Ok sorry this is only lightsaber battle. I still say Sidious wins. Sidious took out four council members in seconds. If Kyle fought Kit, Tiin, and Kolar at the same time, i doubt he could have tooken them out in seconds. Windu beat him only because of his use of vapaad. Sidious fought on par with Yoda, who mastered all six forms of lightsaber combat, and even mastered ataru to its highest degree. Sidious also kept up with Yoda's speed.