ROTS Sidious vS. ROTJ Sidious

Originally posted by Captain REX
My opinion is that Sidious lost the lightsaber fight, but started faking everything after. From the looks of things he does later, he could have flung Windu away from him at any time. *shrug*

*waits for someone to shout 'fanboy!' or 'feat wars!'* 🙄

Not really. He tried to fling Mace away and failed almost too miserabely.

Databank Sez:

Palpatine unleashed a torrent of Sith lightning at the Jedi Master, but Windu was able to deflect it back at the Chancellor. The evil energies twisted Palpatine's face as they flowed through him, scarring and disfiguring his once handsome features.

Rex, baby... It was STATED that Palpatine started playing weak after his initial lightning didn't work on Mace. Everything before, he was pwned.

Originally posted by tdtd
Rex, baby... It was STATED that Palpatine started playing weak after his initial lightning didn't work on Mace. Everything before, he was pwned.

Why'd you just call Rex "Baby"?

I smell Brokeback Mountain all over again . . .

So, How come George didn't clear up in the commentary that Sidious was faking it? He said Sidious began to fake it after he had been defeated.

"Began" is the key word here. If he really said that then I yield, if he didn't then it's open to interpretation.

And stop with the namecalling. No need to get hostile over this.

Originally posted by tdtd
Rex, baby... It was STATED that Palpatine started playing weak after his initial lightning didn't work on Mace. Everything before, he was pwned.

Where's the 'fanboy' rantings? Baby?

Anyways, I didn't mean the lightning. Mace was obviously deflecting that with his lightsaber. But then we see Sidious flinging things several times the weight of Mace Windu at Yoda. If Anakin hadn't walked in, could he have possibly just knocked Windu away from him and run for it, or pushed him out the window?

Originally posted by Gamblor
[b]So, How come George didn't clear up in the commentary that Sidious was faking it? He said Sidious began to fake it after he had been defeated.

"Began" is the key word here. If he really said that then I yield, if he didn't then it's open to interpretation.

And stop with the namecalling. No need to get hostile over this. [/B]

Stop with the namecalling, you say?

*Shifts into third grade.*

Make me!

Everything is a Key word with you. Sidious got smashed by Mace. Accept it.

Originally posted by Captain REX
Where's the 'fanboy' rantings? Baby?

Anyways, I didn't mean the lightning. Mace was obviously deflecting that with his lightsaber. But then we see Sidious flinging things several times the weight of Mace Windu at Yoda. If Anakin hadn't walked in, could he have possibly just knocked Windu away from him and run for it, or pushed him out the window?

Possibly, assuming Mace had no defense for a force push or anything like that. Then again if Anakin didn't come in, Mace would have killed Palpatine.

So we would assume.

Well no it's actually kind of logical.. Palpatine couldn't move Windu and Windu would have just struck down Palpatine. Again, damn that prophecy.

Originally posted by tdtd
Too bad you're just another troll that tries to contradict the words of George Lucas, just like FistoftheNorth.

?

How am I trolling. I'm merely stating facts you're opposing yet you accuse me of inciting flame. (and fanboyism). You couldn't counter and I'm the bad guy. Only at KMC.

I come in peace, td-man

Your facts aren't facts. They're opinions which are inaccurate.

Originally posted by tdtd
Your facts aren't facts. They're opinions which are inaccurate.

It's not a fact that Anakin saw Padme's death in a nightmare he was having? I'm inaccurate in my saying that Anakin turned to the Darkside to try and save Padme from dying? Have you watched ROTS, dude?

If so, tell me what I said that was inaccurate or nonfactual.

Again, if Anakin new why she was dying he would have never turned to the darkside. The word Irony comes to mind in the way she died.

Exactly, tdtd.

Thank you

Originally posted by tdtd
Possibly, assuming Mace had no defense for a force push or anything like that. Then again if Anakin didn't come in, Mace would have killed Palpatine.

Oh yea, that really sounds like Palpatine. Letting himself get arrested and a chance to get tried by Yoda and Mace.. Very logical.

Originally posted by tdtd
Oh yea, that really sounds like Palpatine. Letting himself get arrested and a chance to get tried by Yoda and Mace.. Very logical.

I HIGHLY doubt the Jedi believed he was going to let himself be arrested. In fact it's more than likely they knew they were in for a fight..

Originally posted by Lörd Sorgo
Why'd you just call Rex "Baby"?

I smell Brokeback Mountain all over again . . .