Biggest question not answered by Ted and Terry

Originally posted by LovelyOne
WHY is Jack thinking of and wanting Elizabeth in DMC whilst his own life is in danger and his time to live is running out?

😉

thoughts anyone?

I cant get on wordplayer after being banned..and I'm dying to ask this question..I cant so I posted it here lol

I think this is the most important question raised in DMC and not actually answered..Ted and Terry wont say why Jack is thinking of lizzie at a time like that. I think I know why..just wish I could ask Terry and see what he says..I think the whole series revolves around that question and the "kick-ass ending" of AWE is going to be linked in with this question..its going to be the answer to it. Thats why they wont say why.

I think MistyPirate touches on this too.....and I think, Lovely, you know the answer you just want to see what we all have to say and if once again we are all on the same wavelength.....Jack is thinking about Liz...because he realizes she is the woman for him, his time is running out and he's never been settled with just one woman, and and...he's thinking he hasn't a legacy to carry on his name and me thinks he sees Liz as that woman that can give him his legacy...his son to carry on his name...to pass his peices of eight to....it appears that Jack has many conflicting thoughts in DMC...he wants Liz, but he doesn't want to want Liz...according to the script...the compass pointed one way and Jack tells his crew to set sail in the opposite direction...he avoids TIa's knowing Look inside her cabin because she is right on the money about him knowing what he wants but is loathe to claim it as his own...plus...at the beginning he believes that Liz and Will are probably married by now and his chance at Elizabeth has passed him by.....then he finds out they are not married...and all of his repressed feelings surface through his outlandish flirting with her...from the moment he sees her "it should be a dress or nothing, I happen to have no dress in my cabin"....to asking her to "persuade me" to give back the letters of mark that he has placed on his body...and the Marriage "proposal"....and at last the kiss...Jack is much more serious in that scene...he is no longer flirting he is downright sexy in that scene staring at her lips...it's more than just sex in this scene...and according to the script jack knows that he and elizabeth's heart are the same..I loved the way they describe the compass in the script when Jack is in the longboat....there is no doubt that the compass was pointing to Elizabeth...

I hope the child is Jack's and not Will's...that would be to Pearl Harbor just as we have said before.....

and not to forget CUTE too!!! LOL!! awwwww Jack + Liz baby i cant wait....there are to many hints....It has to be true!

and I love the way the script says that It was a kiss for the ages...a kiss that has been building up since the day they first met...

implying LOVE AT FIRST SIGHT!!!!! awwwww I LOVE IT!!!

There HAS to be another kiss in the next movie!!!! Their love is so passionette and real it knocks my socks off!!

Well I said I was going to try something different, So I'm still suggesting that the kid could be Will's. *giggles and staggers out* 😉

Misty....ok turn the switcch off and come back! lol....ur scareing me!! LOL!

And yes Jack and Liz there is still to much untold story about them....and seriously a kiss can sum it all up!! or a BABY for that matter...lol!

*Tries clicking switch off* Nope it didn't work, sorry. 😄 It's Will's *goes and hides under sofa*

Originally posted by jackismyboo
There HAS to be another kiss in the next movie!!!! Their love is so passionette and real it knocks my socks off!!

i'm thinking that another kiss would be great, but certain other things would be even better. like... an honest conversation between them, some great eye contact even. it won't take much to make the fans happy.

*grabs a bat* Oh MisTy come out, come out wherever u are! I'm not gonna hurt u!! JUST KNOCK SOME SENSE INTO YOU!!!! LOL!!

Originally posted by katelovespirate
i'm thinking that another kiss would be great, but certain other things would be even better. like... an honest conversation between them, some great eye contact even. it won't take much to make the fans happy.

I agree...Honest conversation sounds great!!!

But what i personally want is....a geniuine HUG between them with some emotion....cause thats pure and innocent and says a lot!!! dont u think!

Originally posted by PirateDiva
*grabs a bat* Oh MisTy come out, come out wherever u are! I'm not gonna hurt u!! JUST KNOCK SOME SENSE INTO YOU!!!! LOL!!

HOLY CRABS!! I love crabs LOL Not a bat. I think I'm back to reality. I'm cool Piratediva. There is no need to use a bat. Jack is the daddy. 😱

LOL.....W0o0o0o0o0o00o0 Much More like it!!!! YAY MISTY!!!!

*puts bat away in a safe place in case she needs it again to knock some sense into somebody* lol!

Originally posted by PirateDiva
LOL.....W0o0o0o0o0o00o0 Much More like it!!!! YAY MISTY!!!!

*puts bat away in a safe place in case she needs it again to knock some sense into somebody* lol!

*switch clicks to off* I think it's Will's baby. They are re-shooting a scene in Hawaii. Only Keira and Orli are in Hawaii, no Johnny. That's not good. 🙁

NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! we were doing so good!!! I feel a big dip in this rollorcoaster ride we call life! 🙁

"I agree...Honest conversation sounds great!!!

But what i personally want is....a geniuine HUG between them with some emotion....cause thats pure and innocent and says a lot!!! dont u think!"------piratediva

I am all for honest conversation, discussing an issue as the equals they are. And hugging! No one hugs in these movies, and they all need hugs badly. I'm surprised Will and Liz don't even hug. I don't count when she runs to him on the beach because they kiss. That's not a genuine hug.

I'm not for a kid yet. It's going to take a lot of convincing and good acting to make me think bringing a kid into the series was the right choice. It's a little too like Pearl Harbor and I hated that movie.

^^If the kid's lines are short, I don't mind so much. I don't really like children, but he's cute enough. 😄 I think if they skip ahead in the future, then a kid would be ok. 😄

I love kids, Surreal, and even I don't want one in it. It takes "Pirates of the Caribbean" and turns it into "Days of Our Lives." This is a pirate movie! Sure, it's about relationships and learning more about one's self, of course. But all that is in the backdrop of a violent, adventure-ride kind of environment and I think it's wrong for them to bring in a kid for dramatic effect. There are problems all around.

1. It's Will and Liz's kid. Okay, great. These two fairytale lovers had a kid out of wedlock in a Disney movie. Jack's been left out in the dust and we all get a happily ever after ending that satisfies not even the most ardent W/L shippers.

2. It's Will's kid and Will dies. Holy crap, Jack raising someone else's kid? No. That's too much like Pearl Harbor and about a dozen other movies and I think T&T are more original than that.

3. It's Jack and Liz's kid. But who knows that besides Liz? I can see the scene where she tells Will being too cringe-worthy, and if she doesn't tell Will, he's left raising another guy's kid and Jack doesn't get to see his son? That's a modern-day custody battle, not POTC-worthy.

4. It's Jack's kid by another woman. Then why the hell would we care?

All in all, I think it's unoriginal to bring in a child. I don't think it's a creative or smart choice even though I do believe Jack probably wants a child by now. I think it would be more satisfying to let him get with Liz (or some other woman) and they get together and we know down the road he will be a father.

i know this sounds wierd but maybe Will learns elizabeth has a kid with Jack and he is on his flying Dutchman reuniting with her and telling his stories with the flying Dutchman and he hasn't seen her in 10 years so now he can go on land and see her again. i know that sounds lame but it could be a possibility.

^^ What ever happened to Will and Elizabeth being married?