Full potential anakin vs Marka ragnos

Vanity Fair magazine and DVD commentary

Youre missing the point lightsnake. A full potential Anakin would still be more powerful than Luke because at full potential he is the chosen one and the greatest force user ever.

Except he's not because Luke has his same exact potential. And is his son

Except for the fact that ANAKIN is the chosen one.

Except for the fact that it doesn't matter considering Lucas said they have the same potential

Except that doesn't matter because same potential doesn't necessarily equate to same strength.

Unfortunately, it does. They have the same potential. Meaning they could be exactly as storng.
Luke reached his potential. Anakin never did

"could" is far from definite. Force potential is just that. The same POTENTIAL.

Yes, and Luke's hit his potential. By what he does, it's obvious. Full potential Anakin is exactly the same as full Luke

When did Luke hit his potential exactly? We'd be comparing a Full potential Anakin to perhaps a LOTF Luke, who might not have hit his potential yet.

Who might not? The guy said to have become what anakin could have?

So Luke by LOTF became what Anakin should have become by ROTJ?

What Anakin should have become period

Go to your library and rent/check out "the making of Revenge of the Sith". GL clearly states that Anakin could have been the most powerful Jedi to ever live. I honestly, never heard Luke being able to become as powerful as Anakin.

PS. By RotS alone, Anakin was stronger then all but about two jedi, and him vs mace is occasionaly debated. Luke potental was extremely high, but no where near that of Anakins. Anakin was perfection. Padme' wasn't. Luke inherited that, so logic alone should tell you that gradually, the skywalker family would get weaker and weaker, for they weren't mating with other Force-born people.

Vanity fair. DVD. Lucas says Anakin and Luke had the same perfection.

This ends the argument. I'm trusting Lucas.

Originally posted by Xepeyon
Luke potental was extremely high, but no where near that of Anakins. Anakin was perfection. Padme' wasn't. Luke inherited that, so logic alone should tell you that gradually, the skywalker family would get weaker and weaker, for they weren't mating with other Force-born people.

Wait, so Anakin got none of his own mothers traits? Or was Shmi perfection, too?

Anakin was created solely by the force. She had nothing to do with it, otherwise he be called The Perfect Being. She herself says; "I can't explain what happened".

So, she didn't give birth, he just appeared?

When a missle is shot out of a plane, did the plane create it? When a bullet is shot out of a gun, did the gun create the bullet?

No...

Horrible example though?

So, Anakin only gave his genetic material to Luke, because, he is the living embodiment of the force, and for some reason, the pregnant one doesn't count...