Captain America vs. Wolverine (Twist)
This is purely a hand-to-hand fight. For argument's sake, Wolverine's physiology is now equivalent to Cap's. Meaning: NO healing factor, NO claws, NO adamantium, no superhuman durabilty, no super sense, etc., etc.
Cap does NOT get his shield either. They're both put on equal footing here physically.
Fight takes place in a featureless arena with walls surrounding the edges.
Now, in plain hand-to-hand combat, who is the victor?
Originally posted by capt it up
well I am assuming logan has all of his knowledge and such.also make it both are normal humans no peak humans so to make it fair since niehter had longer experience with there given abilites
Why? I put them both on equal footing. They both have the physiology of Cap. I would think you'd want that, otherwise the fight would last only a couple of minutes, fatigue dragging them down.
You think Wolverine would be hindered by the ability to be peak human? 😑
Why would that matter anyway? This is all just depends on who the better fighter is.
Originally posted by Metalmanx
Why? I put them both on equal footing. They both have the physiology of Cap. I would think you'd want that, otherwise the fight would last only a couple of minutes, fatigue dragging them down.You think Wolverine would be hindered by the ability to be peak human? 😑
Why would that matter anyway? This is all just depends on who the better fighter is.
if this had to do with skill then why won't you just make them both humans?
with cis on, wolverine loses, he's fought for so long in situations where he could afford to be careless that it's going to cost him in this fight, captain america has to make every move count cause he ain't got a healing factor, he's been fighting that way forever, but logan is easily more prone to being sloppy.. cap 6/10
Originally posted by capt it up
becuase logan was just amde peakhuman when capt was not. capt had more experience with the abilties and limits of his body why logan ahs not.if this had to do with skill then why won't you just make them both humans?
Okay. Fine. It shouldn't matter anyway. But I'll appease you, nonetheless.
They're both made regular human athletes. Athlete: able to lift one to two times one's own body weight. All their stats are the same (speed, agility, reaction time, endurance, durability, etc.), save for their specific heights and weights, obviously.
I believe Captain America wins the majority.
Originally posted by jinzin
with cis on, wolverine loses, he's fought for so long in situations where he could afford to be careless that it's going to cost him in this fight, captain america has to make every move count cause he ain't got a healing factor, he's been fighting that way forever, but logan is easily more prone to being sloppy.. cap 6/10
You know, seeing you back Captain America instead of Wolverine almost make me want to prove you wrong... hmm
Originally posted by Metalmanx
His 5'3", 200lb body structure would help Wolverine how?I think Cap takes it in skill.
structure wise it help a good deal. of they have the same strength which they should since that the whole point of this for them to have the same abilities.
Logan is closer to the ground making him ahrder to nock down not mention making him a harder target.
Not to mention he has extremely long arms allowing him quite a reach for such a small body.
how ever it skill wise and I think logans the more skilled and clearly the mroe experienced
Yea, well, I'd already anticipated your answer. I'm waiting to hear from some others concerning this topic now.
Cap will still have a longer reach both in his arms and legs.
And honestly, I've never seen Wolverine have "extremely long arms" before, unless you're referring to his claws' length. They look to be about proportionate to me.
This is interesting 🙂
Jinzin brings up the best point however. Taking away the healing factor and claws and whatever else is a huge disadvantage for Wolvie.
Not that he isn't more skilled than Cap (I think he certainly is) just, as was mentioned, his fighting style is more prone to taking injury.
imho, if they were given 2 months or whatever to train with their new physiologies, Logan would have it.
As it stands, 50/50 with a slight edge to Cap, since all he loses is his shield.