Wait. Are we usiung Bat-God here? The same Bat-God that can figure out the world's greatest mysteries while literally sleeping and in a coma? I thought we were using the standard (hah!), non-universe-killing Batman?
He's NOT going to figure out that DD is blind during their fight. When they met, he didn't even figure it out until WELL after the fight. Batman is going to be so busy trying not to get his ass kicked, he'll never have a chance to realize DD is blind. Thus, he'll just try and out martial arts him, or use batarangs or something. In that case, DD is superior due to his senses.
Cage can toss Wolverine into the next county. He IS in fact that strong. And Spider-Man can, in fact, suffucate him if he really wants to. We've seen what a non-holding back Spider-Man can do to him.
I didn't think T'Challa's anti-metal claws worked on Cap's shield, but I could be wrong as well. Evidence?
Honestly, however, I think that Black Panther would get the majority over Cap, but since they're not fighting, there's no worry there.
There is no way that Black Panther would be able to stalemate Spidey for "a long, long time". If he wanted to, Spidey would wreck T'Challa. Hell, written properly, Spider-Man can take out the entire team himself. He's done more impressive before, in my book.
Batman is by far the first to go down. From there, it's a steady win for Team 1.