Maul, Dooku, Vader vs Sidious

Started by Kadesh11 pages

i never said im a good debator. im getting all these insults because they cant accept the fact that certein threads about DEsid has been broken

Originally posted by Kas'Im
The thing is, at least Sexy can admit and accept that he's a below average debater, you can't and that's why you're getting all this stick.

Below an average debater? I'm as good of a debater as anyone for someone with limited knowledge of star wars. I've only read some of the comics, a few books, watched the movies, and read the NEC. The people that know more about SW than me are better debaters. Don't presume that I admitted i'm below an average debater, stop embarassing yourself.

*cough* escape81 needs a life.

Do you say this to everyone who is a better logician and debator than you, San'Doria?

You must repeat this all the time.

btw kun > sidious already janus, ikc and borbarad had convinced me that, now shut up escape 81, you are not going to convince me either way.

IKC is in love with Exar Kun. He also believes that DE Sidious > NJO Luke and Exar Kun > NJO Luke. But he's wrong in all three instances.

And, Janus? Janus is the same way. This is a guy who once thought that Dooku was more powerful than Sidious and could defeat him in combat.

Finally, when have I said that I wanted to convince you? I don't have to.

ok i may not be special i never said i was but speak of the devil, i find you the worst and most idiotic debator here yet who only debates on sidious

Well, fortunately for me, your opinion doesn't really amount to much, does it?

Where is Lucas quoted to have said he LOVED DE and considers it close to a sequel???
yawn!!

wow u guys have quite the brawl going on herechair

chill escape 81

Originally posted by Escape81
Do you say this to everyone who is a better logician and debator than you, San'Doria?

You must repeat this all the time.

nope,

Originally posted by Escape81
IKC is in love with Exar Kun. He also believes that DE Sidious > NJO Luke and Exar Kun > NJO Luke. But he's wrong in all three instances.
[/B]
o hell yes that is so true but still he has pretty good arguments, i mean come on there is fanboy in all of us

Originally posted by Escape81
And, Janus? Janus is the same way. This is a guy who once thought that Dooku was more powerful than Sidious and could defeat him in combat.
[/B]
not really, i have read his posts and his arguements, i personally find him and fishy the best debators on kmc,

Originally posted by Escape81
Well, fortunately for me, your opinion doesn't really amount to much, does it? [/B]
i was not talking to you

Originally posted by Kadesh

o hell yes that is so true but still he has pretty good arguments, i mean come on there is fanboy in all of us

If you call ignoring source material, calling everything a blanket statement, and making up random shit good arguing then yes, he was great..

[quote]not really, i have read his posts and his arguements, i personally find him and fishy the best debators on kmc,


Good thing your opinion is irrelevant.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
If you call ignoring source material, calling everything a blanket statement, and making up random shit good arguing then yes, he was great..
nope, fishy janus and borbarad are great debators, they dont ignore canon, they use their brains, not like you going around calling people idiots and assuming superiority

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Below an average debater? I'm as good of a debater as anyone for someone with limited knowledge of star wars. I've only read some of the comics, a few books, watched the movies, and read the NEC. The people that know more about SW than me are better debaters. Don't presume that I admitted i'm below an average debater, stop embarrassing yourself.

Hold up, no need to get defencive, I was sticking up for you.
And just a hint, it really isn't too hard to differentiate between someone's debating ability, and their knowledge base.
However I'll stop 'embarrassing myself'.

Wow, so this thread is going to who's being a good debater and all, now?

Anyway, if you ask me who's the best debaters here, I'll tell you (as I am remaining nuetral here)

Level A Debaters:

1.) Ushagarak
2.) Escape81
3.) Advent
4.) Nai

Level B Debaters:

1.) Lightsnake (though he could be Level A)
2.) Prodigal Knight
3.) Kadesh
4.) Kas'Im
5.) Subjekt
6.) Darthsith19

Level C Debaters:

1.) Darth Sexy
2.) Rampant Ox
3.) Zephiel7
4.) Darth Sexist
5.) Council #13
6.) JollyJim

Level D Debaters (rising up):

1.) Ogami Itto
2.) Medvock
3.) ....

/////NOTE\\\\ The Order of numbers is not a ranking system. I just listed it out. I guess some of the people I put in a specific order but most of them I just listed it. From my time here at KMC, here's how people have shown themselves. But it's just my own opinion I guess...

I feel sorry for Medvock

I'd say it would be, imho:

A1. Ushgurak.
A2. Borbarad.
A3. Swirly Girl.
A4. Escape81.
A5. Generic Hero.

B1. Motoko Sama.
B2. Lightsnake.
B3. Darth Glentract.
B4. ((The_Anomaly)).
B5. Kamikz.

C1. Deception.
C2. Great Vengance.
C3. Darth Sexy.
C4. Medvock.
C5. Captain Rex.

you forgot the retired debators like janus ikc illustrious and fishy, they are really really good.

O YES i no longer hate revan now

Well I didn't know how Swirly, Generic, Glentract, Deception, and Great Vengance really debated.

Crap, I forgot Kamikz and Anomaly. They would definately be on my list.

Oh yeah, Medvock is rising. however, he seriously needs to get rid of that Fisto fanboyism.

Besidies, that list I made was for RIGHT NOW currently here at SW Versus Forum. Janus and them are all retired. So yeah.

mine is

group A
advent
fishy
escape81
janus
borbarad
illustrious
Lightsnake

group B
kasim
Kadesh
Prodigalknight
Subjeckt
darthsith 19
kamikz
rampant ox

group c
zephiel
darth sexy
darth sexiest
Adas(now banned)

group D
sparten
..

they are in no paticular order

Ahaha you guys are hilarious. How you put yourselves above others, I'll never know. Good thing your opinions are meaningless.

Hold up, I didn't even include myself in my ratings.

Level A (The Top Ten Finest)

1.) Ushagarak
2.) Escape81
3.) Janus
4.) Advent
5.) Nai Fohl
6.) Generic Hero
7.) IKC
8.) Illustrious
9.) Swirly Girl
10.) Fishy

Level B (The Top 10-20 Finest)

1.) Lightsnake
2.) Sorgo
3.) Darth Glentract
4.) Prodigal Knight/Kadesh/Kas'Im
5.) Prodigal Knight/Kadesh/Kas'Im
6.) Prodigal Knight/Kadesh/Kas'Im
7.) Faunus/Darthsith19
8.) Faunus/Darthsith19
9.) Subjekt
10.) Kamikz

Level C (The Top 20-30 Finest)

1.) Adas
2.) Darth Sexy
3.) Deception
4.) The_Anomaly
5.) Zephiel 7
6.) Council #13
7.) Jollyjim
8.) Great Vengeance
9.) Darth Sexist
10.) Sparten?

..... More but here's the Top Thirty