What this fight comes down to is the few questions:
A) Could Surfer absorb/control/manipulate Oan energy? Fact is, all we really have to answer that is speculation, since Oan doesn't exist in marvel. However, we've NEVER come across an energy type that the Surfer couldn't manipulate, control, or absorb, so the precedent is set up in the 'affirmative' direction.
B) Could the Surfer speedblitz kyle? (Speed being one of the Surfer's only CLEAR advantages over kyle, everything else being almost equal). The answer to this one? Also speculation. Who the hell knows? Kyle has had shield up in an 'instant' just as many times as the surfer has 'instantly' done something. There is no way to accurately tell which way this should go.
😬.