potc3... let's map out what we know.

Started by LovelyOne15 pages

that whole scene on the pearl with gibbs talking about mother's son..the letters of marque etc..the persuade me scene. I think that is all one huge hint of Jack's and Lizzies future togetehr.

1. i still dont think tia and beckett are in league, but i could be totally wrong. i was just implying that Beckett has back knowledge. Beckett knows a lot more about Jack and our other characters than makes sense. ya know what i mean? it makes me think he will try to pit will and jack against each other on purpose, because he sees the love triangle more clearly than any of them do. does Liz fall back into Beckett's hands>?

2. that all makes a lot of sense about throwing in the kid scene and then making 4 a "fill in the 10 year gap" thing. i always wondered what the heck they were talking about with "reinvention"... but if they are planning on having a significant time jump towards the end of 3, that would make perfect sense... to show where each character is, and then go back in subsequent films and fill in those holes. lol. i would really enjoy that actually.

and that would also clear up how they plan on solving the love triangle in an absolute way, while still making room for more films.

either way, i think orlando would be a part of more films, even if its just a cameo here or there. he does bring in the teenage girl audience.

apparantly the dude who plays barbossa just had an interview in which he says there are 12 (yes, count em, TWELVE) plot lines that come together in one epic battle sequence that puts Ben Hur to shame. EXCITING!!!!!

so let's see... what could the 12 be?

1. will saving dad
2. jack and barbossa's battle for the pearl
3. beckett and the eitc trying to stamp out piracy
4. pirate brethran trying to fight eitc
5. pintel and ragetti trying to get rich
6. everyone trying to kill davy jones
7. norrington's redemption
8. jack reconciling with his father
9. tia dalma being revealed as calypso
10. Liz revealing where her heart truly lies
11. sao feng and crew wanting revenge
12. who's becoming next captain of fd.

wow, i could actually go on with this list. talk about a complicated plot. gee.

by the way, here's a funny version of the 12 plots from worplayer:

Guaranteed 97.3% accurate.

1) Everyone hunts for Jack, and they find him. He's alive!

2) Everyone then sails to Florida, where they rob the state's first bank, in a clever caper involving parrots and a fake wooden leg.

3) Everyone heads to Miami Beach for Spring Break. Barbossa wins the wet t-shirt contest. Jack gets drunk.

4) Jack and Will become private eyes, and save Davy Jones from being kidnapped by a Chinese restaurant and served as 70 or 80 appetizers.

5) An Asian gang comes to kidnap Elizabeth. Lots of chop-socky action ensews. Elizabeth wields nunchuks in her underwear. Barbossa loses a foot. Jack gets drunk.

6) Road trip! They need to go find Will's Mom. On the way everyone bonds. Will's Mom is about to lose her land to taxes, so they put on a show. Will and Jack sing a duet of "It's Raining Men".

7) Vegas! Jack dallies with several hookers, and gets syphilis, but Norrington shows up and invents penicillin.

8) California. Partying on another ocean. Surfs up! Jack gets drunk.

9) They steal a ship, and sail to Alaska, where the endangered green seal is being menaced by poachers. They save the seals, but then accidentally eat them all. Jack gets drunk.

10) Jack goes into rehab, and flashes back to his days as little Jack, when at 8 years old he used to make pirate copies of Abe Lincoln's sex tapes. Christopher Walken guest stars as Abe.

11) Out of rehab, Jack, Will and Elizabeth join the circus. Mayhem ensues, 62% of it involving elephants.

12) Jack and Will finally give in to the love that dare not speak its name. Elizabeth gets drunk, and goes off with Norrington.

I think 2 are going to involve Liz.one she will reveal where her heart lies..but that will be FAKE,,then she is going to show us who she really belongs with, gonna be Jack. I bet you.

Kate how can beckett know what will happen if he seperates Jack/Liz he has no powers to see into the future yet he seems to know that she will fall for Jack...so does Tia.

Yeah...I'm beginning to believe you LovelyOne...cuz something in that interview I saw of Naomi Harris...something she said made me think that she and Beckett may be in cohoots...that she knows whats going on with everyone and that she can see into people's hearts...that Pirates come to her when they are in trouble...maybe Beckett knew this and disguised himself as a Pirate or something and went to her and got info..or maybe there's a mole....maybe Barbossa...don't know thinking randomnly....

There is a very easy explanation to why Beckett taunts Liz about Jack that doesn't involve Tia. Beckett's just interrupted their wedding day and here is the bride with a gun to his head saying she didn't get to have sex. What's an arrogant short man to do? Typical Beckett, he spins it around and makes it seem like he did her a favor. Also, he'll say anything to distract her from shooting him so he starts implying there was more to Liz and Jack's relationship at the time than there was. Then listening to her response "these aren't for Jack," made him see how riled up he got her, indicating that there definitely could be feelings.
Say what you want about Beckett, he's very observant and very good at reading people, knowing their motives. He's trying to mess with Liz's mind so her attention will be anywhere other than planting a nice bullet between his eyes.
I could be wrong, but there is no scene that shows Beckett and Tia together, nor do they even seem to acknowledge the other exists. I can't assume they've met and are in league.

Yeah I agree lovethemtigers..something is really fishy about Beckett and Tia in this movie...they seem to be the only 2 who kow about Will, Liz and Jack's futures.

willofthewisp..explain to me how Beckett knows so much about Jacks magical compass? Tia made that and even people closest to Jack have no idea what it really does. Gibbs may be the only one who knows.

again all the closure is in movie 2 when it comes to the love triangle according to ted..and by the end of It Jack is who Liz gives up a "happy ending" with will for in order to find him again

Originally posted by katelovespirate
by the way, here's a funny version of the 12 plots from worplayer:

Guaranteed 97.3% accurate.

1) Everyone hunts for Jack, and they find him. He's alive!

2) Everyone then sails to Florida, where they rob the state's first bank, in a clever caper involving parrots and a fake wooden leg.

3) Everyone heads to Miami Beach for Spring Break. Barbossa wins the wet t-shirt contest. Jack gets drunk.

4) Jack and Will become private eyes, and save Davy Jones from being kidnapped by a Chinese restaurant and served as 70 or 80 appetizers.

5) An Asian gang comes to kidnap Elizabeth. Lots of chop-socky action ensews. Elizabeth wields nunchuks in her underwear. Barbossa loses a foot. Jack gets drunk.

6) Road trip! They need to go find Will's Mom. On the way everyone bonds. Will's Mom is about to lose her land to taxes, so they put on a show. Will and Jack sing a duet of "It's Raining Men".

7) Vegas! Jack dallies with several hookers, and gets syphilis, but Norrington shows up and invents penicillin.

8) California. Partying on another ocean. Surfs up! Jack gets drunk.

9) They steal a ship, and sail to Alaska, where the endangered green seal is being menaced by poachers. They save the seals, but then accidentally eat them all. Jack gets drunk.

10) Jack goes into rehab, and flashes back to his days as little Jack, when at 8 years old he used to make pirate copies of Abe Lincoln's sex tapes. Christopher Walken guest stars as Abe.

11) Out of rehab, Jack, Will and Elizabeth join the circus. Mayhem ensues, 62% of it involving elephants.

12) Jack and Will finally give in to the love that dare not speak its name. Elizabeth gets drunk, and goes off with Norrington.

YES! hahaha I always knew that's where T&T would take the movies! hahaha

....Beckett and Gibbs?

now there's a thought.

Hmm, why would Beckett know about Jack's compass without talking to Tia?

Well, he and Jack used to work together and we don't know exactly when Jack got the compass, so he might have had it then. I don't know. Jack screws up a lot and could have let it slip that he had a magic compass. Beckett has to know a lot about Jack because of their experiences together.

Or...and this is a little more far-fetched, but so is Tia and Beckett in league together. What if the compass is a Jack Sparrow legend? There are a lot of stories circling around about him and not everyone tells the same stories. Like the whole thing about Jack getting off the island. I bet there are a dozen different stories going around Tortuga alone about how he did it. But Beckett might have counted on this legend being true, especially when Norrington said the compass didn't point north.

I'm just saying there is more to one explanation.

Jack didnt get the compass until he met Tia and I think that was a good few years after he left Beckett

Elzaibeth has been reading up on Jack her entire life and she knows nothing of the compass.

Then my guess is that either you are right and Beckett and Tia are on the Evil team together or that I'm right and a select few believe the compass story. It's just not something we can gather from these two movies alone.

or Beckett's just slimy enough to be a stalker...? haha

not a evil team..just that she's been talking to him..I dont think Tia is on any spesific side..she just watches what happens.

I do think she has helped each character find their true destiny though.

i'm more inclined to think Beckett heard of Jack's compass because he spies on Jack, and hears the legends. Beckett obviously knows (in depth) the legend of Davy Jones and has his entire evil plot to take over the world wrapped up in his ability to steal a magic compass, find a chest with a live heart in it, and get Davy Jones in a position to be blackmailed.

AKA: Beckett is more willing to accept the illogical and supernatural than even Will or Elizabeth. Which makes me think, he has had dealings with someone of a supernatural nature at some point, OR he has been roped into Jack's misadventures before too.
When he is talking to Will about the compass and describing it, it sounds as though Beckett has seen it and remembers it as something Jack had when Beckett knew him.

But perhaps Jack and Beckett have crossed paths and swords since their original falling out 13 years ago.

I do think Beckett has in some way been in on some mysterious stuff. Still dont really think he and tia are in evil cohoots together or anything. I think he just has tons of spies everywhere, that sort of thing. like when his henchman shows up in tortuga to get information about Elizabeth.

Or perhaps Beckett and Jones have met before.

oh, and one other thought i forgot to add above.

perhaps that was the meaning of the jar of paprika. Beckett and his crew stopped off on the pelgostas island, traded with them... and thats where the paprika and the wig and all that stuff came from. Then, since Tia is apparantly on the same island as the pelogostas, he met up with Tia.

just an idea. it seems to be supported by the hints of the story.

I agree i dont think they are an evil league.I dont think Tia is actually on Jack's side or Becketts side..she's on Will's side I bet ya LOL

know what I find strange..when I said Achillies reminds me of will? his mother was a goddess 😂

maybe Tia's liking of Will is more a mothers love or maybe she fancies the pants off him..who knows..

Originally posted by LovelyOne
I agree i dont think they are an evil league.I dont think Tia is actually on Jack's side or Becketts side..she's on Will's side I bet ya LOL

know what I find strange..when I said Achillies reminds me of will? his mother was a goddess 😂

maybe Tia's liking of Will is more a mothers love or maybe she fancies the pants off him..who knows..

LoL...I Think it's more she fancies the pants of him...lol!! she's suppose to be a NYMPH right?

and you know what i always found weired about the scene in Tia's shack/hut?...

i always thought it was weird when Tia asked Jack "The Compass you BORROWED from me, it can't take you there?" she didnt say the compass i GAVE you....which made me think that maybe Jack and Tia may have an arrangement too...i think shortly after the "Wench" sank and Davy rose it from depths of the sea and renamed it the BLACK PEARL....Jack met Tia and she let him borrow the compass for a certain amount of years...maybe say oh 13 years!! i think she probably knew that when the 13 year debt with Davy was up that Jack would want to go serching for the Chest of Davy's Heart to get out of it....i mean she knew about the black spot on Jacks hand!!!

...maybe she wants the chest too!!

Originally posted by PirateDiva
and you know what i always found weired about the scene in Tia's shack/hut?...

i always thought it was weird when Tia asked Jack "The Compass you BORROWED from me, it can't take you there?" she didnt say the compass i GAVE you....which made me think that maybe Jack and Tia may have an arrangement too...i think shortly after the "Wench" sank and Davy rose it from depths of the sea and renamed it the BLACK PEARL....Jack met Tia and she let him borrow the compass for a certain amount of years...maybe say oh 13 years!! i think she probably knew that when the 13 year debt with Davy was up that Jack would want to go serching for the Chest of Davy's Heart to get out of it....i mean she knew about the black spot on Jacks hand!!!

...maybe she wants the chest too!!

in that scene she says Bartered, not borrowed
Bartered means trade or to tade goods or service for the same ammount of goods or service
if that helps at all🙂