids by simply nudging their guns to fire slightly over his head and then slicing them in half. Obi-wan and Lumiara could also do the same very well.

Many of the Jedi will die, but I don't see them losing.

Edit: Fishy, when did a HK droid ever fly?

HK talks about it, he was shot down while flying in Mandalorian space. Something on him was damaged and he couldn't fly anymore, after that he was repaired and he could fly again.

I don't see an jet packs on him. I think he was talking about shot down while in a ship. Also, why didn't any of the replica HK-50 droids fly?

Didn't they? Then how did they go to where the Exile was flying from the military base?

And he wasn't talking about a ship, he says he was damaged and doesn't even mention a ship. And I think he talks about another time when he was flying trying to kill a daughter company of Czerka, but i'm not entirely sure about that.

I don't remember HK ever talking about flying under his own power. And I think the HK-50 droids had a shuttle to get from place to place.

I didn't see a shuttle there, and its unlikely that they managed to get through the turrets that shot down Atton...

The Droid Factory had many shuttles in it and it was in the military base. But alas, it was cut.

In any case, most of the battle droids on Geonosis were the weak idiotic kind, with only a handful being the potent droidekas. A hundred HKs with assault blaster rifles could lay down saturation fire well beyond any Niman practitioner's means of defence. They are also independant yet collectively bound, and are bounty hunter droids of the highest caliber.

Thousands of battle droids or 100 HK Units? If the only things they are armed with a Mandalorian Repeaters. Then the Jedi win.

EDIT: Besides, there are 400 to 500 Jedi in the arena. George Lucas said it himself in a interview about AotC.

Eh, IG-88 could take HK-47, so second highest caliber. 😛

To say that the HK droids are going to take down two Jedi a piece doesn't make any sense though. It's not like they have the abilty to gas the Jedi or kill them with booby traps. Mace alone could take down at least ten of them by just nudging their guns to fire away from the Jedi. Obi-wan, Vos, Bulq, Luminara, Plo Kon, and Kit Fisto could easily nudge the guns of at least 50 of the droids away.

Erm... are you missing something?

The thousands of battle droids were tactically inferior. they were controlled by a central computer and their fighting effectiveness was pathetic. There were 200 jedi on Geonosis aside from the named characters. A Repeater Blaster Rifle fires in excess of five rounds a second- more than the carbines and wrist blasters the battle droids were using.

Now, these droids are capable of tactical thought, indepedant thought, and they know how to trap and eliminate prey. Just one of these evil bastards is capable of destroying jedi. You put them in this large a group, arm them with automatic war weapons and have a bunch of halfassed jedi and it's pure carnage.

There is more firepower from thousands of droids than 100 HK Units.

And there's far more power in a group of a thousand musketeers than in a hundred German landsers, but the latter is a better army group and more effective if used properly.

Originally posted by Guy LeDouche
EDIT: Besides, there are 400 to 500 Jedi in the arena. George Lucas said it himself in a interview about AotC.

Janus, as I said, they can just rip the droids guns from their hands or simply nudge them a few inches upward, allowing a Jedi to storm in and kill it. Most of the Jedi will die, but I don't see how they droids would win.

Uh, Glentract? If they can just "rip the guns from their hands" how come they didn't do that EVERY SINGLE TIME they encounters battle droids?

Apparently because it's not that easy to do on a battle field.

Originally posted by PurpleSaber
There were actually 200 Jedi in the arena.

Says who?