ESB Luke vs. Qui-Gon Jinn

TPM Qui-Gon vs. ESB Luke in his prime. I know Qui-Gon would own him but Master Vos thinks that Qui-Gon's only slightly stornger than ESB Luke so I want to prove him wrong. Tell me people, does Qui-Gon own ESB Luke?

Qui-Gon pwns while drinking martini's with his old master.

I voted that Qui-Gon owns but not to badly. I remmeber I made a ROTJ Qui-Gon vs. ROTJ Luke thread a while back and most people thought Qui-Gon would win, personally I'd say Qui-Gon and ROTJ Luke are equals.

Well Qui-Gon managed to hold his own against Maul twice in TPM. ESB Luke would get wtf pwned by Maul - in fact Maul could probably win without his saber. Luke goes down - hard.

Yeah, Maul vs. ESB Luke without Maul using his saber would be close but Maul might win. And Qui-Gon held off Maul but wasn't as storng as Maul was.

Qui-Gon owns ESB Luke, but not ROTJ Luke, that one wtfpwns Qui-Gon.

ESB Luke wasn't that well trained, a nublet, Qui-Gon was one of the greatest Masters ever, with a lot of experience

Jinn defeats Luke, easily.

Qui-Gon owns ESB Luke, but not ROTJ Luke, that one wtfpwns Qui-Gon.

ESB Luke loses to Qui-Gon but not by much.

Look guys, Qui-Gon Jinn was an experienced and classically trained Jedi Knight, Master, in fact. He could mop the floor with ESB Luke with his eyes closed.

Qui-Gon wins easily, in one move.

Right....I'm sure...Luke would give Qui-Gon a nice run for his money.

Originally posted by Quinlan_Vos
Right....I'm sure...Luke would give Qui-Gon a nice run for his money.

Yeah, mabye in a game of baseball. 😛

Qui-Gon is not much more powerful than Luke. I say Qui-Gon wins closely or made in the rare scenario, Qui-Gon owns but not too badly.

Qui-Gon, especially against ESB, is alot more skilled and powerful than Luke.
In this scenario he is a Jedi Master, whilst Luke is barely a half-trained apprentice.

So, Qui-Gon beats Luke.

Very, Very easily and very, very badly.

Is there any particular reason you like think ESB Luke will do well Quinlan? Because you are starting to sound like me in some of the Count Dooku threads - unable to accept the fact that he will lose. 😉

Originally posted by darthsith19
Woah, woah, woah. Wait a minute, so you think Qui-Gon owns ESB Luke but ROTJ Luke wtf pwns Qui-Gon? How much stronger do you think Luke got during the six months between ESB and ROTJ? Six times as strong?

Luke was leet in ROTJ, he beat Vader for goodness sakes, much more controlled, and I don't think it's 6 months, probably closer to a year or 2. Luke has the whole Chosen One thing going for him(I consider Luke the Chosen One) so that equals great increase in Power, Anakin did it

Originally posted by Darth Kreiger
Luke was leet in ROTJ, he beat Vader for goodness sakes, much more controlled, and I don't think it's 6 months, probably closer to a year or 2. Luke has the whole Chosen One thing going for him(I consider Luke the Chosen One) so that equals great increase in Power, Anakin did it

All I have to say is LOL to the "Luke is the Chosen One" part.

But Qui-Gon WTFpwns Luke

Qui-Gonn would leave footprints in Luke's ass.

Originally posted by Darth Kreiger
Luke was leet in ROTJ, he beat Vader for goodness sakes, much more controlled, and I don't think it's 6 months, probably closer to a year or 2. Luke has the whole Chosen One thing going for him(I consider Luke the Chosen One) so that equals great increase in Power, Anakin did it

Originally posted by Rampant ox
Is there any particular reason you like think ESB Luke will do well Quinlan? Because you are starting to sound like me in some of the Count Dooku threads - unable to accept the fact that he will lose. 😉

Hey, very witty Rampant. 😉