Originally posted by willofthewisp
"I think Jack doesn't like Elizabeth and that she is too dorky for him."---christna.I have to disagree. If anything, I think Jack's feelings for her are stronger than her feelings for him. The entire second movie is him trying to sort out his feelings for her, not wanting to want her, but wanting her just the same. It's the whole reason why the compass won't work for him. He's positive Elizabeth isn't conflicted in what she wants and assumes the compass will work for her, which is why he gives it to her.
What do you mean by "what kind of sparrabeth?" Like Kate, I'm a little confused by your posts, too. I personally like to think that Jack and Elizabeth are soul mates whose paths crossed and will cross again later. Their relationship is complicated and limited due to circumstances and their own sense of what should be. Neither thinks they SHOULD be with the other, but it doesn't change how they feel. That's my take on them in summary.
So you're into Scarlett, huh? It seems like the movies seemed to favor Giselle, but both are kind of intriguing characters since they have a history with Jack and even though he's cheated on both of them with the other, they seem to be friends, hanging out together even when he's not there for them to fight over.
Just for my benefit, can you grammar check your posts, please? I can't tell where your sentences begin and end and it makes it hard to tell what you're asking all of us or what you're sharing. Thanks!
I already grammar checked my stuff.
Originally posted by willofthewisp
"I think Jack doesn't like Elizabeth and that she is too dorky for him."---christna.I have to disagree. If anything, I think Jack's feelings for her are stronger than her feelings for him. The entire second movie is him trying to sort out his feelings for her, not wanting to want her, but wanting her just the same. It's the whole reason why the compass won't work for him. He's positive Elizabeth isn't conflicted in what she wants and assumes the compass will work for her, which is why he gives it to her.
What do you mean by "what kind of sparrabeth?" Like Kate, I'm a little confused by your posts, too. I personally like to think that Jack and Elizabeth are soul mates whose paths crossed and will cross again later. Their relationship is complicated and limited due to circumstances and their own sense of what should be. Neither thinks they SHOULD be with the other, but it doesn't change how they feel. That's my take on them in summary.
So you're into Scarlett, huh? It seems like the movies seemed to favor Giselle, but both are kind of intriguing characters since they have a history with Jack and even though he's cheated on both of them with the other, they seem to be friends, hanging out together even when he's not there for them to fight over.
Just for my benefit, can you grammar check your posts, please? I can't tell where your sentences begin and end and it makes it hard to tell what you're asking all of us or what you're sharing. Thanks!
Basically I don't understand. It's all about age difference. Think of Will's supposed father feelings for Davy Jones. It's the same idea as Elizabeth and Jack. Jack and Teague. Teague and the tree.
It's totally stupid. It's about the idea that no one is a god.. (Xanadu anyone.) It's about the age old idea that Jack is not old enough to be a parent of Elizabeth and that Elizabeth shouldn't communicate with him b/c he is getting there. It's about that no one can feel another person as godly or ever perfect and that ppl younger than Elizabeth, be it a day or second etc., feel Jack is a god based on that someone can take the place of Elizabeth's sorrow.
Originally posted by willofthewisp
"I think Jack doesn't like Elizabeth and that she is too dorky for him."---christna.I have to disagree. If anything, I think Jack's feelings for her are stronger than her feelings for him. The entire second movie is him trying to sort out his feelings for her, not wanting to want her, but wanting her just the same. It's the whole reason why the compass won't work for him. He's positive Elizabeth isn't conflicted in what she wants and assumes the compass will work for her, which is why he gives it to her.
What do you mean by "what kind of sparrabeth?" Like Kate, I'm a little confused by your posts, too. I personally like to think that Jack and Elizabeth are soul mates whose paths crossed and will cross again later. Their relationship is complicated and limited due to circumstances and their own sense of what should be. Neither thinks they SHOULD be with the other, but it doesn't change how they feel. That's my take on them in summary.
So you're into Scarlett, huh? It seems like the movies seemed to favor Giselle, but both are kind of intriguing characters since they have a history with Jack and even though he's cheated on both of them with the other, they seem to be friends, hanging out together even when he's not there for them to fight over.
Just for my benefit, can you grammar check your posts, please? I can't tell where your sentences begin and end and it makes it hard to tell what you're asking all of us or what you're sharing. Thanks!
By what kind of Sparrabeth, I mean the issue that got you here can't be that you think Jack and Elizabeth should simply talk to each other as opposed to not. It's either that you think Jack is an okay father figure vs. can pretend to mate but still cannot communicate.
Then you ask, is it bc Elizabeth is bad or good or bc of age dishonesty. It's not always that interesting a topic.
So Sparrabeth = 1/2 1/2
And it all leads to that it's always better to be younger than you are... Who do you feel most connected to parentally? I'd say ppl up to @ 20 yrs older, unfortunately. I believe ppl are ppl. I like to say "feel something." Aha, I like to feel something.
But at the same time I don't reject anything that isn't pop.
But I never talk to ppl that age.
Originally posted by willofthewisp
"I think Jack doesn't like Elizabeth and that she is too dorky for him."---christna.I have to disagree. If anything, I think Jack's feelings for her are stronger than her feelings for him. The entire second movie is him trying to sort out his feelings for her, not wanting to want her, but wanting her just the same. It's the whole reason why the compass won't work for him. He's positive Elizabeth isn't conflicted in what she wants and assumes the compass will work for her, which is why he gives it to her.
What do you mean by "what kind of sparrabeth?" Like Kate, I'm a little confused by your posts, too. I personally like to think that Jack and Elizabeth are soul mates whose paths crossed and will cross again later. Their relationship is complicated and limited due to circumstances and their own sense of what should be. Neither thinks they SHOULD be with the other, but it doesn't change how they feel. That's my take on them in summary.
So you're into Scarlett, huh? It seems like the movies seemed to favor Giselle, but both are kind of intriguing characters since they have a history with Jack and even though he's cheated on both of them with the other, they seem to be friends, hanging out together even when he's not there for them to fight over.
Just for my benefit, can you grammar check your posts, please? I can't tell where your sentences begin and end and it makes it hard to tell what you're asking all of us or what you're sharing. Thanks!
Basically, everyone thinks Elizabeth Swann is the bfh.
I was discussing 101 Dalmations, or starting to, in another thread....
I believe they put the lucky horseshoe on Lucky not to make him easier to discuss but to entice ppl to admit they would/might like him.
The novel is almost not stimulating bc Cadpig goes around in a wagon with a TV.
And I said, talk @ PotC or Harry Potter if you wanna talk @ being a baby..
IMHO
Jack Sparrow = Lucky
Elizabeth Swann = the Cadpig http://www.wikipedia.org-Cadpig
I wasn't sure of whether or not this was in the background. This must be the theme, somehow.
...But, :[ you know how I said.. Well, sometimes ppl who are older than you seem younger, like if they are, who knows, atm, it seems, less than 20 yrs older, they seem younger than you :[
...
Originally posted by christnabarrett
I think the thing was that ppl Jack's age don't want to think they "have to" necessarily get old enough to be a parent.
Ppl like up to @ 20 yrs older than me are all complete morons and stupid heads.
I see gooey smellingy drool.
I see gooey bodies..
I see dazed looks which I don't have.
..I do sees a diff world....
Originally posted by christnabarrett
sparretthttp://pirates.wikia.com/wiki/Scarlett
http://pirates.wikia.com/wiki/Pirates_of_the_Caribbean_%28ride%29
Actually, she looks a few years older.