"a Prophecy that Misread, could have been"

Was it true that the profecy was misread, heres what i think:

Anakin was to bring BALANCE to the force, he kills all but two jedi, and its just him and palps, making two jedi versus two sith.
Obiwan Trains luke to use the force and makes three jedi and two sith, Ergo anakin steps in and kills Obiwan.
yoda and luke versus sids and vader, then yoda dies. Luke fights sids and vader kills sids making is one sith versus one jedi, then vader dies and luke starts a jedi order of his own, but we realize there's more evil in the galaxy, so on so forth and (ect.)

Balance to the Force is destroying the Sith, it's not a 'wipe out the Jedi to fight the Sith equally' bullshit.

Lightsnake's right.

How? Balance implies both sides of the Force are equal. 2 Sith and 2 Jedi fits the bill.

exactly.

Then the force was pretty much only balanced for a year or so.

Hahah probably, or maybe longer, like when the sith fought the jedi it was balanced.

Hmm, I thought that it was the dark side that disrupted the balance in the force to begin with...

It is.

Afraid that this is not speculation, Legion.

Balance is nothing to do with equal amounts of Jedi and Sith. Balance is purely a force of good. The imbalance is the Dark Side. It is caused by the Sith. The Balance was restored when the Sith were destroyed.

Killing Jedi had nothing to do with balance and was nothing but pure evil.

Also, moving...

omfg here we go again with the frikin scales.

Originally posted by Ushgarak
It is.

Afraid that this is not speculation, Legion.

Balance is nothing to do with equal amounts of Jedi and Sith. Balance is purely a force of good. The imbalance is the Dark Side. It is caused by the Sith. The Balance was restored when the Sith were destroyed.

Killing Jedi had nothing to do with balance and was nothing but pure evil.

No.

Mesa think there should be 2 jedi and 2 Sith! This so, because 2+ 2 = 4. And Mesa thinks 4/2 = 2.

Mesa has found balance.

Yousa are all wrong!

Bringing balance to the force means destroying the Sith because they unbalance the force. So basically Anakin did bring balance to the force by throwing Palpatine.

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Balance to the Force is destroying the Sith, it's not a 'wipe out the Jedi to fight the Sith equally' bullshit.

I dont like that view. I think Lucas presents a confusing point. WHy have two sides of the force, but then say that the force is "balanced" when only the light side is in control?

By "balance to the Force" I think Lucas tried to imply "Stability."

There can't be stability of the Force if the Dark Side keeps f*cking things up.

No, but imo the jedi f-ed thing up a lot too, like during the Mando wars and the Clone Wars. Balance (in general) means both sides are equal, with niether one outcompeting the other.

How is it balanced by only having one side in control? Its like a dictatorship, where everythign is happy because everone is forced to have one opinion. This also breeds rebellion, which could be molded to the perspectvie of sith/darksiders, construed to be "unbalancing" from the jedi point of view.

I like the word stable better, but then why did Lucas use "balance"?

In my opinion the Jedi were stupid in ROTS

people who will accept the true concept will do so.
people who wont accept it will not...and are really stupid.

:edit: @MC
imho the only jedi that came off as completely stupid
were mace's posse, which is the saddest and most annoying
irony of all since they are supposed to be the elete, so to speak.

The Jedi had stupid moments, but the Dark Side held a tendency to start wars, hence causing imbalance (or preferably, "instability"😉 in the galaxy and the Force.

Originally posted by PVS
people who will accept the true concept will do so.
people who wont accept it will not...and are really stupid.

Why can't I question? I think I have raised legitimate points.