Crisis on Infinite earths vs. Infinite Crisis

Well I had to do it. Which one did you guys like better?

Personaly I think Marv Wolfman and George Perez got served

("My heart, my achy breaky heart"😉----South Park reference 😄

It was good man, good ending and everthing.

Please just compare the stories, and not artwork. That would be unfair.

Crisis on Infinite Earths no doubt. That one was actually a Crisis, even after reading IC I don't feel like it was a true crisis.

Infinite Crisis.

COIE was great, but soooooo confusing and long. I just like how (decently) organized IC was.

Infinite Crisis was good, and a good follow up to COIE.

But it doesn't compare.

Geoff Johns is great but he's no Marv Wolfman. 😄

The original crisis had true, changing impact on the Universe. This time, the decks chairs were moved around a bit is all, and any change we've seen is temporary, to be sure.

I voted Marvel story just to be a goof. I thought that both were good stories, but I had to read over Crisis three times to get it all.

Crisis of Infinite Earths is better.

The only improtant thing to me was the death of Kal-L.

Only Infinite crisis carried this element so my vote goes to IC.

Really hard to choose either one. I'm gonna say Infinite Crisis for now because we haven't fully felt the aftermath of the events. Superboy dies and SBP is just psychotic villain. Will there be a third Superboy? Let us wait till 52.

The only moments where IC felt epic to me were when it was riffing on elements from CIE.

I would probably enjoy Crisis on infinite earths a lot better if I had read all of silver age DC.
Everything would make more sense, plus I think it would have a bigger imapact on me as well.

Crisis On Infinite Earths wasn't actually all that good, in my opinion. Infinite Crisis all the way.

(All the importance and true, changing impact isn't worth squat if the comic itself isn't good, and the Anti-Monitor wasn't a very interesting bad-guy)

Both.
I wish Infinite Crisis was 12 issues though.

Originally posted by Juntai
Both.
I wish Infinite Crisis was 12 issues though.

Marvel's Big crossovers kill DC's.

Originally posted by King KAM
Marvel's Big crossovers kill DC's.

Originally posted by Validus
Very funny.

Civil War in one issue has already outdone IC. Sorry, but Infinite Crisis was a lot of hype. It was a good story and all, but not really that big of a deal. It seemed like one big advertisement for Superboy Prime. 😬

Originally posted by King KAM
its the truth, look at the sales....look at the threads....the proof is in the pudding my child...the proof is in the pudding...

Sales mean squat. I can name a ton of things that do well financially but still suck.