Originally posted by forumcrew
the problem with valuable part is a ton of people fit. Say you just look at those that are gonna make the playoffs and then pick the guy most valuable to their team. Well the colts would likely be about 4-12 without manning so isnt he automatic? Cowboys clearly were not fit for the NFL without Romo, The only reason the redskins have accomplished anything is Portis taking over games but they most likely wont be in the playoff picture and portis is hurt so who knows what the end of his season will look like.Its such a hard award and lacks a clear distinction of what you should base it on. If the Vikes make it the playoffs I predict Peterson gets it, because he will be the top RB in the league and the only way they are making it is if he carries them in these final 4 games. Also because then voters dont have to decide between a mess of QB's some who have the stats some who have the "valuable" quality.
True. This year, there isn't a clear cut winner. I think Manning should easily get some recognition. He single handily made them stay in the playoff hunt with a bum knee and a leaky defense. Defense is playing well so its not really much but the Colts were awful in the first 6-7 games.