Elizabeth: Who will she choose? (*Spoilers)

Started by blackpearl446 pages

No kidding ^^ lol

Will think liz can't take care of herself, and he dosn't trust her to take care of/protect herself /smeone else......but Jack puts that trust it her, and he knows she can handle it, and she respects that in Jack.

You guys are going in circles as I said in my other post.
This will never end lol. I think all I have to say is everything that has been said is true about Liz and Jack we just have to wait and find out.

Originally posted by blackpearl44
No kidding ^^ lol

Will think liz can't take care of herself, and he dosn't trust her to take care of/protect herself /smeone else......but Jack puts that trust it her, and he knows she can handle it, and she respects that in Jack.

You know what that would make sense actually. I read 50 pages of what is apprently the draft script for PotC3. It was won in a competition and the winner put it up on MYspace to share. I dont know if its real or not though.

POSSIBLE SPOILER HERE:

But what you just said makes sense for one part I read. Where Jack trades Liz over to Seo Feng (or something) for one day after being betrayed by Will. and he seems to have faith in her that she can handle herself. He tries to reassure Will but Will wont listen. He seems to think that she is still all weak and needs protecting.

And sweet_Kat..hehe yeh we are going round in circles but its fun going round in circles. 💃

Ok now this is really really outta the blue but here is one thing i think or mostly want...as most of u know im a huge Will//Liz fan...but maybe Liz will go with Jack but maybe he'll go back to Scarlett...i know its really hopeful on my part but she's on the cast list for POCT 3 so idk...it might just happen

Originally posted by LovelyOne
You know what that would make sense actually. I read 50 pages of what is apprently the draft script for PotC3. It was won in a competition and the winner put it up on MYspace to share. I dont know if its real or not though.

POSSIBLE SPOILER HERE:

But what you just said makes sense for one part I read. Where Jack trades Liz over to Seo Feng (or something) for one day after being betrayed by Will. and he seems to have faith in her that she can handle herself. He tries to reassure Will but Will wont listen. He seems to think that she is still all weak and needs protecting.

And sweet_Kat..hehe yeh we are going round in circles but its fun going round in circles. 💃

I don't think that script is real, some parts may be semi-possible, but for the most part I think it's fake.

but the thing that you read from the apparent script does make sense. if that is a part in the movie, it's probably something modefied from that form.

and it is fun going around in circles lol but it seemes we make a new point on each subject everytime we bring it back lol.

Yeah I have a feeling the script is fake too. But the guy seems pretty certain its not..If it is fake I hope Disney sues his ass.

and yeah we are picking up on more and more things. I just hope we are right.

Pirates=love...who's scarlett? 😕

Originally posted by LovelyOne

Pirates=love...who's scarlett? 😕

LOL That's what i'd like to know.

and the more things we pick up on, the more accurate we can be on our theories lol.

Originally posted by blackpearl44
LOL That's what i'd like to know.

and the more things we pick up on, the more accurate we can be on our theories lol.

I think she may mean Anna Maria 😂 Oh I just had a horrid thought. Maybe Disney are just teasing us with this Jack/Liz thing and they will go back to thir typical disney ways and end it with Will/Liz..then Anna Maria will appear right at the end or something..with their lame "everyone gets someone" ending. I hope not. I think most people would be really dissapointed at that..people want to see the LEADING LADY WITH THE LEADING MAN! JACK SPARROW

But yeh, lets keep finding things to back up our theories. There are too many things that suggest they wont end it like a typical disney movie.. With this film I think they are softening the blow (by slowly changing the characters priorities around) for a BIG BANG of an ending..and they better not dissapoint!

Yea, this is why I can't wait until the second movie is availible on DVD, then I can compare the 1st and 2nd side by side lol.And this is why I think they are changing will's priorities around also. to keep Jack the way he is, and let liz conform to his lifestyle, which is what she really wants. but as long as we can find peices of info to backup our theories. any one of them is possible. it will also be helpful when we get more legit info on the third movie.

"BIG ASS POSSIBLE SPOILER HERE
I heard that apparently Elizabeth’s dad is murdered by Norrington..This could mean that Disney are making it so all the ties to her old life have been cut. So she won’t be going back to it maybe? And that means she won’t be going back to Will unless he changes or something." (Lovely One)

^^ If this happened then I could see her turning Pirate for good and maybe going off with Jack.

However, I believe the only reason why she kissed Jack was because of the deal they had made. That Jack wasn't capable of doing anything good and that once he had done something good, she would do something bad.

Therefore, Jack comes back and saves everyone and she realizes he actually has done something good, so in return she kisses him (which is bad b/c she's with will).

I don't believe that she will end up with Jack. B/C Jack is Jack...all women slap him, he manages to piss them off and that's just his character.

I believe that Elizabeth is upset b/c the one time she had to do something bad (immoral) it wound up in the death of someone she admired greatly.

As for a future love between the two....I dont see it. I think they threw that in the movie to get us (the FANS) stirred up and waiting for #3.

As for Elizabeth becoming Pirate...she did it so she could escape and she had to blend in with the Pirate crew b/c she was going to save WILL...not Jack. It was also the only way for her to escape without beign seen since there was a bounty on her head. Obviously she couldn't just walk around with her dress on, she'd be spotted in no time.

Tia also mentioned that Will has a destiny (huge) that will play a big part--which may make him a hero in the end. I still believe that he will end up with Liz one way or another.

I think the writers may, make it look like they are going to split (Will & Liz) and have them arguing a lot in the next movie and then when the truth is revealed about why it happened, then all will be good!

Oh and about the compass.... it has something to do with Jack. The compass stopped working for Jack after his 13 yrs were up as the Captain of the Pearl then The Crackin' was to come for him, so whoever holds the compass it points to Jack b/c that's where the Crackin' needs to go to find him.

(This was said in the movie....also Tia had something to do with the compass I think b/c she knew alot about it and was surprised Jack didn't know it was the map to Davey's Heart)

However I think the writers/producers made it funny that it always pointed to Jack when Liz held it for some humor for the audience b/c Liz doesn't know that the compass will lead the Crackin' to Jack.....

JUST MY THOUGHTS..... I could be wrong. 🙂

The compass points to what your heart desires most....so you think it just happens to point to Jack everytime liz holds it, and that is broken? I don't think that is the case......

Will and Elizabeth have no choice but to engage in Piracy. They are wanted from that Lord who wanted the heart. They are never safe they way they were, so they are probably going to both engage in piracy.

Air Angel, I must disagree with you on the compass. The compass shows what your heart desires the most. In Elizabeth's case it points to Jack.

I believe the compass pointed to Jack because Elizabeth wanted Jack to be a good person at heart and not such the Pirate he was. That is probably wanted the most.

Matt

She knows jack can be a good person.....but liz is turining into something jack loves, and will dosn't, because will is preoccupied with his father, and was barely with liz in the 2nd movie.....and when he was he was just telling her to guard the chest (as i've already said, in the top post)

i love these circle discussions. hahaha. i am delighted that everyone has so much to say. 🙂
it would be VERY disney to stick liz and will back together and then throw annamaria at jack like "everybody gets someone". gee. how annoying would that be.
i think it was pretty obvious right from the start that liz's dad was going to die. that norrington does it is a nice twist. i like that. that will be really dramatic. the question is, who will get norrington?!

It wouldn't be a problem if they just wrote norrington out, obviously, Beckett is going to be the one causing all the trouble now.....norrington has lost everything...I don't think they should bring him back, but they might..and the main character, Jack, should get the main girl, liz, having them put Jack with a character we've barely even seen, would be worse than putting Jack with nobody lol will dosn't want to change, but liz is willing to, because she's tired of her old life, and will won't like it, and will is going to have his hands full with the father situation, and Jack and Liz will grow closer together, as liz and will grow farther apart......

Originally posted by katelovespirate
i love these circle discussions. hahaha. i am delighted that everyone has so much to say. 🙂
it would be VERY disney to stick liz and will back together and then throw annamaria at jack like "everybody gets someone". gee. how annoying would that be.
i think it was pretty obvious right from the start that liz's dad was going to die. that norrington does it is a nice twist. i like that. that will be really dramatic. the question is, who will get norrington?!

Yes, -.- I have feeling Disney will do that. Usually what they do. I think that Elizabeth's admires Jack and sees herself within him, so thats why she wants him to have a good heart because she wants to be a good person at heart. Possible theory -.-

Matt

No before i didnt mean Anna Maria i meant Scarlette or however you spell it... she slapped Jack in the first movie then the other girl slapped him....then in the second movie when Will was in Tortuga looking for JAck she said "give this to Jack for me" and slapped him

and i only say this bc i want Will and Liz together....and the fact shes on the cast list for the 3rd movie

oh gosh she is way too small a character to try to develope in one film... i hope they dont try to do that...

Why would they try to put Jack together with a person that hates him, and has no prominent role in the movie whatsoever?