Predestination

Started by FeceMan15 pages

Predestination

Discuss.

I don't think it happens.

Originally posted by Alliance
I don't think it happens.

I'm shocked. Seriously. 😐
Originally posted by FeceMan
Discuss.

I think it Biblically supported, however, I do not think it conflicts free will.

Originally posted by Nellinator
I do not think [predestination] conflicts free will.

*dies of confusion induced aneurism*

[edit]: I've got the Presbyterian Handbook at home it has a sction on how to explain predestination. I'll post it when I get there.

Predestination DOES go against free will, but there are scriptures that do back it up that other denominations have built their faith on...It's really quite sad because if one is not predestined, then it wouldn't matter what they did, because they were not intended to really be saved. And how would a person prove it? Predestination is an evil doctrine.

One verse that would combat it is "Jesus came to die for everyone especially the unbelievers" meaning that people can choose ie..freewill.

Originally posted by debbiejo
Predestination DOES go against free will, but there are scriptures that do back it up that other denominations have built their faith on...It's really quite sad because if one is not predestined, then it wouldn't matter what they did, because they were not intended to really be saved. And how would a person prove it? Predestination is an evil doctrine.

One verse that would combat it is "Jesus came to die for everyone especially the unbelievers" meaning that people can choose ie..freewill.


I knew you were going to say that... 😂

Really??.LOL

bangin

I have two lines of thinking about predestination.

1. God has only offered salvation to certain people. However, these people also happen to be the ones God knows will accept salvation.

2. God offers salvation to everyone but has elected certain people to become saved. Others outside this may become saved, but God has not "predestined" them to salvation.

Either way, God isn't "withholding" salvation from people.

I'm along the lines of 2. I believe that one reason predestination exists is to ensure that the faith survives and continues to be preached. I think that God probably uses it very little in Western countries nowadays, but that it is very present in third world countries that are being evangelized.

I don't believe in it. I believe for every action there is a consequence. And your actions merit you eternal salvation or eternal damnation.

Originally posted by Nellinator
I'm along the lines of 2. I believe that one reason predestination exists is to ensure that the faith survives and continues to be preached. I think that God probably uses it very little in Western countries nowadays, but that it is very present in third world countries that are being evangelized.

That makes quite a bit of sense. From that standpoint then, prophets and peoples such as Noah, Mary, Isaiah, Ezekiel, Jeremiah, John the Baptist, Moses, King David and the like would probably be predestined, since their lives played very significant roles in God's plans.

Many of these peoples make references within the scripture to God forming them in the womb, for these specific purposes.

None of this of course would represent favortism on God's part for these people, nor would it take away their free will...but God elected and purposed them to be used as special instruments in fulfilling his purpose, which generally entailed informing others of his true loving nature.

These predistined people were probably held to much higher standards of abiding by God's will then the common man. And rightfully so, seeing as how God had already instilled them with a great knowledge of his true loving character from the womb.

No such thing

Originally posted by Strangelove
No such thing

See Ephesians 1:4-5 (its the only useful quote about predestination in the handbook)

If an omniscient being exists, then it is impossible to have free will; see omniscience paradox.

Originally posted by Adam_PoE
If an omniscient being exists, then it is impossible to have free will; see omniscience paradox.

Unless one possesses omniscience themselves, how do they know this to be impossible?; see common sense.

Originally posted by Thundar
Unless one possesses omniscience themselves, how do they know this to be impossible; see common sense.

see common sense

if something knows everything then nothing can defy that knowledge ie no free will

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
see common sense

if something knows everything then nothing can defy that knowledge ie no free will

If one is not omnsicient, then they won't know what is/isn't possible to do with omniscience; skip common sense, and redirect oneself to stupidity.

Originally posted by Thundar
If one is not omnsicient, then they won't know what is/isn't possible to do with omniscience; skip common sense, and redirect oneself to stupidity.

Supidity:
See Thundar

Predestination

With everything we discuss in this forum, this thread was bound to happen... renske

Re: Predestination

Originally posted by Mindship
With everything we discuss in this forum, this thread was bound to happen... renske