The Midnighter vs. Wolverine

Originally posted by Creshosk
You mean the superior orbital fissure which is like maybe 5 millimeters?

And a 50 cal bullet is ten times the size of it?

that "tube"?

I saw the hole on some guy and it looked like I could stick my thumb in it. Maybe I'm remembering it larger because it was one of the most horrible videos I had ever seen. Everyone was so casual, like a family video or something. Ugh.

I don't know how big my thumb is compared to a 50 caliber bullet, or if the tube is straight enough to get a bullet through. I just wanted to make an internet tube joke.

I'm pretty sure that these debates here are the reasons that writers write most comic forums off as a big "LOL".

Originally posted by Eel O'Brian
I'm pretty sure that these debates here are the reasons that writers write most comic forums off as a big "LOL".

I know I would. 🙂

Midnighter.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Okay.. what "MEAT" would you see behind the eye with the muscle stripped away?

There's no muscle INSIDE the skull. the brain is fairly large with very minimal room around it.

And don't you DARE make me have to post pictures of what the brain looks like when exposed... Let's just theres a reason its referred to as grey matter.

Any change in the consistency of the brain matter if it was brain could simply be explained away to being roasted.

Originally posted by jinzin
The eyes were still in Wolverine's skull when he started melting away, the writer stated that Wolverine had brain matter still inside the case of the skull when the rest of the skeleton dropped.

Any change in the consistency of the brain matter if it was brain could simply be explained away to being roasted.

Meat doesn't turn red when cooked unless its something like lobster.

You still haven't explained this: (Due to the thickness of the black line inside the eye socket. the blue grey and red spots appear to be at the right depth for the spheroid bone.

Okay well the blurryness of your scans notwithstanding, I had to go get the comic and look for myself also partially due to your past shenanigans.

Okay after having gone back and looked at that panel as well as several other peices of evidence including the instance where Wolverine's burned to a skeleton while fighting Sabretooth, I have to redirect my opinion here. There has CLEARLY been Adamantium depicted on panel receding into the eye socket. So I must RECONCEDE to the assertion that a bullet going into his brain was PIS..

Midnighter.

I think the thread can be closed now.
Almost every post is inclined to Midnighter's favor.

Originally posted by occultdestroyer
I think the thread can be closed now.
Almost every post is inclined to Midnighter's favor.

no

Originally posted by jinzin
Okay well the blurryness of your scans notwithstanding, I had to go get the comic and look for myself also partially due to your past shenanigans.

Okay after having gone back and looked at that panel as well as several other peices of evidence including the instance where Wolverine's burned to a skeleton while fighting Sabretooth, I have to redirect my opinion here. There has CLEARLY been Adamantium depicted on panel receding into the eye socket. So I must RECONCEDE to the assertion that a bullet going into his brain was PIS..

Originally posted by Creshosk
My past shenanigans? pr1983

Originally posted by jinzin
Okay well the blurryness of your scans notwithstanding, I had to go get the comic and look for myself also partially due to your past shenanigans.

Okay after having gone back and looked at that panel as well as several other peices of evidence including the instance where Wolverine's burned to a skeleton while fighting Sabretooth, I have to redirect my opinion here. There has CLEARLY been Adamantium depicted on panel receding into the eye socket. So I must RECONCEDE to the assertion that a bullet going into his brain was PIS..

Originally posted by jinzin
Wolverine crucified by reevers, and graveyard fight.

Originally posted by Starscream M
ya no good flip-flopper!

Originally posted by Creshosk
What are you talking about? pr1983

Are you serious?

😬

Originally posted by jinzin
lol, yeah I know, but having gone back and looked at the evidence with a more considerable amount of attention it can't really be argue that bone's been depicted with having bone in the back of the eye socket.
Of course there's the discrepency of artistic representation vs. storytelling. Wolverine was depicted with Ady muscles perhaps we'd be right to discredit the bone in the eye socket as well?

1. either he doesn't have the sphenoid bone

or

2. his sphenoid wasnt coated with adamantium

I think 1 is the correct finding.

Originally posted by jinzin
😐

Are you serious?

😬

Originally posted by Starscream M
whether there is bone 'drawn' or not is disputable....I believe there is no bone, you see differently. What is indisputable is that logan got shot through the eye and the bullet entered the brain...that leads to 2 conclusions

1. either he doesn't have the sphenoid bone

or

2. his sphenoid wasnt coated with adamantium

I think 1 is the correct finding.

It was PIS... its not "indisputable" It was just stupid, and its not useable in debates because it was PIS.

some idiot writer didn't know that there's bone behind the eye.

Originally posted by Creshosk
And Thor got taken out by a sniper. And Sopiderman beat up Firelord, and Storm flew on Solar Winds, and Toyman is a threat to superman, And wolverine climbed out of a vat of molten steel,

It was PIS... its not "indisputable" It was just stupid, and its not useable in debates because it was PIS.

some idiot writer didn't know that there's bone behind the eye.

so is it PIS that logan's organs don't liquiefy when he gets punched by CL100s?

is it PIS when Spiderman's skull doesn't shatter into a million pieces when he gets hit by cl100s?

is it PIS when Superman flies at ultrasonic speeds without creating sonic booms and shock vacuums that would destroy cities?

cuz all those things go against science and are prob due to writers ignorance