Elizabeth: Who will she choose? (*Spoilers)

Originally posted by Shadow0fabandit
Will and Elizabeth have no choice but to engage in Piracy. They are wanted from that Lord who wanted the heart. They are never safe they way they were, so they are probably going to both engage in piracy.

Air Angel, I must disagree with you on the compass. The compass shows what your heart desires the most. In Elizabeth's case it points to Jack.

I believe the compass pointed to Jack because Elizabeth wanted Jack to be a good person at heart and not such the Pirate he was. That is probably wanted the most.

Matt

Think about it this way. Liz/Will relationship has not managed to develop any further in the current film but Jack/Liz has. Disney didnt just add in Will's father for no reason. He is there to be Will's main focus. Not elizabeth. There is hardly anything in this movie that suggests a bright future for Will and Liz even the wedding scene was gloomy and depressing plus he saw her before the wedding which signals bad luck. There is alot of stuff some subtle others not that symbolize Jack and Liz are meant to be throughout this movie. I find it hard to see anything suggesting Will and Liz in the future.

Jack is the leading man Liz is the leading lady...Will is the support actor. What usually happens in movies? The leading lady gets the leading man.

yah i agree. 🙂 i wish i was in charge of how this turns out

I know me too. I have a feeling they might be pressurised into going for the perfect fairy tale ending..I hope not. DISNEY break the mould for once!! there is a reason why you are going down hill. If you break the mould it may revive some positive opinions for you.
*just incase they read this forum lol*

But the perfect fairytale ending is not liz and will, because they won't be happy, they always have to be happy, Jack and liz together is the perfect ending, because they will be happy. that's what I think.

Originally posted by blackpearl44
But the perfect fairytale ending is not liz and will, because they won't be happy, they always have to be happy, Jack and liz together is the perfect ending, because they will be happy. that's what I think.

Very true actually. Liz's changing and all.

We still need a bit more character development from Jack when it comes to Liz. Might be in the 3rd movie. He's probably going to learn to treat her properly unlike all his other women he's had. and if his compass really was pointing to her when he held it, that means she is the one for him 🙂

Will is going to develop a father son relationship with his dad hopefully and not change into Mr pirate..His dad is might actually try and persuade Will not to be a pirate after what happened to him. He probably wont want his son to live dangerously like that.

Yea, there still needs to be a little bit more development between those two....but the deleted scenes from the 1st movie helped us alot. showing us the rest of the stuff that they applied in the movie, but didn't show it. But, we'll be able to figure out more when we get more info on the third movie.

But the deleted scene prolly had nothing to do with the second movie because disney prolly had no idea about what they were gonna do with a second movie or if there was even going to be one... i mean it took 3 years for the second to come out and its only going to be 9 months for the 3rd so in my opinion "clues about a relationship" from the deleted scenes are just people overly excited

Originally posted by Pirates= Love
But the deleted scene prolly had nothing to do with the second movie because disney prolly had no idea about what they were gonna do with a second movie or if there was even going to be one... i mean it took 3 years for the second to come out and its only going to be 9 months for the 3rd so in my opinion "clues about a relationship" from the deleted scenes are just people overly excited

The way I see it Disney thought back then it might have been too much to break the mould like that. So they stuck to happy ending and removed those scenes. But with the second movie you can see they dont care about expectations anymore when it comes to perfect endings. So they decided to add a bit more Jack.Liz

The public aren't going to be interested in it ending with Will all the time, its going to get boring Disney detected this and gave it a little twist with Jack/Liz. Will is not the overall fave actor he is the support actor..Keira is the leading lady and Jack is the leading man. The majority are going to want to see more of that relationship. IMO.

To be honet the only reason I became really interested in this franchise is becuase Disney broke the mould the second time round. I'm glad they did.. I really loved the first one but if they continued like that with the second then I would have probably lost interest (probably true for most of the audience)..This change disney has made is going to draw the audience back in for the third.

If you look at starwars for example, By the first one the audience thought that Luke and Layah were going to end up together. Lucas realized that Hans Solo had more of a chemistry with her and the audience liked that relationship she he changed it round and made him go with her instead of Luke.

When the first starwars was made Lucas didnt intend to make more so he ended it luke/layah to please the audience but as he made more he realised to keep the audience hooked he needed to make a more interesting relationship....similar to what happened with PotC, Jack and liz IMO

Its a classic trend with trilogies that they swap charactors priorities around.

*to quote scream here"

the first one sets the rules, The second bends the rules...the third? FORGET THE RULES

watch most trilogies and you see this happen. This is already true when you look at the first and second film.

I agree, once the 2nd film is released on dvd, watch both the first and the second movies, you can tell that is exactly what's happening.

YAY for happy logic, LovelyOne. What does IMO stand for???
if they care at all what the world thinks, they will go with jack. i'm a big supporter of CHEMISTRY.

Yes, I am a big supporter of chemistry too lol. therefore, a supporter of Jack.

You may be a supporter of Jack, but knowing Disney, it probably won't happen that way. We'll just have to wait 10 months and find out now won't we? I stick by my "ship" till the end.

Matt

I'm more inclined to think that Will and Elizabeth will end up together just because of Jack's character. I never saw Jack as being monogamous. I think he's too much of a free spirit to settle down, even if it were with a pirate. Throughout the movie, I just viewed Elizabeth's attraction to Jack as little more than a crush, and I still think that she's in love with Will.

Also, I'm not even sure the Elizabeth/Jack kiss was the writers' idea. In several interviews, Keira has said that she "begged" for a kiss with Johnny Depp, so they decided to give her one. I think the parts with the compass could have still been in the story, but I think they added the kiss later on.

Originally posted by JeSuisUnÉcumeur
I'm more inclined to think that Will and Elizabeth will end up together just because of Jack's character. I never saw Jack as being monogamous. I think he's too much of a free spirit to settle down, even if it were with a pirate. Throughout the movie, I just viewed Elizabeth's attraction to Jack as little more than a crush, and I still think that she's in love with Will.

I never thought Liz would be an untrustworthy sluttish Pirate but she did...The only character that is left to develop is Jack. Maybe the writers didnt want to give the relationship away that early on

Who will Liz choose

my money is on Jack... aahh..

I love Jack/Liz since the first movie... the stranded island scene

^^ Yea, me too, I've also liked the Jack /Liz thing since the first movie, into the second movie. And if Jack and liz get together, they won't settle down, because that would mean they both are not the "settle down" type, because Jack certainly isn't, and liz is developing into a character that is compatable with Jack.

And that was a really good scene....the island scene in the first movie.

heck yes it was, especially when viewed with the deleted scenes, inclduing the scene i had labled the "jack's sexy scars" scene.