Ranks for MAs · Comic Books

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by snoopdogg
How can bull eye beating Gambit get him 2nd tier but Gambit stalemating DD won't get him to 2nd?

I never said it gets him second tier. I only brought it up to counter the arguement to move gambit up based on stalemating DD for a few seconds. and gambit used weapons to do this. he not nearly as skilled in h2h combat as he is with a bo staff.

Battlehammer Senior Member

I know many of you love cyclopes nuts, but why is he being voted on to be moved up a tier when there are people superior to him in MA skill in his very tier who clearly deserve to be moved up before him.

cyclopes is overrated by the board in my opinion.

Warrior18 Keyboard Warrior

Originally posted by snoopdogg
bull eye need to be moved down also.

No way man.

The guy goes H2H and gives DD absolute hell pretty much every time they fight. He has beaten Elektra I think twice.

Last time they fought together he was taking it to both DD and Elektra(skrull?) at the same time.

Keep a look out for next months Dark Reign:Elektra, as I have a feeling he might be squaring off against Wolverine.

Phantom Zone Junior Member

Originally posted by Battlehammer
I know many of you love cyclopes nuts, but why is he being voted on to be moved up a tier when there are people superior to him in MA skill in his very tier who clearly deserve to be moved up before him.
cyclopes is overrated by the board in my opinion.

The whole table is a mess.

Trackz Senior Member

Originally posted by Warrior18
No way man.
The guy goes H2H and gives DD absolute hell pretty much every time they fight. He has beaten Elektra I think twice.
Last time they fought together he was taking it to both DD and Elektra(skrull?) at the same time.
Keep a look out for next months Dark Reign:Elektra, as I have a feeling he might be squaring off against Wolverine.

isn't that because he studied their exact fighting styles and how to counteract them?

Warrior18 Keyboard Warrior

Originally posted by Trackz
isn't that because he studied their exact fighting styles and how to counteract them?

He studies two top tiers then trains and the end result is that he is skilled enough to give them good fights.ermm

snoopdogg Big Pimpin

Originally posted by Warrior18
He studies two top tiers then trains and the end result is that he is skilled enough to give them good fights.ermm

How has he faired agaisnt top tiers who he didn't study?

Juk3n Devils Advocate

Doesn't matter if he studied, it's not frikkin' supernatural, he did some home work and then proceeded to whoop some ass, Bullseye deserves to stay put.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

biscuits

But seriously, I wouldn't move him down.

SuperiorTech Senior Member

Cyke to third: against

juggernaut74 Bigsexy

Against Kingpin to 2nd.

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
The whole table is a mess.

this could be very true

Tha C-Master Zitz! Rash! Pimple!

Originally posted by Battlehammer
comic wises no, they get wrecked by most of the top tier in pure skill. there only second tier

I find them more lethal comic wise or at least recently. Meh, it's a really hard thing to argue tbh and I won't be around to do it.

jinzin Senior Member

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
Why? Try not to make the answer massive.

In a nutshell, I simply don't feel that these characters are on the same level as the other people of the tiers they're being motioned into and have not performed the necessary displays of h2h feats to suggest otherwise, though I will admit Moonkight is a bit of a crap shoot so he's tougher to call.

Phantom Zone Junior Member

Originally posted by jinzin
In a nutshell, I simply don't feel that these characters are on the same level as the other people of the tiers they're being motioned into and have not performed the necessary displays of h2h feats to suggest otherwise, though I will admit Moonkight is a bit of a crap shoot so he's tougher to call.

There are people in the sceond tier that should be in first such as Black Panther and Midnight Sun. Hes beaten Bulleyes was getting the better of Black Widow and was stalemated Nomad for a page and a half.

Originally posted by Battlehammer
no gambit tried using his cards bulleye caught them and throw them back, gambit dodged them and ran bulleye caught up he wrecked him in h2h

True.

http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/838/fight244hl.gif
http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/94/fight254wy.gif
http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/3218/fight266ss.gif

Battlehammer Senior Member

Originally posted by Phantom Zone

True.
http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/838/fight244hl.gif
http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/94/fight254wy.gif
http://img267.imageshack.us/img267/3218/fight266ss.gif

thank you.

that just the fight I was talking about

Wild Shadow Restricted

wasnt gambit sleep deprived and physically exhausted from being hunted prior then bullseye showing up.

Warrior18 Keyboard Warrior

Originally posted by snoopdogg
How has he faired agaisnt top tiers who he didn't study?

Originally posted by Juk3n
Doesn't matter if he studied, it's not frikkin' supernatural, he did some home work and then proceeded to whoop some ass, Bullseye deserves to stay put.

jinzin Senior Member

Originally posted by Phantom Zone
There are people in the sceond tier that should be in first such as Black Panther and Midnight Sun. Hes beaten Bulleyes was getting the better of Black Widow and was stalemated Nomad for a page and a half.

Absolutely. I was shocked to see BP in the second tier to be honest. But this doesn't change how I feel about the remaining characters in the same tier.

jrodslam Senior Member

Originally posted by juggernaut74
Against Kingpin to 2nd.

Why so? Did you read my argument? Considering the people hes fought and beat compared to those in a tier higher and havent done as much as he in terms of h2h.

White Tiger and Red Skull. White Tiger whos a tier higher and someone who has hardly any fights/feats. Red Skull whos also a tier higher and someone who Fisk beat in a pure h2h confrontation.

Also, does Red Skull have the tracklist of skilled combatants hes fought and beat as Fisk? Just asking. I know for a fact that White Tiger doesnt.