Should rapists be castrated?

Started by Syren15 pages

It's not just a case of being unable to control their sexual urges, though. It's a warped perception of right and wrong, a need to exercise control and power over another, 'weaker' person.

Originally posted by Syren
It's not just a case of being unable to control their sexual urges, though. It's a warped perception of right and wrong, a need to exercise control and power over another, 'weaker' person.

Yes. Rape, as a concept is a huge social issue. It cannot be described as a single cause of it, nor can it be simplified into ''sexual urges'' as a cause.

Why doesn't anyone says ''oh its what animals do'' when a mother kills its baby. Animals do it all the time - she can't help it. Well, then that makes it ok then.

Not only is suggesting men rape out of urge, offencive to men everywhere, it basically understands it as a natural occurance.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
Yes. Rape, as a concept is a huge social issue. It cannot be described as a single cause of it, nor can it be simplified into ''sexual urges'' as a cause.

Why doesn't anyone says ''oh its what animals do'' when a mother kills its baby. Animals do it all the time - she can't help it. Well, then that makes it ok then.

Not only is suggesting men rape out of urge, offencive to men everywhere, it basically understands it as a natural occurance.

Exactly. Men and 'uncontrollable urges' don't go hand in hand and it would be wrong to suggest this. As you said, rape occurs because of a combination of things, not just triggered by sexual urges.

So, castration of men who rape - yes or no, lils?

ok milla, so if a dog screws a cat without its consent, is this rape? this isnt hypothetical as ive seen this happen.

I don't think you could call that rape. Perhaps there's another word for it, but 'rape' is something one human does to another, right?

Rape is the act of intitiating involuntarily sexual acts through the use of violence, force, threat of injury, other duress, or where the victim is unable to decline due to the effects of drugs, alcohol and/or underage immaturity.

Can this be applied to animals?

Originally posted by Syren
Exactly. Men and 'uncontrollable urges' don't go hand in hand and it would be wrong to suggest this. As you said, rape occurs because of a combination of things, not just triggered by sexual urges.

So, castration of men who rape - yes or no, lils?

Personaly, I am against it. Mostly because I believe that sexual urge does not have all that to do with it - castration would then be redundant (unless you see it as a punishment soley).

Men rape women using all kinds of objects, and sometimes strap on dildos. (yeah, fecked up).

So probably...no...

Originally posted by Syren
Rape is the act of intitiating involuntarily sexual acts through the use of [...]force

yes 😖mart:

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
Personaly, I am against it. Mostly because I believe that sexual urge does not have all that to do with it - castration would then be redundant (unless you see it as a punishment soley).

Men rape women using all kinds of objects, and sometimes strap on dildos. (yeah, fecked up).

So probably...no...

Fair enough. But as a punishment, ideal 😄

Another note, how would you see the situation if it were a paedophile? Same thing?

Originally posted by PVS
yes 😖mart:

Such a smartass mhm

Originally posted by PVS
ok milla, so if a dog screws a cat without its consent, is this rape? this isnt hypothetical as ive seen this happen.

Rape is a occurance within numans. You cannot apply the accepted deffinition to animals, for the obvious reasons.

Originally posted by lil bitchiness
Rape is a occurance within numans.

hehehe numans

Shush you! 😮

hug

seriously though, you're right. the definition of rape involves humans exclusively.

Numans.....lol.... 😑

Originally posted by PVS
hug

seriously though, you're right. the definition of rape involves humans exclusively.

Do I get a hug? Coz, you know, that's what I said too weep

Originally posted by Syren
Do I get a hug? Coz, you know, that's what I said too weep

no....you attempted to ignore me before schmoll

(notice i said 'attempted'😉

*wind whispers*

Say what? ermm

Originally posted by PVS
hug

seriously though, you're right. the definition of rape involves humans exclusively.

I once saw a small dog mount and penetrate a male cat (I did break it up after the initial shock/awe), the cat was growling and hissing vehemently, I doubt this was a sound of welcome to the dog. You wouldn't consider this rape?

by principle, yes. however the definition only applies to humans which forcibly have sex with another person or animal

Originally posted by Robtard
I once saw a small dog mount and penetrate a male cat (I did break it up after the initial shock/awe), the cat was growling and hissing vehemently, I doubt this was a sound of welcome to the dog. You wouldn't consider this rape?
Originally posted by PVS
by principle, yes. however the definition only applies to humans which forcibly have sex with another person or animal

Plus unless you speak fluent cat, you dont know if there was permission? he might have been talking dirty!

well....yeah ✅