katelovespirate
Senior Member
All right I just saw it again, and I had some big thoughts. One of them is a bit of going back on earlier comments... i still hope liz and jack get together, and think it is a better overall choice--- but i was wondering if Liz's moment of true "piracy" just made her miserable, which is why she is heartbroken at the end. She was curious, she gave it a shot, and felt terrible afterward. not that she cheated on will or whatever, but that she did something really dishonorable by locking jack up, and it didnt give her the satisfaction she thought it would. Its true i think she does look to him as a hero.
2. will is actually pretty piraty in this film. he's pretty much caused a whole ships death, he's carrying a dagger in his mouth, and as usual, he working against Capt. Jack.
3. If Tia Dalma was at one time Davy's lover (which we dont know) why would she help Jack kill him?
AND, her dress looks scary-alike to Liz's wedding dress, just old and worn out.
4. I think Jack knows Barbossa is alive. In Tia Dalma's hut, he actually picks up Barbossa's old hat, looks at it, etc. I think he knows. Which may explain why he doesnt mind being all heroic in the last moment- he knows Dalma can bring him back or something.
>>> side question... why is Jack so worried before entering tia's hut? What does he think she will do to him?
5. I get more and more convinced jack was going to stay on the ship at the end. And i almost think he knew what Liz was up to... Its true that he looks delighted by it--- like, he thinks it is hott. but i dont think he was entirely suspecting that either.
6. there actually were more good will/liz moments than i remember- they just have a good level of trust and work together well on the ship when the kraken is attacking... will trusts her to shoot properly, liz trusts him to get off in time, etc. i dont see any extremely romantic chemistry, but they do get along well. they can talk with their eyes.
7. this is purely my opinion, but i actually think Will figures out why Liz kissed him when she says "he elected to stay behind". there is just a look of meaning that passes between them, and in my mind that means that Will understood what she did... which makes him saying "if there was anything could be done to bring Jack back..." make a bit more sense. He knows she feels awful about what she did and he wants to help her set things right or something.
i'll probably think of more junk to say as things go along, hehe. Jack gets hotter and hotter. He and Liz should def. end up together.