Should rapists be castrated?

Started by Starhawk15 pages

Originally posted by Robtard
Now that's funny... After expressing how greatly you want to be a lawyer and then a judge so you can effectively change and command the legal system you now state that you took it upon yourself to do a little vigilantism. Are you "Batman", fighting against the law for the law?

So I take it you are unable to prove your accusation. Just say so, it's okay.

Oh believe me he was guilty, and I never laid a hand on him or anything illegal.

what did you do then, rape his dog?

Originally posted by Starhawk
Oh believe me he was guilty, and I never laid a hand on him or anything illegal.

Guilty of what? An attempt and a failure? How can you be certain of what he did?

Originally posted by PVS
what did you do then, rape his dog?

No, I ruined his life, lost him his job, his family, his friends, his gf, told his landlord and the first time he was a day late with his rent he got evicted

I told him if he ever came back, then I would come up with something more creative.

Originally posted by Syren
Guilty of what? An attempt and a failure? How can you be certain of what he did?

The person has never told a lie in her life. Shes lived a sheltered life and kindof has a naive innocent look at the world.

Originally posted by Starhawk
The person has never told a lie in her life. Shes lived a sheltered life and kindof has a naive innocent look at the world.

Ok, fair enough. But that makes you certain of what happened? I'm not suggesting she's a liar, but without hard evidence you definitely don't have the right to take the moral high ground and act as judge and executioner 😬

Originally posted by Syren
Ok, fair enough. But that makes you certain of what happened? I'm not suggesting she's a liar, but without hard evidence you definitely don't have the right to take the moral high ground and act as judge and executioner 😬

2 years earlier I saw the guy take a taco and ram it into his GF's face. he treats women like trash and has real anger issues. trust me he did it.

Originally posted by Starhawk
2 years earlier I saw the guy take a taco and ram it into his GF's face. he treats women like trash and has real anger issues. trust me he did it.

Ok, no worries. It's good of you to care enough to sort this guy out as he does sound like an @sshole. But really, it wasn't down to you to step in.

I know as a law student I'm supposed to believe 100% in the system to sort hings out but sometimes that system needs help.

As PVS said, you needn't play the vigilante role. If you want to be a hero, buy a cape 😛

Originally posted by Starhawk
I know as a law student I'm supposed to believe 100% in the system to sort hings out but sometimes that system needs help.

That's not helping the system, that's using the system to help yourself, and it's one of the reasons the system doesn't work.

-AC

That was justice, the law is about Order and protection from harm.

Originally posted by Starhawk
law student
Why don't you put it in big bold letters in your signature?

Originally posted by Starhawk
That was justice, the law is about Order and protection from harm.

'The law is about order and protection from harm'

Are you saying it's not about justice? Implying it's to be used only as a form of prevention? It doesn't work that way, law should be to keep order, protect the innocent and provide justice. Sounds a little cheesy the way I word it but you get my point.

You're not the law.

Originally posted by Syren
'The law is about order and protection from harm'

Are you saying it's not about justice? Implying it's to be used only as a form of prevention? It doesn't work that way, law should be to keep order, protect the innocent and provide justice. Sounds a little cheesy the way I word it but you get my point.

You're not the law.

Actually the first thing they teach you in law school up here is law isn't about justice

Originally posted by Starhawk
Actually the first thing they teach you in law school up here is law isn't about justice

Really? hmm

Well, shouldn't it be? I don't mean specifically, but an element of law should be the justice, right?

I think that's a copout because law fails to provide on most occasions 😛

Originally posted by Syren
As PVS said, you needn't play the vigilante role. If you want to be a hero, buy a cape 😛

and some supercool neon tights!!!

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
and some supercool neon tights!!!

superman

its castration man!!!

Originally posted by Starhawk
The person has never told a lie in her life. Shes lived a sheltered life and kindof has a naive innocent look at the world.
Originally posted by Starhawk
2 years earlier I saw the guy take a taco and ram it into his GF's face. he treats women like trash and has real anger issues. trust me he did it.

That's all circumstantial... You ruined a guys life on a maybe. Nice going Hero, you'll make a great lawyer.