Originally posted by Myth
What do you guys think of the all-star reserves selections? I think they were shit. If anybody watched TNT Thursday, I agree with Barkley's statements on the picks. As good as they are, Vince Carter and Rip Hamilton should not have made the team. The Nets are below .500 and definitely do not deserve 2 all-stars. Kidd is playing out of his mind right now, so he is the obvious choice from the Nets. In Carter's place should have been Okafor. The Pistons are doing pretty well and potentially are deserving of 2 all-stars, but not when the Bulls are doing about the same as the Pistons and they don't get any all-stars. Ben Gordon should have been selected over Rip.In the West, it is a little tougher because all the talent out west. But Dallas should have gotten 2 all-stars with the way Josh Howard is playing. The hard part is deciding who should have been left off. The Suns have 3 guys going, and all three guys are great, but its hard to say if they should have 3 going while Dallas only has 1. Maybe Tony Parker should have been left off. Howard is at least playing on Parker's level while his team is doing better. As deserving as the Spurs are to have 2 all-stars, Dallas earned it more.
Well, in the East you know I'm going to be biased, and say Rip over Gordon, Rip should be given the benefit of the doubt since year in, and year out he has played at or close to the same level he plays every year. I am with you on Okafor tho, and he is deserving to play in AllStar, but I think realistically, Gordan would have a better chance getting in over Rip, than Okafor did getting in over Carter, even tho Carter deserves it the least.
I think Ray Allen was snubbed more than Josh Howard, yea, Josh Howard is playing great, and has been playing great for Dallas, but he isn't carrying that team, and he benefits alot from Dirk, while Allen doesn't have the depth, talent, or coaching Dallas has, he's still plays at a very high level, and the players on Seattle benefit from him.