Vader vs Kenobi

Started by Null ARC Avis5 pages

Vader vs Kenobi

ESB vader VS ROTS obi wan.
I think vader because obi wan hasn't proved resistent to the dark side really.

Ummm. Kenobi can outmatch him in lightsaber skills.

And Obi1 isn't resistant to the darkside?

His master was slaughtered infront of him. He got just a little annoyed.
He was betrayed by his masters master. He got just a little annoyed.
He was betrayed by his former padawans masters padawans masters padawan and he defeated him and got just a little annoyed.

He confronted Vader 20 years after the duel. He was striken down and he got just a little annoyed.

Kenobi is the ultimate Jedi-personality along with Yoda.

You know what i mean. Dooku wtf pwned him with his force powers. Vader can do the same if not better. Also Vader is a good lightsaber fighter. He killed 5/7 jedi with it.

It's not that Kenobi just got a little annoyed. Rather, he got furious when Qui-Gon was slaughtered, ticked off when Dooku revealed himself to be evil, and horrible depressed and upset that Anakin had chosen death and the Dark Side.

Thing is, he didn't use these emotions for power.

Vader killed a lot of Jedi during the Purge, not just in the comic.

Anyways, I say Vader, though Kenobi is more agile at this point.

Kenobi wins. He's abouyt twice as fast, he's smarter,he has less weaknesses and he's defeated a stronger version of Vader. Vader's stronger due to his suit, but that's it. Their Force powers must be about the same. But Kenobi wins cause seriously how the hell's Vader going to get past Kenobi's Soresu Mastery?

he wont ignite his lightsaber. All he has to do is choke him. He choked a man frrom a mile or more away (ANH) i am sure he can choke Kenobi.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Their Force powers must be about the same.

Kenobi and Vader are equal in the Force? Hardly, Vader has been practicing Darkside techniques for how long now? 22 years or so? Yeah, Vader is > Kenobi in the Force I'd say.

vader has this in the sense that: A, there is no highground, B, this his completely skill, and c, because Vader has the most agressive lightsaber form. Vader also takes this because many people have already told you what i would have said.

Dark side goes like this:
First you start out strong and progress at great speed, then you start to peak. After you peak you become stronger, but slower at becoming stronger.
Light Side:
You start out weak and slow, as you progress you get better, but not as fast as the sith. Next you get better faster, around the time that the sith are slowing down.

Originally posted by Null ARC Avis
he wont ignite his lightsaber. All he has to do is choke him. He choked a man frrom a mile or more away (ANH) i am sure he can choke Kenobi.

A mile away? When did this happen?

Kenobi and Vader are equal in the Force? Hardly, Vader has been practicing Darkside techniques for how long now? 22 years or so? Yeah, Vader is > Kenobi in the Force I'd say.

Yeah, maybe your right Vader is 80% of Sidious but Kenobi's really good, too. it'd be close. there's no way Vader could win in a duel, though.

Originally posted by darthsith19
A mile away? When did this happen?

ANH. the executor is many miles long.

Originally posted by Sesse
Ummm. Kenobi can outmatch him in lightsaber skills.

And Obi1 isn't resistant to the darkside?

His master was slaughtered infront of him. He got just a little annoyed.
He was betrayed by his masters master. He got just a little annoyed.
He was betrayed by his former padawans masters padawans masters padawan and he defeated him and got just a little annoyed.

He confronted Vader 20 years after the duel. He was striken down and he got just a little annoyed.

Kenobi is the ultimate Jedi-personality along with Yoda.

YOU ARE BIASED, YOU HAVE A KENOBI AVATARARATA (or something)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Obi-Wan takes this. He's too good with a lightsaber..

And Vader's not going to choke a Jedi Master nearly as easily as a fat Commander.

Originally posted by overlord
YOU ARE BIASED, YOU HAVE A KENOBI AVATARARATA (or something)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I think you mean "fanboy", in which I hold a slight agreement with. Vader beats Obi with the Force.

All he's done with the Force is choke people, which Obi wouldn't let him do...Obi -Wan takes this

Originally posted by Null ARC Avis
ANH. the executor is many miles long.

The executor wasn't in ANH. You mean when he choked Admiral Ozzel in ESB? Yes, it may have been over a mile but we really can't say cause we don't know how far Vader's personal chambers are from the bridge.

Vader is 80% as powerful as RotJ Sidious.

RotJ Sidious > RotS Sidious > RotS Dooku in force powers.

However, Vader isn't quite as good as Dooku in the force IMO. Will he still be able to choke Kenobi? I think so.

And the Executor is 19 kilometers(12 miles) long. He choked Admiral Ozzel in ESB, not ANH.

damn. i always get them mixed up. still i am right!

Originally posted by overlord
YOU ARE BIASED, YOU HAVE A KENOBI AVATARARATA (or something)
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Overlord is back!

Originally posted by Null ARC Avis
he wont ignite his lightsaber. All he has to do is choke him. He choked a man frrom a mile or more away (ANH) i am sure he can choke Kenobi.

Why didn't Anakin do that at Mustafar? I'm sure Obi-Wan would defeat Vader. Come on Obi-Wan is awesome in Revenge of the Sith and Vader is just a shadow of his former self.

Originally posted by Razielim
Vader is 80% as powerful as RotJ Sidious.

RotJ Sidious > RotS Sidious > RotS Dooku in force powers.

However, Vader isn't quite as good as Dooku in the force IMO. Will he still be able to choke Kenobi? I think so.

And the Executor is 19 kilometers(12 miles) long. He choked Admiral Ozzel in ESB, not ANH.


Do we know how far it was from Vader's personal chambers to the bridge where Ozzel was? if not it would have been 12 miles or it could have been .012 miles.