Originally posted by Ushgarak
I am telling you that if GL says it is so in the films, then it is in the films. That's policy, get used to it.
then maybe you should make some changes to post you made with Cannon Policy. Right now it says Movies are the absolute cannon. As long as it says that then I will hold the Movies higher then Lucas.
Originally posted by Rampant ox
Pffffffffft. In a battle that was tipped so far in Anakins favor that if he lost he would have been nothing more than a mere youngling!!!
Provide proof. Palpatine wanted the stronger of the two. And Anakin WTFpwned Dooku. So climb down from your cross, use the wood to build a bridge, get over it, and:
(image removed)
Originally posted by Jam-Jul_LisonHaha, you have a hard time stating your points. Nobody is going to read that huge block of text. Vious' constant trying to have the last word against a moderator is what killed him. Saying dumbass stuff like "I'm willing to stop posting if you do" never did anyone good. Don't defend children who are stubborn.
overlord all you do is troll. Not only have i seen it but i have talked to others that say you troll. And yet you never get in trouble. Now here is the real point this post.http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f38/t20461.html
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f5/t20463.html
"When it comes to absolute canon, the real story of Star Wars, you must turn to the films themselves - and only the films. Even novelizations are interpretations of the film, and while they are largely true to George Lucas' vision (he works quite closely with the novel authors), the method in which they are written does allow for some minor differences."
it says it right there that movies are the absolute cannon. It does not say Lucas is the absolute cannon. Ushgarak you were the one that made that whole post. Are you now going against what you posted as forum policy? Also restricting Darth Vious was stupid. Yes his Luke and Leia thing was annoying but he kept providing proof for his words and was debating properly. Nothing in the movie proved Anakin was a better swordsman. Yes he won. He won for several reasons. Dooku though if he lost Palpatine would step in to keep him from getting killed. No one fights their hardest when they have a safty net. That is basic psychology. The fight started on 2 on 1. 2 on one is likly to wear someone down but when it is 2 young vs 1 60 year old guy, the 60 year old will wear out faster. Dooku's arrogence throughout the duel. He taunted Anakin making him angry. When angry Anakin become physicly stronger. Anakin grabbed Dooku's arm to restrain his arm from being able to stop Anakin from chopping it off. Restraining a 60 year old man would be easy for just about anyone Anakin's age. Reason there is no proof that Anakin is not a better swordsman. He failed to land a blow on Dooku. He had to resort to grabbing Dooku's arms to win. Here is reasons as why Anakin is not better. First off you can not realy tell this from ROTS. So let's look at Dooku's fight against Yoda in AOTC. Dooku stalemated with Yoda is a contest of sabers.
Originally posted by Rampant oxLMAO!! A funny picture of Anakin getting electrocuted! Exactly, overlord is the troll around here!
LMAO!!!!
Please both of you grow up, jam jul something: go learn how to communicate properly by starting a new line once in a while, rampant ox: get over your fanboyism of Dooku or start saying something worth while.
Just look at these arguments: "Now if Anakin was better swordman then he would be better then Yoda"
LOL that makes no sense.
"While the Lucas and Anakin fans might think words from lucas of some secondary cannon script is proof enough"
LOL Lucas and Anakin fans!
"I myself am simply looking at what I saw in the movie"
Me too. I at least saw Anakin beat Dooku and I also see people whining that it wasn't fair, boohoo..
"Dooku though if he lost Palpatine would step in to keep him from getting killed"
You die most of the time when you lose in a lightsaber contest, don't forget that lightsabers cut people in half with relative ease. So that theory makes no sense at all.
"No one fights their hardest when they have a safty net. That is basic psychology"
Even if he did have some imaginary safety net (see, good spelling!) he still fought pretty hard and fast and it doesn't take away his defensive abilities and focus.
"When angry Anakin become physicly stronger"
What the f*ck? Are you acting like you're Yoda now?
"Dooku stalemated with Yoda is a contest of sabers"
Maybe Yoda was holding back eh? Seems much more realistic than Dooku holding back to get killed.
Originally posted by Jam-Jul_Lison
then maybe you should make some changes to post you made with Cannon Policy. Right now it says Movies are the absolute cannon. As long as it says that then I will hold the Movies higher then Lucas.
Read what I said. The movies ARE absolute canon. But when it comes to interpreting what is IN the movies, GL's word is king.
If you intentionally keep going against forum policy after I have clearly defined it to you, then that is going to cause a problem, believe me.
This thread has become pointless, so closing.