cap vs spider-man

Started by xmarksthespot134 pages

Originally posted by Alfheim
*shrug* Ok fine.

So why did you give an example of a human being hit by 20 tons of strength? 😕

To parallel your statement. 😐

"All the best martial artists in the real world know how to punch, grapple and take damage from stronger opponents"

"All the best martial artists in the real world die when hit by someone whose 20 times stronger than them."

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
To parallel your statement. 😐

"All the best martial artists in the real world know how to punch, grapple and take damage from stronger opponents"

"All the best martial artists in the real world die when hit by someone whose 20 times stronger than them."

So in other words you are comparing the martial artists in the real world to Cap?

Originally posted by Alfheim
So in other words you are comparing the martial artists in the real world to Cap?
No I was extrapolating your comparison with a parallel statement. 😐

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
No I was extrapolating your comparison with a parallel statement. 😐

Yes but you misunderstood what I was saying. CA is a martial arts expert and Spiderman is not, therefore the skills of the martial artist in the real world are increased when given to CA in the MU.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Yes but you misunderstood what I was saying. CA is a martial arts expert and Spiderman is not, therefore the skills of the martial artist in the real world are increased when given to CA in the MU.
I understood what you're saying it just holds no water unless you are selectively amplifying martial arts and nothing else.

"All the best martial artists in the real world know how to punch, grapple and take damage from stronger opponents"

Real world martial artists have skills that allow them to fight stronger people, but of comparable strength.
Comic martial artists have amplified skills that allow them to fight stronger people, but of comparable strength.

Extrapolation of your statement can be done with this statement:

"All the best martial artists in the real world die when hit by someone whose 20 times stronger than them."

Real world martial artist still dies when hit by someone in the real world 20 times stronger than the real world martial artist.
Comic martial artist with amplified skills still dies when hit by someone in the comic world 20 times stronger than the amplified martial artist.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
I understood what you're saying it just holds no water unless you are selectively amplifying martial arts and nothing else.

"All the best martial artists in the real world know how to punch, grapple and take damage from stronger opponents"

Real world martial artists have skills that allow them to fight stronger people, but of comparable strength.
Comic martial artists have amplified skills that allow them to fight stronger people, but of comparable strength.

Extrapolation of your statement can be done with this statement:

"All the best martial artists in the real world die when hit by someone whose 20 times stronger than them."

Real world martial artist still dies when hit by someone in the real world 20 times stronger than the real world martial artist.
Comic martial artist with amplified skills still dies when hit by someone in the comic world 20 times stronger than the amplified martial artist.

They don't die, they dodge 😖hifty: Have you not seen Karate kid the movie 😠

Originally posted by xmarksthespot

Real world martial artist still dies when hit by someone in the real world 20 times stronger than the real world martial artist.
Comic martial artist with amplified skills still dies when hit by someone in the comic world 20 times stronger than the amplified martial artist.

Yes but the 2O times stronger person does not have martial arts skill. He can fight but he's not one of the best fighters in the world like Cap.

Originally posted by Ricodrayz
They don't die, they dodge 😖hifty: Have you not seen Karate kid the movie 😠
Daniel-san is in a league of his own.

Originally posted by xmarksthespot
Daniel-san is in a league of his own.
😆

Originally posted by Psyquis52
Strange...

I don't see agility or stamina on either of those.

I suppose stamina is redundant at this point but what's the deal with agility not being on there?
I know that Marvel used agility at one time because when you look up Spiderman they say he has a 6 and Captain America has a 5

AAAHHEMMMM!!!!!!

spiderman wins

Originally posted by The-Judge
spiderman wins

bash

GRRRR!!!!!

caps wins

Cap lays the Parker out.

Spider-man.

The Free Thinking American hero wins. The communist dies! Down with spiderman!

Spider-Man wins.

😕 Who started this thread again.....dont get me started *twitch* *twitch*

Originally posted by xmarksthespot

Real world martial artists have skills that allow them to fight stronger people, but of comparable strength.
Comic martial artists have amplified skills that allow them to fight stronger people, but of comparable strength.

Oh yeah I did not reply to this. Thats nonsense Comic martial artists can fight people alot more stronger than themselves.

You yourself admitted that humans in the MU are tougher, therefore the MA's should be tougher, so they should be able to fight people much stronger than themsleves.

Originally posted by Alfheim
Oh yeah I did not reply to this. Thats nonsense Comic martial artists can fight people alot more stronger than themselves

I really thought this was done with. Guess not. And yes, comic artists can fight people stronger than them, but the question here is can Cap win. He can't when he's up against someone so many times faster and stronger than he is