Doc Samson vs. Spiderman

Started by h1a87 pages

Originally posted by tkitna
Samson probably doesnt have any more or any less than any of the villians your talking about. He shouldnt need it. Also, Samson doesnt need to keep up or see fired bullets,,,,they cant harm him. thats my point.

My point was that, no amount of smarts sampson can have in order to see spiderman clearly. That means he won't be able to hit spidey no matter how smart he is (due to spidey's speed and sense). That also means he can't prevent spidey from hitting him no matter how smart he is.

The Hulk didnt hit Spiderman either in the scans posted above, but yet Spiderman was on the ground and ready to die in a matter of seconds until Samson saved him. i imagine Samson could operate in that same fashion.

This is because Hulk used his famous thunderclap and didn't actually physically hit him (Even though that would be PIS if he did). Sampson will need to be at least class 100 to perform an effective thunderclap against spidey.

I admit that Spiderman can cut his hair, but I cant or wont admit that he doesnt need to.

I don't see why you can't admit that he doesn't need to. Spidey will see Sampson moving in super slow motion (though Spidey don't even need to see him since his sense will easily guide him out of the way).

Spidey simply cannot be hit by sampson and sampson cannot stop spidey from doing the "Maximum Spider" super combo finish on him. Nuff said! 😉

Originally posted by tkitna
How is it pathetic? I agree Spidey is durable, but nothing like the durability of Samson and Spiderman has supposedly taken down the Hulk (still interested in those scans). I'm just looking at the comparisons here.

No one is agruning Samson's durability and strength. Everyone here admits Samson has the ups on those two. But thats it. Spider-Man has everything else going for him in spades.

I'm at work now so those scan's will have to wait till I get back home. They are forthcoming though

Originally posted by tkitna
Well, the Hulk did get busted into a building by Samson, but to be honest with you, no, I dont believe the hulk was being to bothered by either of them.

Thats right. Lets not forget to mention that the Hulk in the fight with Spidey and Samson was stronger than normal but the one in the pic you put up was weaker than normal. Just something to think about

Originally posted by tkitna
A hair net? 😮

I wonder if a gamma fortifying shampoo would work to strengthen his follicles. lol

Spiderman wins. All Samson has is super strength and durability, im sure the Doc is smart but so is Spiderman. Spiderman has that as well as super speed, webbing and stealth mode.

Spiderman 10/10

i dont see why it's soo hard to admit that spider-man can beat samson, im not even saying samson wont put up a good fight, but in the end spiderman as the more versital character should win out 9/10

Hi new poster here :

Doc Samson is traditionally listed as strong as a calm hulk. Which is about the 80-85 ton range. He did for a while had a weakness against having his hair cut, and yet in various pictures his hair is MUCH shorter (especially in his red costume). Gamma empowerment tends to incorporate subconscious tendencies, desires or fears into the form taken. Doctor Leonard Samson is jewish, and one would think therefore VERY aware of his namesake. Again, citing the occasions where he's had his hair shorter, this factor no longer seems an issue with regards to his strength.

That was point 1. About the hair yanking strategem.

Point 2 : 'Doc couldn't touch him'. MarvelPrince posted (and thank you) the following image : hulkvsspidey8al9.gif ... Hulk struck the ground and the shockwave/shrapnel from the hit knocked Spidey silly. Doc's not strong enough to do this? I think he is. While not quite class 100, he can certainly manage a ground strike. And Doc is smart enough to do this, whereas the Hulk probably just pounded the ground out of anger or frustration.

I love Spidey and I like Doc. But Doc COULD beat Spidey if he resorted to a series of ground strikes. Not sure if he could do the hulk sonic hand clap, but that would also be effective. Spidey doesn't wear ear plugs, as far as I know, though he could surely web some up.

On the other hand, Spidey might just keep webbing Doc's eyes and mouth repeatedly and keep punching him. He might be strong enough to pull the webbing off, but off his EYELIDS?? ouch!

I'd give it about a 50/50. Depends how quickly and IF Doc thought to do ground strikes.

Originally posted by malhavok
Hi new poster here :

Doc Samson is traditionally listed as strong as a calm hulk. Which is about the 80-85 ton range. He did for a while had a weakness against having his hair cut, and yet in various pictures his hair is MUCH shorter (especially in his red costume). Gamma empowerment tends to incorporate subconscious tendencies, desires or fears into the form taken. Doctor Leonard Samson is jewish, and one would think therefore VERY aware of his namesake. Again, citing the occasions where he's had his hair shorter, this factor no longer seems an issue with regards to his strength.

That was point 1. About the hair yanking strategem.

Point 2 : 'Doc couldn't touch him'. MarvelPrince posted (and thank you) the following image : hulkvsspidey8al9.gif ... Hulk struck the ground and the shockwave/shrapnel from the hit knocked Spidey silly. Doc's not strong enough to do this? I think he is. While not quite class 100, he can certainly manage a ground strike. And Doc is smart enough to do this, whereas the Hulk probably just pounded the ground out of anger or frustration.

I love Spidey and I like Doc. But Doc COULD beat Spidey if he resorted to a series of ground strikes. Not sure if he could do the hulk sonic hand clap, but that would also be effective. Spidey doesn't wear ear plugs, as far as I know, though he could surely web some up.

On the other hand, Spidey might just keep webbing Doc's eyes and mouth repeatedly and keep punching him. He might be strong enough to pull the webbing off, but off his EYELIDS?? ouch!

I'd give it about a 50/50. Depends how quickly and IF Doc thought to do ground strikes.

It's about time we get some new, logical posters with well-thought debates. Kudos, my friend. And welcome.

You can teach a lot of these people here. Hell, you can teach a lot of the senior posters some things about debating.

Originally posted by malhavok
Hi new poster here :

Doc Samson is traditionally listed as strong as a calm hulk. Which is about the 80-85 ton range. He did for a while had a weakness against having his hair cut, and yet in various pictures his hair is MUCH shorter (especially in his red costume). Gamma empowerment tends to incorporate subconscious tendencies, desires or fears into the form taken. Doctor Leonard Samson is jewish, and one would think therefore VERY aware of his namesake. Again, citing the occasions where he's had his hair shorter, this factor no longer seems an issue with regards to his strength.

That was point 1. About the hair yanking strategem.

Point 2 : 'Doc couldn't touch him'. MarvelPrince posted (and thank you) the following image : hulkvsspidey8al9.gif ... Hulk struck the ground and the shockwave/shrapnel from the hit knocked Spidey silly. Doc's not strong enough to do this? I think he is. While not quite class 100, he can certainly manage a ground strike. And Doc is smart enough to do this, whereas the Hulk probably just pounded the ground out of anger or frustration.

I love Spidey and I like Doc. But Doc COULD beat Spidey if he resorted to a series of ground strikes. Not sure if he could do the hulk sonic hand clap, but that would also be effective. Spidey doesn't wear ear plugs, as far as I know, though he could surely web some up.

On the other hand, Spidey might just keep webbing Doc's eyes and mouth repeatedly and keep punching him. He might be strong enough to pull the webbing off, but off his EYELIDS?? ouch!

I'd give it about a 50/50. Depends how quickly and IF Doc thought to do ground strikes.

You make good sense.
But i'm afraid that some unofficial sources have Doc Samson at about 70 tons strength (slightly below that of calm hulk which is 70tons and not 80-85 tons).
But the official sources, from the guys who write about Doc Samson, Marvel writers themselves, say that he can lift up to 25 tons. You wouldn't dare argue with them now would you? 😕
With that said, Hulk's strength at that time he hit the ground was on a ridiculous level (way above 100 tons). I doubt seriously that samson can generate 1/100 of the force Hulk generated when he hit the ground (since he lacks the strength and his hand would probably hurt too much). Thus proving that tactic ineffective.

Originally posted by malhavok
Hi new poster here :

Doc Samson is traditionally listed as strong as a calm hulk. Which is about the 80-85 ton range. He did for a while had a weakness against having his hair cut, and yet in various pictures his hair is MUCH shorter (especially in his red costume). Gamma empowerment tends to incorporate subconscious tendencies, desires or fears into the form taken. Doctor Leonard Samson is jewish, and one would think therefore VERY aware of his namesake. Again, citing the occasions where he's had his hair shorter, this factor no longer seems an issue with regards to his strength.

That was point 1. About the hair yanking strategem.

Point 2 : 'Doc couldn't touch him'. MarvelPrince posted (and thank you) the following image : hulkvsspidey8al9.gif ... Hulk struck the ground and the shockwave/shrapnel from the hit knocked Spidey silly. Doc's not strong enough to do this? I think he is. While not quite class 100, he can certainly manage a ground strike. And Doc is smart enough to do this, whereas the Hulk probably just pounded the ground out of anger or frustration.

I love Spidey and I like Doc. But Doc COULD beat Spidey if he resorted to a series of ground strikes. Not sure if he could do the hulk sonic hand clap, but that would also be effective. Spidey doesn't wear ear plugs, as far as I know, though he could surely web some up.

On the other hand, Spidey might just keep webbing Doc's eyes and mouth repeatedly and keep punching him. He might be strong enough to pull the webbing off, but off his EYELIDS?? ouch!

I'd give it about a 50/50. Depends how quickly and IF Doc thought to do ground strikes.

Been a while since I've seen intelligent thought out posts like this. A few points though. Doc Samson did have short hair for a while but IIRC that was time when his body was further radiated. For all the appearances I've seen his strength still depended on his hair length. If this has been changed (I didn't read his last mini so it cut have been addressed there) then I'll retract my statement.

No prob with the images. About the feat remember that Hulk was far stronger than normal Hulk. He is definitely out of the good doctor's strength level. I doubt he could produce a wave of such intensity with his strength.

Ground strikes could work, but remember Spider-Man doesn't really stay on the ground. If Doc goes for ground strikes he'll adapt. Take to web swinging or even jumping and gliding with his new costume. I think his sonic, while weaker than Hulk's, would be an effective weapon. Effective long range. If Spider-Man is up close then Samson isn't gonna get a chance to pull back his hands for a clap.

Its not a curbstop but I think Spider-Man wins the majority here. Doc Samson really just has his strength and Spider-Man has bought down stronger

wolverine took out spider-man already and he did took down the hulk and hulk is stronger then samson so wolverine can beat them both

Originally posted by wolvertooth
wolverine took out spider-man already and he did took down the hulk and hulk is stronger then samson so wolverine can beat them both

When did Wolverine ever definitivly beat Spider-Man?

new avengers he owned spider-man

Originally posted by wolvertooth
new avengers he owned spider-man

Are you talking about that stab that was in ASM? And Wolverine didn't own him, he was getting the crud kicked outta him after he stabbed Parker untill Iron Man pulled him off, I wouldn't call that an ownage, especialy since wolverine shouldnt have even been able to pull out the webbing the way he was webbed.

Originally posted by wolvertooth
new avengers he owned spider-man

They have NEVER fought in New Avengers. Unless you mean in Marvel Knights where they were sparing and Logan stabbed him. While they were sparring. When they weren't really fighting. You get it. And after than Spider-Man kicked the crap out of Logan till Tony pulled him off.

Later though Spider-Man punches Logan through supposedly unbreakable glass out the Tower.

In Spider-Man vs Wolverine Peter is putting Logan's head through tombstones and sees a way to kill Logan but decides that he won't kill.

In Marvel Team Up Spider-Man simply webs him up in an alley with his fists to his head.

Pure and utter Spider-Ownagge

I stand partially corrected.

The Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe Deluxe Edition lists the calm hulk's strength at 70 tons. However, the OHOTMUDE update '89 clarifies the GRAY hulk's calm strength at 70 tons, and the GREEN hulk's calm strength at 85-90 tons. Now, the OHOTMUDE does list Doc Samson's strength at 25 tons, and doubtless what the writers are quoting. Though they certainly portray him as being much stronger. EARLIER editions DO list Doc as having a strength equal to a calm hulk. Formerly listed as 70 tons, though later clarified for the green hulk. But even the writers of the OHOTMUDE do not claim it's perfect, and made great efforts to clarify errors. A brilliant piece of work, and I am a huge fan. Another example of underestimation would probably go to Iron Man in the OHOTMUDE, in which his armor is said to ampify the wearer's strength by a factor of 90. IF Tony Stark could lift 300 pounds above his head, then the armor would give him a strength level about 13.5 tons without rerouting power. And I think it was more impressive than that. I tend to stick by the estimation of Doc having about a 70 ton strength, perhaps a bit more. He did steal his strength from the green hulk and not the gray. Someone with only a 25 ton strength wouldn't even cause the hulk to notice (without compensatory speed like spidey has). It'd be Rick Moranis vs Hulk Hogan (the other hulk). And Doc Samson definitely puts up a better fight than that ... though he ALWAYS loses in the end, barring the occassional sucker punch.

some very nice debats here...now then i think i can really get started with my argument, while doc samson physiclly is no diffrent from any other tanker spidy has taken down he has several strengths the others did not, for one he has no intent of murdering spidy and he is a WHOLE lot more mentally stable not to mention smart and able to think on his feet so spiderman would have a hard time out thinking him in a situation like this, spiderman fights in 3 diffrent ways either relying on his strenghts as the spider (his powers abilities and instints) the man (his street smarts and scientific knowlage) or the spider/man combo (self explanitory) useing any one of the 2 latter spidy wont win but using the fromer he can spiderman's versitlity makes him one of the hardest people to contend with in marvel

Re: I stand partially corrected.

Originally posted by malhavok
The Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe Deluxe Edition lists the calm hulk's strength at 70 tons. However, the OHOTMUDE update '89 clarifies the GRAY hulk's calm strength at 70 tons, and the GREEN hulk's calm strength at 85-90 tons. Now, the OHOTMUDE does list Doc Samson's strength at 25 tons, and doubtless what the writers are quoting. Though they certainly portray him as being much stronger. EARLIER editions DO list Doc as having a strength equal to a calm hulk. Formerly listed as 70 tons, though later clarified for the green hulk. But even the writers of the OHOTMUDE do not claim it's perfect, and made great efforts to clarify errors. A brilliant piece of work, and I am a huge fan. Another example of underestimation would probably go to Iron Man in the OHOTMUDE, in which his armor is said to ampify the wearer's strength by a factor of 90. IF Tony Stark could lift 300 pounds above his head, then the armor would give him a strength level about 13.5 tons without rerouting power. And I think it was more impressive than that. I tend to stick by the estimation of Doc having about a 70 ton strength, perhaps a bit more. He did steal his strength from the green hulk and not the gray. Someone with only a 25 ton strength wouldn't even cause the hulk to notice (without compensatory speed like spidey has). It'd be Rick Moranis vs Hulk Hogan (the other hulk). And Doc Samson definitely puts up a better fight than that ... though he ALWAYS loses in the end, barring the occassional sucker punch.

Great stuff dude!
But there are some things you need to know (if you didn't realize already).
Many characters have went through upgrades and downgrades in powers and abilities over the years without explanation. This has been done seamlessly throughout their history in the comics. Many say that Marvel comics are in continuity. Well I disagree. Doc Samson is a perfectly good reason for this too. There has been characters in comics whose abilities contradicted other comics. That is why I went to Marvel.
If you go here and click on
1.10 How do you go about writing each profile? :
http://www.marvel.com/universe/OHOTMU:FAQ#How_do_you_go_about_writing_each_profile.3F

then you can see how they go about updating each character.
I believe threaders should clarify which version (golden age, current, etc.) of a character (only the ones who have many contradictions in their abilities in comics) that the thread is about.

Also Force=mass x acceleration. That means Samson (with 25 ton strength)can punch with roughly the same speed as spidey (but with way more mass) since he can generate the necessary acceleration. Thus making his punch something for Hulk to notice. Even Cap has caused Hulk and other class 100 guys notice with his kicks (Not that it is realistic but just to be consistent for Doc Samson).

Lastly, if you read at the sight I gave you above then you will see that the writers of the official handbooks go through nearly the entire history of a character (without consulting the original writers) before stating their abilities (That is why Doc Samson was first listed as 70 tons). But if there are any discrepencies (or contradictory showings) with a character then the writers go to the original writers to settle the discrepencies. Thus that is why, currently, Doc Samson is listed as 25 tons even though he may have shown more strength at times in the past. Many of these discrepencies are due to the writer's faulty scientific reasoning. For example, the writer may not know that a particular feat in which they want to show the character doing will exceed that character's originally created (or defined) level of power because of scientific ignorance.

Originally posted by marvelprince
They have NEVER fought in New Avengers. Unless you mean in Marvel Knights where they were sparing and Logan stabbed him. While they were sparring. When they weren't really fighting. You get it. And after than Spider-Man kicked the crap out of Logan till Tony pulled him off.

Later though Spider-Man punches Logan through supposedly unbreakable glass out the Tower.

In Spider-Man vs Wolverine Peter is putting Logan's head through tombstones and sees a way to kill Logan but decides that he won't kill.

In Marvel Team Up Spider-Man simply webs him up in an alley with his fists to his head.

Pure and utter Spider-Ownagge

😄 😄 😄 😄 😄

Re: Re: I stand partially corrected.

Originally posted by h1a8
Great stuff dude!
But there are some things you need to know (if you didn't realize already).
Many characters have went through upgrades and downgrades in powers and abilities over the years without explanation. This has been done seamlessly throughout their history in the comics. Many say that Marvel comics are in continuity. Well I disagree. Doc Samson is a perfectly good reason for this too. There has been characters in comics whose abilities contradicted other comics. That is why I went to Marvel.
If you go here and click on
1.10 How do you go about writing each profile? :
http://www.marvel.com/universe/OHOTMU:FAQ#How_do_you_go_about_writing_each_profile.3F

then you can see how they go about updating each character.
I believe threaders should clarify which version (golden age, current, etc.) of a character (only the ones who have many contradictions in their abilities in comics) that the thread is about.

Also Force=mass x acceleration. That means Samson (with 25 ton strength)can punch with roughly the same speed as spidey (but with way more mass) since he can generate the necessary acceleration. Thus making his punch something for Hulk to notice. Even Cap has cause Hulk and other class 100 guys notice with his kicks (Not that it is realistic but just to be consistent for Doc Samson).

Lastly, if you read at the sight I gave you above then you will see that the writers of the official handbooks go through nearly the entire history of a character before stating their abilities (That is why Doc Samson was first listed as 70 tons). But if there are any discrepencies (or contradictory showings) with a character then the writers go to the original writers to settle the discrepencies. Thus that is why the current Doc Samson is listed as 25 tons even though he may have shown more strength at times in the past. Many of these discrepencies are due to the writer's faulty scientific reasoning.


wow very through i have no complaints

Excellent link and post. Very cool and well thought out. Though I still contend that in his appearances that Doc is 'portrayed' at the 70 ton range. Shehulk, who is listed as 75 tons can leap 1000 feet. Doc, who WAS listed at 70 tons was listed also in the OHOTMUDE as being able to leap 910 feet. Pretty comparable, I think. And why I'd rank him at 70 tons rather than 85-90 tons upon retrospection. Also anyone laying the smack down on Rhino so easily does NOT have a normal 25 ton strength.

Now, you may argue physics ... but physics has little to do with the powerhouses of the marvel universe or most universes. If so, the only way the powerhouses with dense flesh could hurt each other would be by grappling. The speed of the punch and their own body mass would be insufficient to hurt each other. The most they'd ever do would be to bounce off each other like croquet balls. If physics truly was a major factor, spidey could beat ANYONE. As his feet would stay matted to the ground and his punch would send anyone without a similar power flying. One must assume that the powerhouses in the marvel universe have some subconscious telekinesis or the like preventing them from making fools of themselves. (Pictures Rhino and Hulk crashing into each other, then bouncing about like a pinballs).

So, on the strength issue, I guess we'll have to agree to disagree.

But to get back to my original thought, ground strikes or sonic claps would probably be the only way to stop spidey. Smacking his fist into the concrete would probably work well, because the stone shard shrapnel would do serious damage to someone without dense flesh. (I've worked with a pick before on stone, and the flying stone chips are h*ll). Anyway, take care and thanks for the intelligent discussion and debate.

Originally posted by malhavok
Excellent link and post. Very cool and well thought out. Though I still contend that in his appearances that Doc is 'portrayed' at the 70 ton range. Shehulk, who is listed as 75 tons can leap 1000 feet. Doc, who WAS listed at 70 tons was listed also in the OHOTMUDE as being able to leap 910 feet. Pretty comparable, I think. And why I'd rank him at 70 tons rather than 85-90 tons upon retrospection. Also anyone laying the smack down on Rhino so easily does NOT have a normal 25 ton strength.

Now, you may argue physics ... but physics has little to do with the powerhouses of the marvel universe or most universes. If so, the only way the powerhouses with dense flesh could hurt each other would be by grappling. The speed of the punch and their own body mass would be insufficient to hurt each other. The most they'd ever do would be to bounce off each other like croquet balls. If physics truly was a major factor, spidey could beat ANYONE. As his feet would stay matted to the ground and his punch would send anyone without a similar power flying. One must assume that the powerhouses in the marvel universe have some subconscious telekinesis or the like preventing them from making fools of themselves. (Pictures Rhino and Hulk crashing into each other, then bouncing about like a pinballs).

So, on the strength issue, I guess we'll have to agree to disagree.

But to get back to my original thought, ground strikes or sonic claps would probably be the only way to stop spidey. Smacking his fist into the concrete would probably work well, because the stone shard shrapnel would do serious damage to someone without dense flesh. (I've worked with a pick before on stone, and the flying stone chips are h*ll). Anyway, take care and thanks for the intelligent discussion and debate.

Yes, a 25 ton strength foe can lack a smackdown on much stronger foes (such as Rhino). Cap, bats, and wolverine have been hurting very high class strength dudes for years with their kicks alone. From that simple fact, hitting power doesn't truly estimate over the head pressing power. Since those guys can't even generate more than 3 tons of force. Yet their strikes are quite effective.

It all depends on where a character strikes a foe anyway. In comics, for some reason, the head seems to be the most vulnerable spot in the whole body. Hulk, Thing, etc. has taken some pretty serious things before yet they have been knock out by foes with much lower strength than them.

I don't believe Samson was consistently shown to press overhead more than 25 tons (maybe not at all). But many has estimated his strength from the type of foes he has hurt and owned before.
This is faulty since many characters such as Luke Cage, Spiderman, Captain America, Batman, Wolverine, etc. has been hurting and knocking out much higher strength class foes for years in which they were no where near these foe's strength.

Durability and Strength are two different things (even though the more strength one has the more durability they need to support that strength)
It is faulty to assume that a class 75-100 being should automatically withstand (without sustaining any damage or being knocked out) physical strikes from much lower strength foes. Again, this has been shown countless times by many characters.

With 25 tons strength (I believe Marvel), there is no way samson can perform a decent enough thunderclap either a ground attack. With 70 tons strength (which I think is falsely estimated from comics), samson also isn't strong enough to produce a groundattack that is faster and powerful enough for spidey to avoid. Hulk's strength when he did it was at least over 1,000 tons (as he was more and more enraged in the battle). Spidey has super speed and spider sense (his greatest power). He has dodge bullets and lasers (speed of light) that was homed to him like a day job. He has leaped, horizontally, hundreds of feet in the air while twisting, turning, and contortioning his body to avoid bullets and other fast attacks many times.

With spiderman's abilities, I considered it PIS that he got hit by Hulk's ground attack. Especially since Hulk punches much faster and was at a closer range and spidey was still able to easily dodge. No way in the heck can samson hit spidey with a ground attack (Even though he is not strong enough to initiate a decent enough one). Spider will simply leap at Samson at super speed and "Maximum Spider" ultimate combo finish him while he attempts such an attack.

Lastly, with 25 ton strength, a thunderclap from samson isn't going to do anything. Samson has never used it in all of his history. I believe writers knew he wasn't strong enough to produce an effective thunderclap. That is probably why you never seen it from him. Also, since spidey is faster and is around 20ton strength then he should be able to duplicate a samson's non effective thunderclap too (since speed is needed more than strength anyway in a thunderclap).