Superman (vs) Ego The living Planet · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Wasn't Ego afraid of crashing into the sun?
And come on guys..It was blatantly obvious that DG had an ulterior motive by resurrecting this ancient and near insignificant thread.

That was a weakened Ego.

At his best Ego can withstand the fire of a thousand suns...
http://img451.imageshack.us/img451/2023/galactusblast1rv5.jpg
http://img179.imageshack.us/img179/2073/galactusblast2mf3.jpg

And what's wrong with me bumping a thread that's been dead for a while? There were still a lot of unanswered questions that I now happen to have evidence on so I bumped it to show that evidence off and correct a lot of common misconceptions. Why should you(or anyone else) have a problem with that?

Avalonofthewind Godot Brew#107

Originally posted by darthgoober
That was a weakened Ego.
At his best Ego can withstand the fire of a thousand suns...
http://img451.imageshack.us/img451/2023/galactusblast1rv5.jpg
http://img179.imageshack.us/img179/2073/galactusblast2mf3.jpg

LOL @ stopping Galactus weapon with a sheet of ice. Anyway..back to topic.

50x Supernova >>> the fire of a thousand Suns.

1 Black Hole >>>> 1 Thousand Suns.

1 Thousand Suns wouldn't hurt Superman either...especially when he's taken the power of a million suns and returned it just fine.

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
LOL @ stopping Galactus weapon with a sheet of ice. Anyway..back to topic.
50x Supernova >>> the fire of a thousand Suns.
1 Black Hole >>>> 1 Thousand Suns.
1 Thousand Suns wouldn't hurt Superman either...especially when he's taken the power of a million suns and returned it just fine.
manofsteel130p14vp7.th.jpg[/IMG][/URL]

I never said anything about Supes not being able to withstand stars(they're his power source after all), you asked about Ego and the sun so I showed you that he was weakened. You've still yet to show what Supes could do to take down Ego, and I've already listed several ways for Ego to take down Supes.

Avalonofthewind Godot Brew#107

Originally posted by darthgoober
That was a weakened Ego.
At his best Ego can withstand the fire of a thousand suns...
http://img451.imageshack.us/img451/2023/galactusblast1rv5.jpg
http://img179.imageshack.us/img179/2073/galactusblast2mf3.jpg
And what's wrong with me bumping a thread that's been dead for a while? There were still a lot of unanswered questions that I now happen to have evidence on so I bumped it to show that evidence off and correct a lot of common misconceptions. Why should you(or anyone else) have a problem with that?

Besides the fact that that you blatantly ressurected it to try and goad people?

Post a ninja smiley...wait patiently for a poster to say "Supes wins!" and then come with your newly acquired scans? 😉

Avalonofthewind Godot Brew#107

Originally posted by darthgoober
I never said anything about Supes not being able to withstand stars(they're his power source after all), you asked about Ego and the sun so I showed you that he was weakened. You've still yet to show what Supes could do to take down Ego, and I've already listed several ways for Ego to take down Supes.

Actually, Juntai has shown and the thread has shown more than enough ways.
Your scans haven't even shown Ego being in Superman's league yet... He effortlessly froze a planet much bigger than Ego munching on a sun. The Elementals of Earth itself which would have exactly the same abilities as Ego itself backed down knowing that they wouldn't stopped a determined Superman, and Superman himself can crack a planet in half with a punch without maxing out.

Ego has lost to Glads, Thor, SS, and nearly died in a sun...it took him a bit of power to overcome a jetpack on his back.

There isn't much to say about this topic...so I'll leave it as is for now.

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Besides the fact that that you blatantly ressurected it to try and goad people?
Post a ninja smiley...wait patiently for a poster to say "Supes wins!" and then come with your newly acquired scans? 😉

Hey I said long ago that Ego wins this in a stomp. Then people started asking for proof which I didn't have at the time, so I left the thread alone. But now that I HAVE that proof, I figured I'd bump the thread and provide proof as people asked for it. Again, what's wrong with that?

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Actually, Juntai has shown and the thread has shown more than enough ways.

Yes but none of the ways he listed could logically take down a non jobbing Ego.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
Your scans haven't even shown Ego being in Superman's league yet...

You mean that the scans I posted that showed Ego to be on par with Galactus's don't prove that he's in Supes's league 😕 ?

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
He effortlessly froze a planet much bigger than Ego munching on a sun.

And what will his freezing Ego accomplish exactly? As I've already shown Ego can create and withstand a MASSIVE amount of ice.

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
The Elementals of Earth itself which would have exactly the same abilities as Ego itself backed down knowing that they wouldn't stopped a determined Superman,

Proof that the Elementals are capable of EVERYTHING that Ego is?

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
and Superman himself can crack a planet in half with a punch without maxing out.
Really? Has he ever cracked a living planet that's on par with Galactus with the ability to heal itself at will in half with a punch?
[QUOTE=9191234]Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
[B]Ego has lost to Glads, Thor, SS, and nearly died in a sun...it took him a bit of power to overcome a jetpack on his back.

Ok let's see...

I already proved that Glads taking down Ego was PISs.

Thor has magical options availible to him that Supes lacks. Also Thor didn't beat Ego solo, he just distracted Ego while Galactus attached that machine to him.

Surfer bested a weakened Ego via plot device.

And I already showed that Ego was weakened during the Sun incident.

Juntai Divine Vengeance

I dunno, showing that he has some versatility, and calling all his fights besides a showing against Galactus PIS doesn't solidify a win for me.

Lots of characters seem versatile enough to handle Superman. Application, adaptation, keeping the pressure, and most of all finishing are quintessential pieces of combat. While both characters have great power, all those of categories belong to Superman.

Now I'm not saying Ego can't win, I'm just leaning towards Superman. In the idea that Supes has been in the situations presented and passed the tests, while Ego continuiously get beaten by characters of a similar tier.

Tyrant Dead

Originally posted by Avalonofthewind
50x Supernova >>> the fire of a thousand Suns.
1 Black Hole >>>> 1 Thousand Suns.

Eh?

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Juntai
I dunno, showing that he has some versatility, and calling all his fights besides a showing against Galactus PIS doesn't solidify a win for me.
Lots of characters seem versatile enough to handle Superman. Application, adaptation, keeping the pressure, and most of all finishing are quintessential pieces of combat. While both characters have great power, all those of categories belong to Superman.
Now I'm not saying Ego can't win, I'm just leaning towards Superman. In the idea that Supes has been in the situations presented and passed the tests, while Ego continuiously get beaten by characters of a similar tier.

You're acting as if all those herald level characters have strait up victories over Ego, but they don't. Thor didn't actually beat Ego, he just distracted him for long enough for Galactus to attach that propulsion device. And again, Thor is the God of Thunder and has a level of control over the weather that Supes lacks, so Supes won't be anywhere near as effective as Thor was in that instance. Surfer didn't actually beat Ego either, he just charged up that propulsion device to reactivate it. Ego was weakened from having to fight against that device, which is why he would have been destroyed by the Sun.

To my knowledge, Gladiator is the only herald level character that has an actual victory over Ego. So if you weigh that ONE showing against Ego's TWO showings against Galactus, it lends quite a bit of support to the opinion that his fight against Glads was nothing more than PIS.

Juntai Divine Vengeance

Who does Ego have definitive victories over?

Tyrant Dead

Originally posted by Juntai
Who does Ego have definitive victories over?

He KO'ed Thor with an indirect attack...ermm

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Juntai
Who does Ego have definitive victories over?

Originally posted by Tyrant
He KO'ed Thor with an indirect attack...ermm

And technically, he has a win over Galactus also since Big G retreated to get help from Thor and Herc.

Magee Senior Member

Galactus retreated to get help from Thor and Hercules. 😆

Juntai Divine Vengeance

Originally posted by Magee
Galactus retreated to get help from Thor and Hercules. 😆

😂

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Magee
Galactus retreated to get help from Thor and Hercules. 😆

Originally posted by Juntai
😂

It's true. That's when Thor's supposed "victory" took place. Galactus wanted Thor, Herc, and Firelord to distract Ego long enough for Big G to attach a propulsion device to the Elder.

Juntai Divine Vengeance

I understand it's what happened, but you realise how rediculous it is, right?

Funny how you call his losses PIS, and stand by a showing of Galactus running away from Ego to get help from Thor. Apperently, you're confused as to what PIS actually is.

The fire of a thousand suns is also obviously nothing more than hyperbole.

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Juntai
I understand it's what happened, but you realise how rediculous it is, right?
Funny how you call his losses PIS, and stand by a showing of Galactus running away from Ego to get help from Thor. Apperently, you're confused as to what PIS actually is.
The fire of a thousand suns is also obviously nothing more than hyperbole.

As I've already explained, Galactus got help to DISTRACT Ego while Galactus attached the propulsion device. Since Thor was able to override Ego's weather systems, Thor just happened to be the best one to do that.

And why do you automatically want to dismiss the fire of a thousand suns as hyperbole? Galactus seems to be a creditable source of info on the power behind his own attacks, and he's not really the type that's given to exaggeration.

Juntai Divine Vengeance

Originally posted by darthgoober
As I've already explained, Galactus got help to DISTRACT Ego while Galactus attached the propulsion device. Since Thor was able to override Ego's weather systems, Thor just happened to be the best one to do that.
And why do you automatically want to dismiss the fire of a thousand suns as hyperbole? Galactus seems to be a creditable source of info on the power behind his own attacks, and he's not really the type that's given to exaggeration.

Because a planet engulfed by the fire of a thousand suns would cease to exist. No covering the planet with ice will work in that occasion. There's simply not enough cold he could ever generate. If for example, Pluto, a whole planet of ice falls into our single sun, it will simply cease to be. It's a rediculous moment, easily as rediculous as Galactus needing Thor for help.

Originally posted by Juntai
I understand it's what happened, but you realise how rediculous it is, right?
Funny how you call his losses PIS, and stand by a showing of Galactus running away from Ego to get help from Thor. Apperently, you're confused as to what PIS actually is.
The fire of a thousand suns is also obviously nothing more than hyperbole.

darthgoober Senior Member

Originally posted by Juntai
Because a planet engulfed by the fire of a thousand suns would cease to exist. No covering the planet with ice will work in that occasion. There's simply not enough cold he could ever generate. If for example, Pluto, a whole planet of ice falls into our single sun, it will simply cease to be. It's a rediculous moment, easily as rediculous as Galactus needing Thor for help.

A regular planet....yes. But then again we're not talking about a regular planet now are we? By the same token, a regular man would be incinerated long before he was able to physically touch the surface of the Sun. But a SUPER man might be able to do just that without to much trouble 😉 .

And again, Galactus just wanted someone to distract Ego. Thor is the God of Thunder and has a history with Ego, so he served well in that regard. And now that Thor is no longer usable as an example of how Supes could put down Ego(seeing as how all he did was distract Ego) all you're left with is your ONE example of Ego being taken down by Gladiator, which is offset by Ego's TWO impressive showings against Galactus.

So again, how can Supes POSSIBLY put Ego down when anything Supes does to Ego can be repaired at will?