Crisis on Infinite earths vs. Infinite Crisis · Comic Books

R.O.T. Yahman Restricted

The original Crisis is one of the most overated stories i've ever read ..... Its doesn't compare to the new Crisis, or the likes of Kingdomcome and the Dark Knight returns.

OB1-adobe Senior Member

I think if I had read silver age stuff like 1978-1985, and was 15 years old or something instead of like 5 at the time it came out. I would have probably gotten more out of it.

kenobi Senior Member

Originally posted by willRules
I loved Infinite Crisis, but compared to what has happened in Civil war so far, it pales in comparison. Although that might be the Marvel Fanboy side of me saying that ✅
Plus Steve Mcniven's art for Civil War has been brilliant so far, as has the storyline, which is quite uncommon for Marvel crossovers. The last Marvel crossover I read that I enjoyed as much as this was either the original Secret Wars or JLA/Avengers ✅

It is not your Marvel Fanboy logic, it is the truth. Civil War is far more interesting. I love both DC and Marvel, but always hated how DC revolves around Superman. Marvel has their popular characters but not one of them has everything revolve around them not even Wolvering or Spider-Man. AT least Infinite Crisis had 2 Superman related characters killed (Superman Earth 2 & Superboy).

Superherovandal CEO of BS Comics Inc.

actually originally NW was supposed to die. but both companies have its share of bad crossovers. IC was magnificent in the beginning if only they had like had SBP become AM or something it would have been a great comics.

R.O.T. Yahman Restricted

Originally posted by Validus
Likewise.
Name something that was good.
House of M? Issues 2-5 are Wolverine wandering about NYC and you can say IC was a SBP ad? What a joke.
Onslaught? Heroes Reborn? Infinity Crusade? 😆
Marvel has two good crossovers in Secret Wars II and Infinity Gauntlet.

Galactic Storm was pretty good ... 🙂

R.O.T. Yahman Restricted

Originally posted by King KAM

And no im not for Marvel, Im actually neutral, DC has just been gettinf out-written lately.

Out written ??????? With the exception of Civil War and Astonoshing, name a Marvel title that is 'Out Writing' D.C. at the moment ?

Grimm22 King of the Castle

Originally posted by R.O.T. Yahman
Out written ??????? With the exception of Civil War and Astonoshing, name a Marvel title that is 'Out Writing' D.C. at the moment ?

Ultimates 2

Ultimate FF

Ultimate Spidey

Of course DC also has amazing books too...

All Star Supes

Teen Titans

Detective Comics

ect...

Grimm22 King of the Castle

Originally posted by Validus
Likewise.
Name something that was good.
House of M? Issues 2-5 are Wolverine wandering about NYC and you can say IC was a SBP ad? What a joke.
Onslaught? Heroes Reborn? Infinity Crusade? 😆
Marvel has two good crossovers in Secret Wars II and Infinity Gauntlet.

Yeah Marvel usually has crappy crossovers.

However, Secret Wars II was awful 😘

Secret Wars I was suberb ✅

R.O.T. Yahman Restricted

Originally posted by Grimm22
Ultimates 2
Ultimate FF
Ultimate Spidey
Of course DC also has amazing books too...
All Star Supes
Teen Titans
Detective Comics
ect...

UFF and Ult Spidey are alright, but they are not any where near as good as G.L. Corps or 52, The Crisis (B4 it finished), JSA (b4 it finished), the recent Up Up and away Supes story, All Star Supes etc ....

jumpmann Glower of Eyes

No, Millar's UFF was among the top books out there easily. Its been amazing ever since he started his run and it ended brilliantly. Probably the best Fantastic Four run in a long time.

Ult Spidey has been average for a long time but looks to be picking up again. Would agree that it doesn't qualify as amazing.

And some DC's best books come from Vertigo. Y: Last Man, Ex Machina, and Fables blow away most of main contuinity DC's best work.