Originally posted by leonidas
not the same at all, val. c'hp ported his OWN non-human (i assume) body. it would be different for hal to port his own body. and what if sinestro nuked the galaxy using some bizarro alien weapon that kyle has never seen and so could NOT recreate?
As for Sinestro, you're just agreeing with me.
Originally posted by leonidas
😑anyway, it's dropped. but duly noted for future matches . . . 😈 especially given that time and again hal has been said to be the greatest gl, i guess he can do . . . anything . . . 😄
Your rebuttal against me just totally missed the point I was making.
I hope everyone is cool with the decisions about the matches. It's never my intention to play favorites or to make things unfair. I try to make every decision in the interest of rule-continuity and fairness. I realize this is not always 100% possible, and hope that everyone also understands.
As it is, I think every team still has a legitimate chance to win, so I don't feel like we've severely handicapped anyone with the recent decisions.
Good luck again to all, and controversy like this is at least preferable to walkovers like last week.
Originally posted by DigiMark007
I hope everyone is cool with the decisions about the matches. It's never my intention to play favorites or to make things unfair. I try to make every decision in the interest of rule-continuity and fairness. I realize this is not always 100% possible, and hope that everyone also understands.As it is, I think every team still has a legitimate chance to win, so I don't feel like we've severely handicapped anyone with the recent decisions.
Good luck again to all, and controversy like this is at least preferable to walkovers like last week.
Why ? What happened ?
I'm to damn lazy to trudge through five pages of huge ass post's....
Originally posted by leonidas
meh, it's moot since digi said all gls can use all gl feats. we shouldn't have bothered selecting individual gls then and anyone who didn't pick just some old gl, really made an error . . .
Actually Digi said you could use the scans if you want.... but don't expect anyone to just accept/believe that just because one GL did it, another one can do the same
(paraphrased.... obviously .... 😛)
Originally posted by leonidasI don't think so I far as I'm concerned Kyle/Hal inerchangable if you want to know the truth.
caveat duly noted. and, as we have the best gl of all . . . duly dismissed! 😛
By the way I don'y think it would be hard for a better GL to duplicate the feat of a lower one. Now a lower one trying to do a better one's feats would be a little iffy.
Edit: Oh by the way just posted in the match go check it out I'm really pleased with it.
Originally posted by Adam Warlock
Might as well toss out the 9 post rule. Doesn't seem to be working.
Originally posted by Validus
I said the same thing yesterday. The whole point of the 9 post rule was to keep to judges from having to sift through pages and pages of nothing. Any non official posts should be done in this thread.
Well, at least given the lengths of the "official" posts the judges should be able to tell which ones are non-official and can be ignored fairly quickly when they look back through the debate. 😬