Well if you take my post out of context, then yeah it fits your argument, I went on to include that HOWEVER in Anakins case, since when his rage and fear and doubts are in his head, it serves to weaken him more then it helps, making him a reckless berserker who can't think straight. Now Anakin in his "crystal clear" state which you put him in in this duel is not in that berserker state. Basically if Anakin can't focus it makes him weaker.
You said that “rage should give him great power” but make him more reckless earlier, which was for the most part, the stance that I held. With his great power, he should easily be able to push back Obi Wan. It’d only be detrimental because in other points of his duel he’d do something stupid like jumping even when having the lower ground, but in that specific instance they were both stuck in the deadlock and even with Anakin’s beserker fury his force skills were not augmented enough to send Kenobi flying.
We've likely seen Anakin manifest this state twice, the first during his duel with Assaji Ventress on Yavin 4 when he goes from being relatively equal with her to completely overpowering and destroying her in a few second,the same with his duel with Dooku.
Yes, I agree with you here. But then again, Bane would destroy Assaj Ventres and he would overwhelm Dooku like he did to Kas’im as well. So I don’t know how Anakin “entering this state of mind” and defeating the aforementioned figures serves to illustrate that he’d defeat Bane at all. Hell, I would imagine that Assaj’s bones would crack into hundreds if she decided to engage Bane.
Anakin in this state as a pure saber combatant could contend with almost anyone in the SW universe.
He’d certainly be a good duelist, but there are a few people who could stalemate him and many who could probably beat him. Revan would probably be able to stalemate him in pure saber combat; given how he was able to defeat a Star Forge empowered Malak multiple times. Same goes for Kas’im. IMO Bane would be able to defeat him by BOTS. Yoda and Mace would also be able to defeat him. From the NJO, Luke, Kyp, and Jacen would probably defeat him.
In the grand scheme of things I would rank him as
superior but not necessarily among the best.
This is the same guy who pretty much single handedly ruined the EU with his "Uber" feats that made the movie characters look like jokes in TOTJ and FOTS and random stupid super weapons.
I will admit that he unfortunately changed Star Wars into an episode of Dragon Ball Z, but NJO made it even worse. Anyways, even though we may raise an eyebrow and call some of the feats described in his works as “ridiculous,” these are the feats we have to work with.
Oh and did I mention his horrible writing?
To tell you the truth, I preferred his writing in BOTS to Karpyshyn’s in PoD. If I had to chose the SW writer I disliked the most, it’d probably be Stover. His “roadrunner” introductions and pointless philosophy doesn’t suit SW, IMHO.
That was coming from inside Banes head, so it really doesn't mean shit, let me remind you Padawan Anakin thought he was a match for Yoda.
The problem is, like I said before, we are picking possibilities not even
hinted on. Remember Okkam’s Razor, the simplest option is most likely the right one. Here we have an option that was hinted on, had analogies made on, and is most likely the right one.
Bane was confident in his overall skills. He was never really that arrogant of his abilities; let me remind you that he spent the majority of his life in hiding, waiting for the perfect time to strike the Jedi as opposed to Kun, Malak, or Dooku whom openly warred against the Jedi Order.
And padawan Anakin was just like older Anakin except going through puberty. You can probably get a picture of how much arrogance that would entail.
C. Its easy to have the bird you know sit down and rest, and he has the ability to use the force to summon beasts so really its not that hard to find a new one.
Then it becomes a “a wild goose chase.” How many beasts did Bane have to summon? If Anderson’s intention was to make Bane appear weaker, why include the entire
bloody passage at all? Why include the over-the-top analogy? It would have been just as easy for him to write down that Bane found an empty ship left behind recently by a band of tomb raiders.
So, because we have one source saying everything "EVENTUALLY" breaks to a lightsaber. and we have Bane swiping at the Orbalisks once, its all of a sudden an exception to the rule?
The thing with “Mandalorian iron and Cortosis” is that proof has been shown that that goes contrary to the view that they can withstand lightsaber blows. Only with such a proof we can we be assured that they are not exceptions. With Bane’s orbalisks though, there has been no mention or hint that they can be destroyed by continued lightsaber combat. Unless proof exists, why should we assume otherwise? Orbalisks are biological organisms, probably infused with darkside by how they live. They are far different from a non living mineral or ore.
Not to mention that Yuzzhang Vong armour was resistant to continuous lightsaber blows. Hell, Luke only killed Shimrra by slicing at his joints. Exceptions do exist.
Not really if he has anything that even touches his brain his pretty much done for, sand really please explain to me how burnt, cauterized cells can be restored?
We don’t know how the orbalisks restore. They could decompose burnt tissue proteins, and with the genetic information of the host they could replace destroyed organs unless the case of a severe trauma (ie., the lightsaber entering halfway through his head.)
Lightning should severely cauterize cells, yet we see Luke, Yoda and Bastila surviving looking spick and spam.
Its not that he'd have no clue, its just he wouldn't be "as familiar" as he would against a foe using a staff saber.
There is no reason to suspect that he would perform worse because he is not “as familiar”. He uses the weapon; he would naturally be familiar with its strengths and weaknesses. The style was the rudimentary form of wielding sabers for generations upon generations. That was most likely the way he trained against fellow acoloytes.
They'd both beat him (Mace and Yoda)
Argument for a different time 😛
and Dooku likely too, but that is anther topic and I wont debate it here.
This I disagree with you. But see above.
Again your saying as if he can just spam force attacks, why didn't he just start spamming force waves on Kas'im?
He may have just discovered the technique at that moment of absolute necessity. We know he didn’t recognize his full power upon coming into contact with Revan’s holocron, so he was a relative newbie at that point, and probably didn’t have a comfortable grasp over his powers either. Notice that after the Seismic blast incident, he almost always reverted to the force to crush his opponents. For example, he didn’t even bother igniting a lightsaber against Qordis; he just ground his bones to dust.
Again...how would that happen? There would have to be space between the foes first off for Bane to even consider a force attack and then there's Kenboi to pop up when he attempts one
Projecting the force in a wave or a choke is really quite instantaneous. Kreia didn’t even have to lift a finger. She just walked in and Kavar, Zez Kai, and Vrook were flung 10 feet away. Similarily, in the movie, Dooku flung Kenobi away in less than a second. Bane is stronger than Dooku, so the effect should be stronger and faster.
then you have to prove that his attacks will even kill/hurt Anakin, considering Anakin took a force charged boot to the face from Dooku that flung him 10 feet
I’d doubt that Anakin would be unable to withstand a massive seismic energy blast that shattered the Rakatan temple if he could not take a “force charged kick” from Dooku.
he's literally run through force pushes before and didn't even bother to put up a shield (Ventress duel of Yavin)
Proof that he didn’t bother to put up a shield? Force shields were only noticed by PoD. Moreover, Ventress was tons weaker than Dooku, so it really isn’t saying much.
has been electrocuted severely through his robotic hand for 15 seconds
Where was this? I’d imagine he’s “pincushioning” the effect, which is quite common among force users.