Silver Surfer vs. Martian Manhunter

Started by thesilverspider7 pages

Originally posted by Xplosive
Now, tell me, how could Superman Vs. Thor be a canon.

What Juntai said plus Marvel has put the event in there Handbook...... 馃檪

Originally posted by thesilverspider

Now it's not like the Hammer throw is that powerful anyway many have taken shots from it before.Nefaria takes Thor's hammer throws and laughs at him Namor has taken a shot right to the face aswell.

TOLERANCE TO MAGICAL OBJECTS.. hello? anyone there?

Anyway, explain the magical weakness of Superman so I can fully understand. Because like I said I have a comic were a few enchanted bullets with Diablo's signature nearly killed him.

Originally posted by thesilverspider
What Juntai said plus Marvel has put the event in there Handbook...... 馃檪

OK, than it is canon.
Still SS wins this.

Originally posted by Xplosive
OK, than it is canon.
Still SS wins this.
Oh, I said already way back in the thread pages ago that Surfer would win most encounters, just people can't seem to come up with HOW, but I have faith in the character. Jonn WILL get his licks in though, and a couple of wins likely... but it'll be tough. 馃檪

Originally posted by GODSCRIBE
TOLERANCE TO MAGICAL OBJECTS.. hello? anyone there?

Anyway, explain the magical weakness of Superman so I can fully understand. Because like I said I have a comic were a few enchanted bullets with Diablo's signature nearly killed him.


All right, I didn't mean for this to stray so far from the topic. I was really just fooling around with Juntai saying one crossover means something while the other doesn't (yeah, yeah, I know it's canon).

Back to the fight here. I'd say telepathy is MM's best bet, but Norrin has shown he's no slouch in that department, so I'd say the Manhunter doesn't have very good odds of winning.

Originally posted by Hit and Run
All right, I didn't mean for this to stray so far from the topic. I was really just fooling around with Juntai saying one crossover means something while the other doesn't (yeah, yeah, I know it's canon).

Back to the fight here. I'd say telepathy is MM's best bet, but Norrin has shown he's no slouch in that department, so I'd say the Manhunter doesn't have very good odds of winning.

Ah. Testing me, eh? 馃槈

Originally posted by Hit and Run
All right, I didn't mean for this to stray so far from the topic. I was really just fooling around with Juntai saying one crossover means something while the other doesn't (yeah, yeah, I know it's canon).

Back to the fight here. I'd say telepathy is MM's best bet, but Norrin has shown he's no slouch in that department, so I'd say the Manhunter doesn't have very good odds of winning.

He wont be able to harm SS telepathically. Like I said, he needs to steal his board to gain some leverage.

Originally posted by GODSCRIBE
He wont be able to harm SS telepathically. Like I said, he needs to steal his board to gain some leverage.

That would only happen do to P.I.S Surfer is way to fast for MM to take his board.

Originally posted by Juntai
Ah. Testing me, eh? 馃槈

You know it! 馃槃

I know it too!!

bump!

How in the hell could MM conceivably beat the Surfer?

Originally posted by Thunderstrike
How in the hell could MM conceivably beat the Surfer?

Surfer starts laughing hysterically cuz he can't believe someone would actually wear that kind of Village People outfit. MM gets pissed, phases, reaches inside SS's shorts and rips his willie off.

Other than that, SS wins 9/10.

Wow, that's a good one. Kill or be killed, I guess I'll go with the Surfer, just because, he's said he's immortal. I don't think John could kill him, although, John matches up perfectly with him because of his telepathy. That's something that has hurt the Surfer on many occasions. I think that John could make him comatose for a while, but killing the Surfer is an entirely different matter.

Q: Can Surfer obsorb the Manhunter's matter and eat if if he's phasing???

I think that John could make him comatose for a while, but killing the Surfer is an entirely different matter.

Moondragon with the Sould Gem didn't succeed. Martian Manhunter is also known of the fact that he arranged Joker's thoughts for a few seconds. Do the maths.

Originally posted by Tshern
Moondragon with the Sould Gem didn't succeed. Martian Manhunter is also known of the fact that he arranged Joker's thoughts for a few seconds. Do the maths.

Ok, I think you're saying pretty much what I said. Manhunter can not kill him. Kill or be killed is a difficult fight for anyone when you're up against the Surfer. Can Surfer die? Aren't Galactus and his Heralds going to be the start of the next universe? They somehow transition the matter or something????

Just thought to remind that MM is not putting SS to comatose.

My 20 Bucks On JLA/Avengers being canon.

On DC:
Yes. If WW fans want to show that WW> a GL by showing that Diana broke Quasars shield then yes they could use it. Wouldnt carry much weight though . . .

On Marvel: No.
The crossover is out of continuity. The only Marvel JLA/Avengers reference that i saw in the Handbook is the one listing ALL the appearance of the Cosmic Cube and thats what it is, a SUMMARY listing of all the appearances of the CC for the benefit of the reader. The handbook entry is not even trying to connect it into the main line 616 continuity. Unless we see the Avengers acknowledging the events of JLA/Avengers (like what happened in JLA's Syndicate rules) in a printed comic book, with editorial confirmation no less, then JLA/Avengers IS NOT CANON.

Oh this also means that using feats in JLA/Avengers are moot in cross company fight threads.

SSFTW!!

Surfer.... owns him 10/10