BACK TO the beach. Elizabeth, Jack, and whoever else was there with them are climbing into a longboat.
Jack: So what's at stake if you lose, hmm?
Elizabeth: I'm glad to hear you have faith in me, Jack. (pauses) Just my life.
Jack looks at her sideways, maybe guessing that she is lying. Elizabeth is struggling to maintain composure.
Elizabeth: Jack... do me a favor. Stay behind and keep your eye on James. I don't trust these creatures.
Jack: Stay behind?
Elizabeth: Please.
Jack shrugs and jumps out of the boat, wading back to shore. He turns and takes his hat off to her and she nods.
They reach the Flying Dutchman and board. Will gives Elizabeth an encouraging hug.
Will: Ready?
Elizabeth: Of course.
The Ship dives, and after Will lightly kisses Elizabeth's mouth, she finds she can breath underwater. Will seems to know where they are going, and steers the Dutchman towards a steep underwater drop-off, where rocks and sunken ships dot the ocean floor. A large crowd of mermaids have gathered, but they hide behind various debri so that only their sharp eyes can be seen. Everything feels dark and cold and vaguely unsettling. Elizabeth closes her eyes for a moment, remembering the time she was sinking to the ocean floor after falling off the parapet when James first proposed to her. Her mind jumps ahead to her old wedding dress sinking. She opens her eyes and shivers.
Anamaria: (looking around) Welcome to Pirates' Paradise.
Spoon and Atropos, restored to their mer shapes, approach the Dutchman.
Atropos: Challenger must come with us. Everyone else stays.
Will and Anamaria look at each other nervously, and Anamaria pulls Elizabeth aside to give her some last minute advice.
Anamaria: Steel yourself, Elizabeth. This place changes skin like a chameleon. You must pass by any temptations that arise, for that is the mer-people's chief power. They will try to beguile or seduce you, but if you would save James, you must hold to your purpose and pass them by.
Elizabeth nods, taking a moment to ponder those words. She climbs out of the dutchman and Atropos leads her to a crevice between the rocks.
Atropos: In there, human.
Elizabeth crawls in. It's an underwater cave, but a huge pocket of air makes the place almost dry, like a cave on land would be. Spoon and Atropos are once again human-looking.
Atropos: Now... for the challenge. (she hands Elizabeth an old, rusted sword with strange lettering across it) You must travel down that corridor (points ahead) until the light meets the bottom of the sea. If you stray from the path, you will die. Once you have reached the end of the path, you will meet a monster you must destroy without mercy. If you kill the monster, you must bring the jewel from its neck back to me, and I will name you winner.
Elizabeth: (indicating Spoon) What about her?
Atropos: She has her own challenge to attend to. Now go! You have only until sunset.
Elizabeth grips the sword and starts down into the corrider. It is dark and clammy, with water dripping through from the sea above. The path twists and turns and Elizabeth eyesight swims; she seems to be hearing sounds and voices around her. Suddenly she starts- a dark shape is ahead of her, calling her name.
Voice: Elizabeth! Daughter!
Elizabeth: Father?
Swann: It's me, Elizabeth. Take me back up to the shore. I've been trapped here for days upon days... but you can save me now! Quickly!
Elizabeth looks at him in horror and fear.
Swann: You must save me, Elizabeth. Your mother would want it.
Tears stream down her face, but Elizabeth shakes her head.
Swann: Don't leave me here, Elizabeth. Don't leave me in this awful place...
With a cry of anguish, Elizabeth runs past him, down deeper into the tunnel, holding her hands over her ears to block out his cries after her.
She has just begun to catch her breath when she hears something else. It is the sound of a man weeping. She runs forward-- and sees Will sitting by the side of the path, his head buried in his hands.
Elizabeth: Will!
Will: (standing) Elizabeth! I thought you were dead...
Elizabeth: I'm not... I'm here. Whatever is the matter?
Will: All my life, I loved you Elizabeth. I gave up everything for you, even my freedom. And your rejection has made life unlivable.
Will pulls something out of his pocket--- it is a beating heart, and Elizabeth realizes it is his own. Blood trickles down his shirt and hands as he holds it up. His shape shifts from the little boy she first knew him as to the man he is, back and forth. He lays the still beating heart at her feet.
Will: Everything's over for me, now.
Elizabeth: No! Will... there's your father, there's Anamaria.
Will: But you are the only one who can save me now! If you bring me back to the surface, my heart could perhaps be mended.
Elizabeth: But I can't! I must.. I must... (but her thinking has become cloudy and she rubs her head, knowing there is something she must do. Will steps closer, holding his hand out to her)
Will: Save me, Elizabeth. You're the only one who can.
Elizabeth is weeping, but she lifts up her sword and warns him back.
Elizabeth: Stay back!
Will: (a plea) Elizabeth...
Elizabeth runs past him, moaning in frustration and despair.
She goes on, deeper and deeper. Everything is hazy... the scenery around her seems to change, and voices call her name. The air seems so thin, she can hardly catch her breath.
She seems to hear the sounds of the sea at night. Wearily, she stumbles on. She hears someone singing. It's familiar... "Yo ho, Yo ho a pirate's life for me..." And then she sees him. It's Jack, standing as before the helm of a ship, singing merrily, a bottle of rum in his hand.
Elizabeth: Jack?
Jack: Lizzie! Have some rum!
Elizabeth: (wondering if he's going to ask her to save him as well) What happened? Why are you here?
Jack: To save you, darling!
Elizabeth: Me?
Jack: Well I love you, don't I? In me own way? And I know your deepest desires, Elizabeth. I know what your heart truly longs for. The sea, and a ship, sailing off into the horizon, into freedom. I can give you that freedom. (steps forward)
He's so real, Elizabeth can smell the rum and the sea and almost see the sun rising over a the endless ocean. A salty breeze drifts by her. He presses his lips against hers, and Elizabeth trembles.
Elizabeth: Jack... I can't... I musn't.
Jack: I'll take you away from all this, Lizzie. To a life of adventure. (kissing her neck) I may be an old sea dog but I still know how to show a lady a good time. Let me save you then, eh? Don't make me be alone forever...
Elizabeth: Oh Jack... I've wanted you to save me. I wanted you to...
Jack moves to embrace her, but she draws her sword again, pointing it at him.
Elizabeth: No, Jack. Not this time...
Jack: The sea awaits you. The pearl is ready!
Elizabeth shakes her head mutely. She backs away from him, finally turning and running down the tunnel, still weeping. She passes under a waterfall and feels along the wall in the dark. For a moment she drops to her knees, exhausted, her heart breaking. She glances back up the tunnel, but it's no use. Using the sword for balance, she pulls herself back up. A long time seems to have passed. She crawls through more tunnels, travels down darker and darker paths. Suddenly, she sees a glimmer of light ahead. She runs forward, and through a rough doorway is a small chamber with no roof, but the water doesn't enter the chamber. The setting sun through the water casts a golden glow across the floor and onto the person standing in the middle of the chamber--- James.
Elizabeth runs to him and throws her arms around him, weeping, but he holds her shoulders roughly and puts her away from him.
Elizabeth: James! I'm here. I'm here to save you.
James: I don't want to be saved. I choose to remain with Atropos and her people, forever.
Elizabeth: No, James! You love me. You belong on land, with people, with me. We're going to start a new life together!
James: No, Elizabeth. I don't love you anymore. I choose to remain here. And since Atropos requires a mighty prize, I will fight you and deliver your body to her.
Elizabeth shakes her head, her strength gone. She lifts up her sword feebly as James attacks. He is brutal and quick, but even when weary, Elizabeth is skilled with the sword.
Elizabeth: (as they fight) James, I'm sorry for everything.
James: I can't forgive you.
Elizabeth: Atropos lied. She told me I would be fighting a monster, not the person I love most in the whole world.
James: Your love isn't enough.
Elizabeth: (suddenly stronger as she battles him) Yes it is!
James: Your love isn't enough!
Elizabeth: My love is stronger than you could imagine.
James: It isn't enough!
Elizabeth: It is!
In a final motion, Elizabeth disarms him and plunges her sword into his heart. She can't believe what she's done as he falls to the floor, writhing in pain. His form begins to change... and it's no longer James, but Spoon who lays there with a sword in her heart, dead. Elizabeth's mind is suddenly clear. With a hand over her mouth, she kneels beside the mermaid and sees a jeweled necklace at her throat. She pulls it off quickly.
In a blinding flash, the room disappears and she is on shore, the sun setting in the distance. Atropos stands before her with a cold face.
Atropos: You have won the challenge. I release my claim on the human and will fulfil the rest of our bargain.
She vanishes into the water. Elizabeth drops to her knees in disbelief and wonder, as the Flying Dutchman surfaces nearby. It begins to fall apart, the spell of it broken, until it is merely a pile of driftwood on the water. Elizabeth closes her eyes blissfully, too weary to find the others just now. In the distance, she sees James coming towards her...