Originally posted by SoljerIn all fairness, I was away. You can't expect this group of assclowns to handle something like that on their own.
I find it kind of hilarious how certain posters seem totally unable to detect a joke when it's staring them in the face....Oh, and for the record, for who ever is keeping track, my vote's for the Hulk to stay low Herald, Wonder Woman to be mid Herald.
And...errr...well, I don't think I played any stupid besides Hulk and Diana. 🙂.
Originally posted by batdude123
And people actually concerned themselves with what SHC thinks about us? Lawlz...KMC is about the best comic site you're liable to find on the internet. Even forums with legit comic writers I've found aren't as good. For one thing, the comic writers only concern themselves with the characters they write, and nothing outside of that.
In terms of overall poster knowledge, KMC is about the best.
I have been on all the main comic forums one time or another, and yes KMC is the best, it has its share of idiots like any site.
It just happens the few (Compared to the amount of not so smart) smart posters make it like that.
Anyway the Union change. 👆
Okay, like eight or so pages ago I moved that Rogue should be placed higher on the tier scale. And...I see it got ignored. I mean, I know that whoever made the tier list is probably busy, so I guess I can just post my reasoning for moving her up again...
Oh, and I also got Symmetric Chaos and nvrbeenwthagirl to agree with me. Go back to pg 164 is you don't believe me. So that counts as the 2 others required, right? 🙂
Reasoning:
- Has beaten about a dozen characters on higher tiers. Some she beats consistently, like Blob. Others include She-Hulk, Juggernaut, Mr. Fantastic, The Thing, and even Thor, etc...
- Currently has a death touch. Were in she is able to absorb the powers, memories, skills as well as kill her victim instantly all through skin-to-skin contact.
- Currently has permanetly absorbed Sunfire's powers. Who is a pretty powerful energy blaster.
So...hopefully she get's moved up. 😄
I think you need to differenciate between Original Power Leech Rogue, Ms. Marvel Rogue, Recall Rogue and Current Rogue because each in this case would be a different power level. Because you seem to be meshing her feats when each version of her character is at a different power level.
The list is based on power output and skills. Which is I guess the reason for Warpaths(A flying Class 75 Brick) position. And Reeds inclusion in High Meta.
As Classic Rogue she could just steal powers...her output was very low...say lower end of Low Meta.
As Ms. Marvel Rogue she was a flying brick just like Warpath who could steal powers. Ms. Marvel has energy projection and can amp her strength and durability up by absorbing energy which is more then what Ms. Marvel Rogue had going for her. I'd say Ms. Marvel Rogue is low end Mid Meta.
Recall Rogue had an insane amount of powers...I'm not sure where I'd place her...High Meta most probably.
Current Rogue has a Deathtouch and Sunfires Energy Projection. She has no super strength or durability though. In terms of output she hasn't done much with Shiros powers. Even though I would place Shiro as a High Meta. She doesn't have the feats to boost her to the High Meta IMO...similarly to how Glads is lower then Supes. And BrB is to Thor. What Rogue has demonstrated with Shiro's powers is lower then what Shiro has demonstrated. Their powers are supposed to be identical but lack of experience places her in High Mid Meta...she's in the same category as Ms. Marvel, Moonstone, Terra, Hellion, Crystal etc seems fair to IMO. So I vote against moving her up.
What about Monet St. Croix? Where do you guys think she falls on that list...I'd say Mid Meta as well.
Originally posted by llagrok
Not sure.Nobody seems to pay any attention to KM's Alpha Flight proposals.
Maybe Sodam Yat should be placed?
Thats cause no one knows anything about Alpha Flight. Pretty much, Mungi tells us where to place them, and we trust him.
As far as Sodam Yat. We could place him if you want, but he really doesn't have enough showings. All he's done is survive an explosion and rip through some nameless Sinestro Corps.