Ulic vs. Malak and Sidious

Ulic in his prime, Malak as of KOTOR I, and Sidious in ROTS.

Who wins?

I don't see Malak and Sidious meshing very well, really.

Should I give them a week to get to know each other better or something? Or should I replace one of them with a better teammate?

I dunno. Just let it go. People will fight over it anyhow. You could have Elmo and Yosemite Sam versus Ulic and there's be controversy.

I don't see many people meshing well together but since this is a star wars forum, how is Ulic going to contend with both of them at the same time, in a saber duel, much less force abilities.

The Sith win.

Probably the duo win, if they get along okay.

That's the point of these versus threads, that there is some collusion between a duo or trio, otherwise there's no point in doing that.

Malak in his prime would be Malak with all of the power of the star forge right? In that case Malak takes him out on his own.

Originally posted by hord06
Malak in his prime would be Malak with all of the power of the star forge right? In that case Malak takes him out on his own.

Malak being powered by the star forge is an unfounded assumption. Ulic was indeed a lightsaber prodigy and stalemated Kun, whether Kun was at his best or not. That alone puts him above Malak.

Unfounded assumption? He was DEFINITELY being powered by the star forge.

Prove it? How was he DEFINITELY being powered by the star forge? At his very best he can not defeat Ulic in a saber battle.

Dude have you played KOTOR? If you are too dumb to understand that Malak was using the power of the star forge from the game itself, you clearly are unable to understand logic and proving it would be a waste of my time.

Where does logic play into non canon gameplay? Where does it specifically state/show that Malak WAS indeed being powered by the star forge? Although it MAY be a logical assumption, all it is is an assumption. And I said either way, Malak at his best would not be able to defeat Ulic in a saber battle.. Perhaps a force battle but definitely not with a saber.

Malak was DEFINITELY using the power of the star forge to revive himself using the bodies of the dead jedi. This is definite as it is confirmed through dialogue. And I was saying that if you are so dumb as to not be able to understand obvious facts, you are clearly lacking in logic and would not understand me if I were to explain it as simply as I can.

Dialogue from whom? A credible source or as IKC calls it, a "fallible 3rd party character"? Hmm? And as I've said regardless if he was or not, at his best he is below Ulic.

Originally posted by tdtd
Prove it? How was he DEFINITELY being powered by the star forge? At his very best he can not defeat Ulic in a saber battle.

I agree with tdtd.

Hord6, you still haven't proved anything. I could say that Malak DEFINATELY WASN'T using the power of the SF to revive himself as it is confirmed through dialogue. Just because I say it doesn't make it true though.

Alright, Malak got a small power boost from the Star Forge. Doesn't change much.

The two Sith win.

The beauty of assumptions.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
I agree with tdtd.

Hord6, you still haven't proved anything. I could say that Malak DEFINATELY WASN'T using the power of the SF to revive himself as it is confirmed through dialogue. Just because I say it doesn't make it true though.

The dialogue is canon. Malak states that he was using 'all of the power of the star forge'.