Originally posted by Myth
The biggest problem I have with Nash getting MVP is simply that he is a defensive handicap. MVPs are superstars that can dominate games in 3 or more ways. Not just in one way. I like Nash. He is definitely a star player. But he is no superstar.
Im really not trying to argue about this i think we just have different opinions on this one. A player can dominate in 3 or more ways and still not lift his team to the next level (LeBron is the prime example - not his fault i might add). I think the MVP should be exactly that, not the player with the best stats but the one who is the most valuable to his team. Nash and Shaq have been head and shoulders above the competition this year and it came down to those two.