ROTS Anakin V.S. KOTOR Revan

Started by Count Makashi18 pages

What, why is is dumb, you just cant say it and offer no explanation.

It's dumb because there's no difference between "EU logic" and GL logic. Logic is logic, characters are portrayed differently, that's all.

Oh, but i still don't see Revan vining in a saber fight.

Good for you, we don't know much about Revan's skill, so probably. Anakin has no chance winning a force duel.

Anakin had no chance to win a Force duel against Dooku and look what happened.

Originally posted by Count Makashi
Anakin had no chance to win a Force duel against Dooku and look what happened.

We dont know ENOUGH about Revan's lightsaber skills, so we cant know WHO'S BETTER. Theres really no way to know who will WIN. But what we know is enough to prove this wont be a "Anakin wins by far" or "Revan wins by far" duel. Though, if Revan's lightsaber skills are good enough to make it a long fight, his Force powers would probably affect in the fight, cuz most probably in a long fight Anakin would get distracted in a moment or Revan would use any lack of Anakin's concentration in his advantage.

Why would Anakin get distracted?

I dont know, i just set an example. It could happend to Revan as well. Or probably something similar to what happened in the duel against Obi-Wan could happen. He thinks he is more powerful than the enemy so he gets too confident about himself. That could be an advantage for Revan.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
It's dumb because there's no difference between "EU logic" and GL logic. Logic is logic, characters are portrayed differently, that's all.

OK so logic was the wrong word, but you know what i mean...in the EU, characters can attack from lightyears away, supposedly move moons, and all that shit; in the movies all they can do is jump high and move some shit around if not really distracted. Completely different, and you know it. So because you look down from your mighty pedestal and argue the semantics of what I said in the first sentence, rather than the point, doesn't make the entire post dumb.

And portrayal means shit...Nebaris portrays himself as a god debater...how do you portray him? The characters aren't portrayed different, they're given god-like powers, and compared to the movies, they (the abilities) are ridiculous.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
And what are you trying to prove here? I stop arguing when things get settled. This is what others do as well.
Not really. all it takes for alot of us to shut up and get things settled is when advent steps in, and when she stepped on you proving you wrong, you kept going on and on

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Yeah! that quote based on Force Lightning Storm. Let me tell you one thing Kadesh! forget it because it is a very old comment. If I start digging about your past mistakes here then it will not look good. Don't bring past things here to prove your irrelevant point here.
Firstly, i never said it is relevant. All i point out is what you do that annoys me. but fine since you are willing to concende ill do so too.
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Once again! shall I remind you that you got smashed twice by Advent? Is it really relevant? I stopped arguing in that thread because I conceded. If I had argue and argue and argue as you claim, I would have done that in that thread. But I didn't and your point holds no water.
Oh i have been trashed by advent more than twice, everybody here has. And you did argue and argue, even as DS Ls and advent stepped in. as i said, if advent is gonna take part in the debate, she just has to make one post to shut us all up, and you still go on argueing and at the same time trashed again. But since you want me to concede on this fine i shall do so, provided you do not relight this topic again
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Once again bringing up past things is irrelevant. Revan's Force Mastery might be twice as good as that of Dooku but it does not means that he is twice as better in all other categories. That argument was old. Forget it and move on.
i merely pointed out what you do which is irritating

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Passing comments on others is bad thing. I know that people can do that but they kept silent afterwards. You should do the same if you don't have anything relevant to say. I don't taunt you in threads when you argue against others, so you should not do the same.
They keep silent when you do not reply with posts that agitate them period
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Want to stay friendly, follow my advice and stop bringing old issues here again and again.
fine by me

Originally posted by Riverollv
I dont know, i just set an example. It could happend to Revan as well. Or probably something similar to what happened in the duel against Obi-Wan could happen. He thinks he is more powerful than the enemy so he gets too confident about himself. That could be an advantage for Revan.

Or the same thing could happen in the duel against Dooku, he only needed to decide to win, in the fight against Obi-Wan he was emotionally conflicted. And Revan would probably think he is better to, then his opponent, like Dooku did.

Oh i have been trashed by advent more than twice, everybody here has. And you did argue and argue, even as DS Ls and advent stepped in. as i said, if advent is gonna take part in the debate, she just has to make one post to shut us all up, and you still go on arguing and at the same time trashed again. But since you want me to concede on this fine i shall do so, provided you do not relight this topic again

Speak for yourself. I never have whether it be on this or any other forum.

actually there have been arguments where lightsnake or myself have stepped in and you kept on arguing.

Me? When? I don't even remember EVER engaging in a full blown argument with Advent on this forum

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
actually there have been arguments where lightsnake or myself have stepped in and you kept on arguing.

Please read what I said carefully before responding.

Well you were very vague to begin with, actually.

Apparently not, if he missed the point altogether.

Apparently not, if he missed the point altogether.

Speaking in completely honesty I don't see what your getting at...I bolded what Kadesh said: "Everybody has been thrashed by Advent." I said I hadn't, again I don't see what your talking about.

Originally posted by xxXAcStylesXxx
Speaking in completely honesty I don't see what your getting at...I bolded what Kadesh said: "Everybody has been thrashed by Advent." I said I hadn't, again I don't see what your talking about.
I was referring to the time before you and legend joined the forums, I apologise that i forgot to specify that

Have we decided who wins in this thread? Rev or Annie?