Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Well, Mace would likely put Sidious on the floor again and kill him while Obi-wan fights Anakin and eventually defeats him. Obi-wan and Mace win. However, in a different setting, say, the Senate Chamber, they'd lose.
You're forgetting the fact that Obiwan isn't better than ANakin. In that one particular fight he was smarter than Anakin and got the higher ground. I highly doubt Obiwan would win against Anakin on more than a few occasions.
Originally posted by Prodigal Knight
Wrong, technically Anakin is better than Obi-Wan. However, Obi-Wan knows all of Anakin's moves and is more relaxed and calm than Anakin. In addition, Anakin's anger will make him make a mistake. That's how Obi-Wan survived Mustafar. It'll just be like that.
Oh really? Well then tell me smartass, what happens when they fight in an open field? On even ground, Obiwan won't be able to get the advantage, and on even ground Anakin wouldn't have to try anything stupid.
Sidious > Mace
Anakin > Kenobi
Yes, Mace beat Sidious in a saber duel but Sidious could likely have still defeated Mace with the Force, imo. Anakin would normally beat Kenobi, he just f*cked up in ROTS when they fought. This time their fighting on flat ground so Anakin will win (cause there's no high ground for Kenobi).
Or else Sidious pwns Kenobi badly while Anakin and Mace duel, then Sidious joins Anakin and Mace gets pwnd.
Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Well, Mace would likely put Sidious on the floor again and kill him while Obi-wan fights Anakin and eventually defeats him. Obi-wan and Mace win. However, in a different setting, say, the Senate Chamber, they'd lose.
Mm-hmm.
Obi-Wan vs. Sidious. Sidious owns him.
Anakin vs. Mace. Anakin holds Mace off 'til Sidious comes over, and they own him.
Also Anakin was extremely mad about the Padme situation and that was a special case. He wouldn't always be that mad. You forget he just turned, and was pissed about Padme and he didn't really want to be doing what he was doing, but he realised that he'd done too much to go back. In any other situation he'd tool kenobi.
Oh really? Well then tell me smartass, what happens when they fight in an open field? On even ground, Obiwan won't be able to get the advantage, and on even ground Anakin wouldn't have to try anything stupid.
Anakin will do something arrogant and foolhardy. Remember, this is ROTS Anakin who believes he the strongest Jedi ever. Obi-Wan will handle him for at least five minutes before he is rescued.
Originally posted by Prodigal Knight
And...?In the Mustafar duel, Anakin and Obi-Wan spent at least three minutes fighting on a flat surface before Obi-Wan jumped onto the balance beam above the lava. This was almost as long as Mace and Sidious fighting.
It depends can Mace kill Sidious or Sidious to Mace.
You're missing the point. Anakin was going to lose had they continued on the flat surface. He was getting kicks and punches in.. Thats why Obiwan Jumped.