Lucas is an idiot!

Originally posted by Tengu
i just dont understand how hes an idiot when he made the very thing you read and debate about. he caused a cultural movement, and his movies have influenced and inspired alot of people both famous and non-famous. Hes the reason theres even a thread to debate about this shit. i think its silly that you guys pick apart every little peice of the trilogy like its supposed to be perfect, then chastize and criticize him about it as if you could've done it better? yeah, obviously the acting and scripting wasnt as good as the OT, but how does that make him an idiot or a dumbass? he gives you something masterful with the OT, then he gives you something not as good you expected or hoped for with the PT, and for that all of a sudden hes a complete idiot?

i dont come in this forum too much but when i do, i see threads critizing the most miniscule tiny details about the movies, like ohh Palpatines head wasnt on straight in the Mace Windu duel, OMG THEY SUCK, IT RUINED THE MOVIE, or ohhh the duel choreography sucked....ya know just silly stuff like that. its like if your gonna b!tch about stuff like that then dont even watch the movie. I for one dont have a problem with the PT, it wasnt that bad that i want to make a big fuss over it.

Im not hating on you guys or anything, i just think its silly to do that. I mean the man isnt perfect, the movies arent perfect, he never said they were supposed to be perfect. He spent have his life making the shit some of you guys have in your favorite movie list and just cuz you dont like how the last ones turned out hes an idiot all of a sudden.

athough i do have a few things i dislike about the PT, i dont concern myself with every little detail i agree that people here can nitpick every little thing instead of really appreciating the movie for what it is

Originally posted by Lord Melkor
I am interested in his arguments, as I enjoy his Star Wars RPG. I am not using those forums much besides role-playing, perhaps I am making a mistake? I would enjoy your arguments too.

I think that the first mistake was making Anakin a child in TPM. He shouldn`t have destroyed the Trade Federation ship in such a clumsy way. I see him as teenager that has much anger into him because of his life as slave. Romance would have worked much better if it started in TPM. Anakin would fight in the Naboo battle because of choice, as Luke. And he would not be a whiny brat in AOTC, more of a dark hero.

TPM should have been a bit more serious, there would be no problem with Jar-Jar if his time was reduced to serve the story. My girlfriend thinks Gungans are the coolest thing in PT.

i agree with this also, the problem with TPM was anakin as a kid not jar jar

Is it now? JarJar and the poo-poo jokes were quite horrendous.

Oh my god, extremely

Nothing makes up for that, except editing it out and destroy all copies with them in it.

And that is just not possible 🙁

Maybe Lucas can do it while searching and destroying every copy of the Holiday Special.

I sure wouldn't mind, I would pay him to do it

What? To destroy the Holiday Special or the poo-poo jokes?

Both!

😂

Watching the Holiday Special was.... interesting.

yeah ok i can agree that jarjar was part of the problem but he doesnt take all the blame. if anakin was a bit older and the story was more mature it might have worked better

Lucas takes the blame. Jar Jar doesn't even exist, he's all virtual. Should we go into Second Life to punish him?

Originally posted by queeq
😂

Watching the Holiday Special was.... interesting.

To say at the very least

Originally posted by queeq
Lucas takes the blame. Jar Jar doesn't even exist, he's all virtual. Should we go into Second Life to punish him?

Already there 😉

Disguised as an Ewok?

NO!!!!!! nuts

Would look nice on ya.

😘

You know it would.

Ummmm.......no 😐